Customs valuation management: Requirements for improving customs valuation management comprehensively

VCN - Customs valuation management is a specific technical field of operation that plays a key role in the management of general and taxes for goods in particular. However, through implementation, the customs valuation management system has revealed a number of problems that must be studied and handled to further improve the efficiency of this work.
Customs officers of North Thang Long Industrial Park Customs Branch inspect import and export goods. Photo: N.Linh
Customs officers of North Thang Long Industrial Park Customs Branch inspect import and export goods. Photo: N.Linh

According to the evaluation of Import – Export Duty Department (General Department of Vietnam Customs), besides the advantages achieved in the implementation of customs valuation management, when comparing the current situation of this work with the model heading towards 2030, there is a huge gap. Therefore, the problem of how to effectively manage customs valuation ​​is being handled by Vietnam Customs step-by-step.

Distance from present to future

According to the assessment of the Import-Export Duty Department (GDVC), in order to reach an effective and efficient modern customs valuation management system, it is necessary to overall reform in five aspects: (1) regulations and career guideline; (2) organizational structure; (3) enforcement personnel; (4) professional information and sense of law compliance.

At the moment, each customs valuation management operation’s system of rules and guidelines is designed independently. The synchronization and coordination among solutions to manage valuation is still inadequate. In addition, the regulations on the content of customs valuation inspection in clearance are complicated and scattered in many documents, causing difficulties for both customs declarants and customs officers during the implementation process. For example, a lack of regulations on the content of customs valuation inspection after clearance and a lack of regulations on application of security/guarantee measures on customs valuation when carrying out customs procedures.

Before 2015, the use of securities in customs valuation was stipulated in Article 16 of Decree 40/2007/ND-CP, whereby the customs authority had a suspicion about the customs valuation, the declarant must pay sufficient security to secure the payment of tax for the entire shipment. However, during implementation, there was an opinion stating that the application of the securities had caused an increase of clearance costs of enterprises because the amount of the securities would increase the business expense.

Furthermore, due to no mechanism to determine the appropriate value of the security, some customs officers showed signs of abuse, causing difficulties for enterprises or conversely colluding with enterprises to determine that the security is not enough to offset the potential tax amount which can be arisen.

Since the Customs Law 2014 took effect, the provisions on securities for valuation are not mentioned in legal documents anymore. Since 2015, especially in the current period, in the context that information is shared more and more, risk analysis and assessment activities are increasingly implemented. Customs authorities have discovered more and more tricks of enterprises to defraud the customs valuation in order to evade taxes. There are many cases where enterprises intentionally avoid measures to recover tax debts after being imposed customs valuation.

Most of the Customs units attended the workshop to collect opinions on the draft scheme on Reform of Customs Valuation Management in the 2021-2030 period and said that it was urgent to apply measures to ensure the determination of customs valuation is selected, for businesses that have low legal compliance, high risk of tax evasion.

According to representatives of local Customs units, there are currently many existing problems, such as consulting on customs valuation ​​in clearance, which both causes difficulties for customs officers and increases sub-procedures while carrying out clearance procedure and reduce the efficiency of tax administration. Furthermore, the customs valuation inspection is mainly focused on checking the formal contents of the valuation dossier, which has not to inspect the actual value of the goods at the time of import and export; the customs valuation determination of Customs officers has not been clearly guided, leading to a situation of arbitrarily determining prices and not complying with regulations.

Giving opinions at the Workshop to collect opinions on the draft scheme on Reform of Customs Valuation Management in the 2021-2030 period, Mr. Vu Ngoc Anh, Trade Facilitation Project Specialist sponsored by USAID, said to implement customs valuation management in the direction of reducing inspection in customs clearance and focusing on post-clearance audit, the current apparatus of customs valuation management must undergo a fundamental change; arrange and use human resources effectively, take advantage of high-quality resources; have appropriate programs and plans for training human resources; and the rotation, arrangement and use of customs officers specialized in valuation management must also be closely monitored.

In human resources, according to a representative of the Personnel and Organization Department (GDVC), the contingent of customs officers working in the field of customs valuation management needs to be built and enhanced capacity in order to meet new requirements. In particular, it is necessary to build a team of valuation experts at the General Department and Customs Departments themselves. This team is the "machines" involved in the development and completion of professional operation manuals, handling valuation problems arising on a daily working, and conducting on-the-job training and program-based training for customs officers in charge of valuation.

In terms of limited resources, with the challenge of the massive workload and increasingly sophisticated fraud tricks, the principles and techniques of risk management are applied to evaluate the subject of management, select the key inspection subject are the “answer” to the customs authority, the representative of the Risk Management Department (GDVC) said.

In fact, risk management in valuation management has been researched and applied since 2011. However, the level of application and effectiveness achieved in different stages of valuation management are also very different. If in customs clearance, the development and use of the list of risky goods in valuation is a guide for customs officers to select customs declarations that must check the value, the use of a specific reference price for a specific item leads to not creating conditions to control the price of the same item, which is easy to become obsolete because the price is always fluctuating. If there is a provision in the Customs Law on post-clearance audit following signs of risk, the process of establishing enterprises with signs of risk in terms of customs valuation is still lacking.

In addition, according to the Hanoi Customs Department, valuation management is heavily dependent on the GTT02 system. Information and other data in service of customs valuation management (such as information on handling of administrative violations of valuation, verification information of valuation, and information on import-export businesses) are not linked to GTT02, so many customs officers in charge of valuation management are not allowed to access and use.

After a period of operation, GTT02 has also revealed many other limitations such as frequent appear information synchronization errors from VNACCS/VCIS; there are not many utilities in looking up and reporting; and there is no warning, feedback, information processing functions. Furthermore, to speed up information processing to meet digital customs requirements, it is necessary to standardize some information such as information about goods' names, units of calculation, information verified through post-clearance audit, inspection and investigation. Furthermore, to serve for digitizing and electronicizing documents for price consultation, it is necessary to develop a centralized IT system, connecting all professional stages.

For the sense of law compliance, on the side of the Customs sector, even from customs officers, there are many people who have a mindset of valuation management which follows the "minimum price list" and do not put efforts into research, so it often occurs the situation of imposing valuation without legal basis.

Regarding to import-export enterprises, they often "neglect" the determination and declaration of customs valuation for customs brokers, leading to the situation that when arising valuation consultation activity, the customs declarant did not provide enough evidence to prove the declared value, meaning it was rejected by the customs authority and imposed an unreasonable price, arising complaints, lawsuits and frustrations of enterprises with the customs authority. As for other state management agencies involved in supporting the provision of information to the Customs to improve the efficiency of customs valuation management, these agencies either do not know or do not ready to connect and share information with Customs authority.

Need a long-term solution

To improve the effectiveness of customs valuation management, according to the Import-Export Duty Department, the Customs sector must conduct reform and improvement activities in the overall management system. Accordingly, the system of legal documents and business processes will be reformed; improving the management apparatus, building a force of professional, qualified and experienced customs officers; strengthening the connection, sharing and collection of information with state management agencies; and thoroughly applying risk management techniques and increase "communication", "dialogue" with the business community in order to improve the sense of voluntary compliance with the law of import-export enterprises.

Regarding the system of regulations and processes, the GDVC has set a goal from now to 2025 to amend the legal basis system, simplify administrative procedures, and facilitate customs declarants. In particular, they will study and propose amendments and supplements to the provisions of the Customs Law to ensure the obligations of enterprises before clearing goods; strengthen the exchange of information and data between the Customs and other state management agencies such as the Public Security, commercial management agencies, banks, insurance and transportation.

By 2025, the Customs authority will study and build a 3-level customs apparatus towards streamlining, reducing intermediaries, not overlapping in functions and tasks, ensuring effective operation in order to meet the management requirements following the centralized and smart customs operation model and establishing centers for handling problems and determining customs valuation. Customs sets out a plan to develop a contingent of customs officers at all levels with professional qualifications, integrity operations, professional working style, mastering modern technology and equipment, sufficient quantity, an appropriate structure associated with the practical needs of the job position the capacity of each individual, meeting the modern customs management model. Researching and applying modern training methods and advanced technologies in training and fostering professional skills for customs officers in order to improve training capacity.

In particular, in the effective use of human resources, the Customs authority strives to complete the rotation model for training and retraining among organizational levels, between departments, in each professional field and among professional fields in order to improve professional qualifications, problem-solving capacity, and practical experience for customs officers and leaders.

By 2030, in the process of researching, building and implementing Digital Customs, Smart Customs, and the customs valuation management module will be designed in the direction of thoroughly applying digital technology and artificial intelligence to enhance an effective step of applying risk management in customs valuation management.

According to a representative of the Import-Export Duty Department, in the immediate period, Customs authorities will further promote information exchanges within the industry and with agencies outside the industry, especially the domestic tax authorities, so that customs officers working in the field of valuation management are provided information serving for task performance. The exchange and connection of electronic information in this period will serve as the foundation for information connection and sharing in terms of Digital Customs and Smart Customs.

The Customs authority will also develop a system of specific criteria and indicators for the system to automatically select the customs declaration to check the valuation and customs declaration to check the value in the stage of post clearance audit and the enterprise must check the customs valuation after clearance. This set of risk management criteria and indicators will help reduce the pressure of inspection work of customs officers, increase the key post clearance audit for customs valuation, improve the rate of detecting violations, preventing loss of revenue for the state budget.

By Nụ Bùi/Thanh Thuy

Related News

Vietnam Customs directs to follow the progress of aviation projects closely

Vietnam Customs directs to follow the progress of aviation projects closely

VCN - The General Department of Vietnam Customs directed the customs departments including Hanoi, Hai Phong, Da Nang, Dong Nai to establish a Working Group to regularly discuss and work with the Project Management Board to grasp the situation and implementation progress of project on building and expanding passenger and cargo terminals at international airports.
The General Department of Vietnam Customs strives to promote import and export growth

The General Department of Vietnam Customs strives to promote import and export growth

VCN - On April 15, the General Department of Vietnam Customs held an online briefing conference to evaluate the results of the first quarter of work and deploy the work program for the second quarter of 2024. According to the authorization of the Director General, Deputy Director General Nguyen Van Tho chaired the conference.
General Department of Vietnam Customs listens and answers problems for FDI enterprises

General Department of Vietnam Customs listens and answers problems for FDI enterprises

VCN - On February 28, General Department of Vietnam Customs held a regular meeting with the Vietnam Business Forum (VBF) Alliance.
Spending over US$11 billion to import one group of commodities in less than two months

Spending over US$11 billion to import one group of commodities in less than two months

VCN - By the end of February, Vietnam had spent US$11.34 billion to import computers, electronic products and components.

Latest News

Vietnam Customs affirms its role in the international customs community

Vietnam Customs affirms its role in the international customs community

VCN - Vietnam Customs has recently promoted cooperation and international integration in the customs field, bringing out many practical results and contributing to affirming the role and position of Vietnam Customs in international forums.
Resolve arising problems to effectively implement ASEAN Single Window

Resolve arising problems to effectively implement ASEAN Single Window

VCN - The implementation of the National Single Window is one of the important contents to ensure the successful deployment of Digital Customs. So what are solutions to effectively execute the ASEAN Single Window for the implementation of Digital Customs?
It is necessary to develop separate software for Program of Enterprises complying with Customs Law

It is necessary to develop separate software for Program of Enterprises complying with Customs Law

VCN - With over 50,000 businesses completing import and export procedures through Ho Chi Minh City ports, Ho Chi Minh City Customs Department has implemented many solutions to encourage businesses to participate in the Pilot Program to support and encourage businesses to voluntarily comply with customs laws. Deputy Director of Ho Chi Minh City Customs Department Do Thanh Quang shared about these solutions.
The Customs agency has a variety of solutions to support businesses

The Customs agency has a variety of solutions to support businesses

VCN - That is the assessment of Mr. Kwon Yeong Min, Chairman of Hyundai Thanh Cong Vietnam Automobile Manufacturing Company on solutions to support and facilitate import and export activities of enterprises of the Customs agency in general and Ha Nam Ninh Customs Department in particular.

More News

Binh Dinh Customs: Set a goal to upgrade administrative reform

Binh Dinh Customs: Set a goal to upgrade administrative reform

VCN - Setting the goal of upgrading administrative reform, in 2024, Binh Dinh Customs Department has drastically implemented many solutions to create leverage to support businesses and facilitate trade.
The first exam for certificates of training in customs in 2024 is going to take place

The first exam for certificates of training in customs in 2024 is going to take place

VCN - It is expected that from June 5-7, the Council of Examination for Certificates of Training in Customs 2024 (referred to as Examination Council) will organize the examination for certificates of training in customs 2024 at Vietnam Customs School.
Establishing a board of project implementation on building an IT system to implement digital customs

Establishing a board of project implementation on building an IT system to implement digital customs

VCN - The Board of project implementation on building an IT system to implement digital customs is led by Deputy Director General Vietnam Customs Luu Manh Tuong.
Ha Nam Ninh Customs Department promotes dialogue and removes difficulties for enterprises

Ha Nam Ninh Customs Department promotes dialogue and removes difficulties for enterprises

VCN – On May 10, Ha Nam Ninh Customs Department Customs- Business dialogue conference with more 130 processing enterprises in three provinces of Ha Nam, Nam Dinh and Ninh Binh to remove difficulties in implementing Customs policies and regulations.
Deputy Director General Nguyen Van Tho works with FedEx leader

Deputy Director General Nguyen Van Tho works with FedEx leader

VCN – On May 10, Deputy Director General of the General Department of Vietnam Customs (GDVC) Nguyen Van Tho had a meeting with the delegation of FedEx Express Delivery Company, led by Mr. Choo Pin Ang, Executive Director of AMEA Government Affairs .
Customs revenue rises thanks to 3 imported groups

Customs revenue rises thanks to 3 imported groups

VCN - The economy in the first four months of 2024 is showing positive signs when import-export activities recover strongly, pushing up the trade turnover. In particular, both exports and imports recorded strong growth in many groups, contributing significantly to the revenue results of the Customs sector.
Quang Ninh Customs promotes development of Customs broker

Quang Ninh Customs promotes development of Customs broker

VCN - Operation of Customs broker in Quang Ninh province have not achieved the expected goals. Therefore, the development of customs brokers in a modern, professional and reliable manner is an urgent requirement.
Customs deploys 132 full-online public services

Customs deploys 132 full-online public services

VNC - Of the 214 administrative procedures carried out by the Customs agency, there are 132 full-online public services.
Post-Customs Clearance Audit Department contributes 90% of entire customs sector’s revenue

Post-Customs Clearance Audit Department contributes 90% of entire customs sector’s revenue

VCN - As of April, the Post-Customs Clearance Audit Department alone contributed 90% of the entire Customs sector’s revenue.
Read More

Your care

Latest Most read
Vietnam Customs affirms its role in the international customs community

Vietnam Customs affirms its role in the international customs community

Vietnam Customs has recently promoted cooperation and international integration in the customs field, bringing out many practical results and contributing to affirming the role and position of Vietnam Customs in international forums.
Resolve arising problems to effectively implement ASEAN Single Window

Resolve arising problems to effectively implement ASEAN Single Window

VCN - According to the Customs Information Technology and Statistics Department (under the General Department of Vietnam Customs), during implementing the ASEAN Single Window (including implementing the National Single Window) has emerged some problems th
It is necessary to develop separate software for Program of Enterprises complying with Customs Law

It is necessary to develop separate software for Program of Enterprises complying with Customs Law

VCN - With over 50,000 businesses completing import and export procedures through Ho Chi Minh City ports, Ho Chi Minh City Customs Department has implemented many solutions to encourage businesses to participate in the Pilot Program to support and encoura
The Customs agency has a variety of solutions to support businesses

The Customs agency has a variety of solutions to support businesses

That is the assessment of Mr. Kwon Yeong Min, Chairman of Hyundai Thanh Cong Vietnam Automobile Manufacturing Company on solutions to facilitate import and export activities of the Customs agency
Binh Dinh Customs: Set a goal to upgrade administrative reform

Binh Dinh Customs: Set a goal to upgrade administrative reform

VCN - Having just completed customs procedures to export a shipment of wooden furniture to the US through Quy Nhon port, Mr. Nguyen Van Muoi, Gia Han Interior and Exterior Co., Ltd. shared that the current customs procedures are very fast and convenient.
Mobile Version