Solutions to prevent or fraud of origin and geographical indication violations

VCN - The Customs Magazine recently interviewed Nguyen Van Hoan, Deputy Director of the Anti-Smuggling and Investigation Department (General Department of Vietnam Customs), to discuss solutions for combating tax evasion, fraud of origin and geographical indication violations in the coming period.
Nguyen Van Hoan, Deputy Director of the Anti-Smuggling and Investigation Department (General Department of Vietnam Customs)
Mr. Nguyen Van Hoan, Deputy Director of the Anti-Smuggling and Investigation Department (General Department of Vietnam Customs)

Could you share the measures that Customs has implemented and will continue to apply to combat tax evasion, fraud of origin and geographical indication violations?

-To effectively address acts of tax evasion and counterfeit origin claims while ensuring minimal disruption to business operations, Customs will focus on the following measures:

Continuously analyze data and compile lists of key commodities and entities with abnormal export turnover increases. This includes identifying high-risk goods for origin fraud and assigning specialized units, the Anti-Smuggling and Investigation Department, and local customs departments to conduct investigations and verify violations.

Strengthen the collection and analysis of risk data, identifying high-risk enterprises for post-clearance audits, particularly focusing on origin fraud inspections.

Continue implementing plans to combat origin fraud and illegal transshipment based on assigned tasks. Actively promote negotiations with the United States on specific cooperation initiatives related to combating origin fraud and illegal transshipment to effectively enforce the Customs Mutual Assistance Agreement between Vietnam and the U.S.

Clarify the areas of collaboration between Vietnam and the U.S., including requests for information, investigations, and verifications from both sides.

Collaborate with the Ministry of Industry and Trade, the Ministry of Science and Technology, the Vietnam Chamber of Commerce and Industry (VCCI), and industry associations to identify high-risk enterprises and those with indications of fraud, origin misrepresentation, improper labeling, intellectual property violations, or illegal transshipment. Appropriate measures will be applied to address these issues.

Another critical solution is improving the legal framework.

There are challenges regarding tax evasion prosecution. Could you elaborate on these difficulties?

-Currently, the investigative authority of Customs under criminal procedure law is limited. The 2015 Penal Code (amended in 2017) grants Customs investigative authority only for three offenses: “Smuggling” (Article 188), “Illegal transportation of goods or currency across borders” (Article 189), and “Manufacturing and trading prohibited goods” (Article 190).

For tax evasion cases, Customs authority must transfer the matter to investigative agencies, which entails lengthy administrative procedures and delays in timely detection and prosecution.

Therefore, it is necessary to expand Customs' authority to initiate and investigate tax evasion cases under Article 200 of the Penal Code.

According to guidance from Official Dispatch No. 196/TATC-PC issued on October 3, 2023, by the Supreme People’s Court, the object of tax evasion involves harming state tax management across various fields, specifically causing state budget losses due to unpaid taxes. The object of smuggling, on the other hand, pertains to violations of the management order of the export and import of goods, currency, precious metals, precious stones...

In this case, although the customs declaration process complied with legal requirements during importation, the goods remained under customs supervision as stipulated in Article 51(1) of the 2014 Customs Law. During this period, the Tax Authority did not yet oversee the goods.

However, the defendant’s decision to forgo production for export and instead divert the goods for domestic consumption without completing customs procedures constitutes a violation of customs regulations. This breach is specified in Article 25(5) of Consolidated Decree No. 24/VBHN-BTC (dated July 11, 2018) and points b and c of Article 21(1) of Consolidated Circular No. 25/VBHN-BTC (dated September 6, 2018).

Such actions qualify as “Smuggling,” as defined under Article 188 of the 2015 Penal Code (amended in 2017).

Yet, according to Article 200(1)(i) of the Penal Code, the act of “using goods subject to tax exemption, tax-free status, or tax reduction for purposes not prescribed without declaring the change in use to tax authorities” is classified as tax evasion. Unlike clauses e, g, and h in the same article, this clause does not exclude acts covered under Articles 188 and 189.

The Tax Administration Law explicitly designates customs authorities as tax administrators. While Article 188 broadly defines smuggling as “illegal trade,” leaving specific acts undefined, it carries harsher penalties compared to tax evasion under Article 200, which delineates clear behaviors and lighter punishments.

Under the principle of leniency for offenders, legal provisions that define specific acts and prescribe lighter penalties should be applied. Therefore, cases where individuals misuse tax-exempt, tax-free, or tax-reduced goods for unintended purposes without declaring the change in use to Customs should be prosecuted as tax evasion.

To avoid differing interpretations and overlapping offenses, it is essential to amend Article 200(1)(i) of the Penal Code to read: “Using goods subject to tax exemption, tax-free status, or tax reduction for purposes not prescribed without declaring the change in use to tax authorities, unless the act falls under Articles 188 or 189 of this Code.”

Thank you for your insights!

By Thái Bình/Thanh Thuy

Related News

An Giang Customs Department escalates multiple tax fraud cases to law enforcement

An Giang Customs Department escalates multiple tax fraud cases to law enforcement

VCN - Many cases of customs law violations and tax fraud discovered by An Giang Customs Department have been transferred to the police for investigation according to their authority.
Customs crackdown nets 1,430 violations in first month

Customs crackdown nets 1,430 violations in first month

VCN - In January 2025, the number of violations detected, seized, and processed by customs authorities increased by 9.6%, and the value of the illicit goods involved increased by 19.4% compared to the same period in 2024.
Vietnam Customs forms implementation task force on developing customs procedures

Vietnam Customs forms implementation task force on developing customs procedures

VCN - Decision 135/QD-TCHQ, recently issued by the General Department of Vietnam Customs, establishes a task force to develop and implement new customs procedures. The task force will be headed by Deputy Director General Au Anh Tuan.
Best covers of Vietnam Customs songs: 15 winners revealed

Best covers of Vietnam Customs songs: 15 winners revealed

VCN - The Vietnam Customs Youth Union has just officially revealed the 15 victorious pieces in the "Cover Songs about Vietnam Customs 2024" contest. These 15 prizes are divided into various categories, totaling approximately 100 million Vietnamese Dong in prize money

Latest News

Customs administrations coordinate to seize nearly 20,000 endangered wildlife

Customs administrations coordinate to seize nearly 20,000 endangered wildlife

VCN – About 20,000 live animals, all endangered or protected species, have been seized in a global operation against wildlife and forestry trafficking networks, jointly coordinated by the World Customs Organization (WCO) and INTERPOL.
An Giang Customs strictly controls goods moving across the border

An Giang Customs strictly controls goods moving across the border

VCN- An Giang Customs Department implements imports and exports smoothly, strictly controls smuggling and illegal transportation of goods across the border, and arrests cases.
Remodel cars to hide drugs

Remodel cars to hide drugs

VCN – Criminals have hiden drugs inside people, vehicles and goods, especially using the method of transporting consigned goods, causing difficulties for the Customs in inspection and control.
Illegal transportation of gemstones by air to handled

Illegal transportation of gemstones by air to handled

VCN – If the luggage of people on exit or entry exceeds the duty-free baggage allowance gone through the customs control area without declaring to customs are considered illegal exports and imports and will be handled under the provisions of law.

More News

Routine security screening uncovers hidden weapons at point of entry

Routine security screening uncovers hidden weapons at point of entry

VCN - During routine X-ray screenings and inspections, the La Lay Border Gate Customs Branch (Quang Tri Customs Department) collaborated with other agencies to apprehend an individual attempting to smuggle two military-grade firearms and 92 rounds of ammunition across the border.
Strictly handling illegal transportation of gemstones by air

Strictly handling illegal transportation of gemstones by air

VCN – Any commodity carried by inbound, outbound persons which exceeds the duty-free limit but still goes through the customs checkpoint without completing the customs declaration shall be considered as illegal imports or exports and shall be handled in accordance with the laws.
Nearly 18,000 cases of smuggling, trade fraud and counterfeit goods detected

Nearly 18,000 cases of smuggling, trade fraud and counterfeit goods detected

The total estimated value of confiscated goods exceeded VNĐ31.35 trillion (US$1.23 billion), marking a 12.5 per cent increase in cases and a 151.3 per cent surge in the value compared to the previous year.
Customs seizes smuggled goods and infringing products worth VND31,000 billion

Customs seizes smuggled goods and infringing products worth VND31,000 billion

VCN – Smugglers have taken advantage business models on e-commerce platforms, social networks, and postal and express delivery activities to use sophisticated tricks for smuggling and trafficking counterfeit goods.
India launches anti-dumping investigation on nylon yarn imports from Việt Nam

India launches anti-dumping investigation on nylon yarn imports from Việt Nam

The Trade Remedies Authority of Việt Nam recommends businesses involved in the production of the goods carefully review the investigation notice and comply with Indian authorities.
Hanoi Customs: 92% of post-clearance audits reveal violations

Hanoi Customs: 92% of post-clearance audits reveal violations

VCN - According to Hanoi Customs, this year’s post-clearance audit plans focus on high-risk areas with signs of violations.
Noi Bai International Border Gate Customs Sub-department: "Blocking" drugs via air

Noi Bai International Border Gate Customs Sub-department: "Blocking" drugs via air

VCN - Along with the recovery and growth of passenger and cargo flights, illegal drug transportation by air is on the rise with increasingly sophisticated and complex tricks and constantly changing methods of operation to deceive Customs and other authorities.
Drug Crime Investigation Police Force cracks down on nearly 29,000 cases

Drug Crime Investigation Police Force cracks down on nearly 29,000 cases

VCN - This is the result of the fight against drug crimes, recently reported by the Department of Drug Crime Investigation (C04, Ministry of Public Security).
Hai Phong Customs busts illegal import of 600 m3 of precious wood

Hai Phong Customs busts illegal import of 600 m3 of precious wood

VCN – About 600 m3 of illegally imported African teak wood, with an estimated total value of tens of billions of VND, has been seized by Hai Phong Customs Department.
Read More

Your care

Latest Most read
An Giang Customs Department escalates multiple tax fraud cases to law enforcement

An Giang Customs Department escalates multiple tax fraud cases to law enforcement

Many cases of customs law violations and tax fraud discovered by An Giang Customs Department have been transferred to the police for investigation according to their authority.
Customs crackdown nets 1,430 violations in first month

Customs crackdown nets 1,430 violations in first month

In January 2025, the number of violations detected, seized, and processed by customs authorities increased by 9.6%, and the value of the illicit goods involved increased by 19.4%
Customs administrations coordinate to seize nearly 20,000 endangered wildlife

Customs administrations coordinate to seize nearly 20,000 endangered wildlife

VCN - According to the WCO, the General Department of Vietnam Customs, Operation Thunder 2024 aims to combat criminal networks involved in illegal trafficking of wildlife and forestry products.
An Giang Customs strictly controls goods moving across the border

An Giang Customs strictly controls goods moving across the border

VCN - According to An Giang Customs Department, during the Lunar New Year holiday, the department has arranged leaders, civil servants and employees to work and effectively handled all arising situations and smoothly processed customs procedures, and prev
Remodel cars to hide drugs

Remodel cars to hide drugs

VCN - Through the fight against drugs, Quang Tri Customs Enforcement force recognized that the drug-related crimes have taken place sophicicatedly.
Mobile Version