55% of FDI enterprises report losses but increase in revenue

VCN- FDI enterprises have made a great contribution to the State budget. However, the number of FDI enterprises reporting accumulated losses still increases. Transfer pricing and tax evasion still exists in the FDI sector.
Profitable FDI enterprises account for small proportion while many enterprises suffer from large and continuous losses for years Profitable FDI enterprises account for small proportion while many enterprises suffer from large and continuous losses for years
Tax evasion questions raised as 55% of FDI enterprises report losses Tax evasion questions raised as 55% of FDI enterprises report losses
2341-3224-10-12
Transfer pricing and tax evasion still incurs in some FDI enterprises

Transfer pricing and tax evasion still incurs in some FDI enterprises

According to areport of the Ministry of Finance on the production and business of FDI enterprises in 2019, industries that achieved good profit margins include: manufacturing and assembling cars, motorcycles and other motor vehicles; food processing industry; wine, beer, soft drinks; business support services; distribution and motorcycle maintenance; and health, education, training, science and technology. Profit before tax of 22,603 ​​FDI enterprises reached more than VND 387,000 billion, up more than VND 29,000 billion year-on-year.Profit after tax was more than VND 324,000 billion, a rise of more than VND 19,000 billion year on year.

Also, the Ministry of Finance reported FDI enterprises play a more important role in contributing to the country's socio-economic development and increasing their contribution to the State budget, showing in the contributions to the State budget and import and export revenue that havesteadily increased over the years.

The revenue growth rate of the FDI sector to the State budget in 2019 was higher than that of the two prior years. In 2019, the revenue contributed by the FDI sector was more than VND 210,200 billion, up 13% year-on-year. In this report, the Ministry of Finance assessed although the growth of revenue, assets and investment capital of the owner was lower than that of previous years, it still remained at a high level, showing the performance of FDI enterprises still maintains a stable growth rate.

However, according to the Ministry of Finance, efficiency in using assets and investment capital in FDI enterprises is still low, has not fully utilised their potentials, and the budget payment is not commensurate with incentives given to them. Besides, transfer pricing and tax evasion still occurs in some FDI enterprises. They always report losses, or even continuous losses for many years, but still expand production and business and their revenues kept increasing years, causing losses in State revenue.

The number of profitable FDI enterprises accounts for a small proportion atonly 45% while many enterprises suffer large losses for many years. 12,455 enterprises reported losses, accounting for 55% although their revenue reached VND 847,000 billion, up 12.7% year-on-year and the total assets decreased by 0.7% year-on-year. There were 3,545 enterprises losing capital in 2019, accounting for nearly 15.7%, but of these, 2,160 enterprises saw an increase in revenue.

In addition to large projects with high economic efficiency and good budget contributions, there were many projects with low efficiency and low levels of budget contribution. For example, in 2019, the total revenue of the two big companies that are Hung Nghiep Formosa Ha Tinh Iron and Steel Co., Ltd and Posco Yamoto Vina Steel Joint Stock Company, increased from VND 77,456 billion to VND 82,741 billion, but their budget payments decreased from VND 101 billion to VND 92.6 billion.

According to the Ministry of Finance, the payment to the State budget is not commensurate with incentives (land andtaxes) given to these large firms. The ministry also proposed the Prime Minister assign it to continue directing the General Department of Taxation and local tax departments to strengthen inspection and examination for FDI enterprises showing signs of transfer pricing.

There should be a specialised unit for anti- transfer pricing

A resolution of the Politburo on the orientations for completing institutions and policies, improving the quality and efficiency of foreign investment cooperation by 2030 saysthe phenomenon of transfer pricing andunder-investment is increasingly sophisticated and tends to increase. To remove this situation, the resolution specifies it is necessary to study and develop regulations to overcome the “thin capital” and transfer pricing; complete the legal basis on anti- transfer pricing towards becoming the law. At the same time, complete and supplement strict regulations fortax, foreign exchange, customs, investment, science and technology, database building andinformation disclosure to control, manage and prevent transfer pricing right from the establishment and during the operation of FDI enterprises. To build a strong and capable specialised apparatus; the interdisciplinary and specialised inspection mechanism to prevent and limit the transfer pricing of foreign-invested firms.

According to economist Nguyen Minh Phong, based on the legal regulations fortax inspection and examination for enterprises, competent authorities should conduct an inspection and examination for FDI enterprises with signs of transfer pricing andtax evasion to promptly detect and prevent this situation.

Many experts also support the need to have a specialised unit in charge of anti-transfer pricing inspection and control, known as a “special force for anti-transfer pricing” instead of performing concurrent tasks. However, up to now, there has beenno implementation of solutions related to the development of the law on anti-transfer pricing or the establishment of a specialised unit in charge of anti-transfer pricing. Therefore, it is necessary to consider this issue seriously and soon establish this specialised unit to limit transfer pricing.

Regarding the issue of attracting FDI, recently, the Minister of Planning and Investment Nguyen Chi Dung said in 2021, there would be a review of FDI firmsin the direction of classifying and assessing legal compliance, especially environmental protection and anti-transfer pricing; carefully considering steel, thermal, and aluminum projects. Reviewing priorities and incentives for FDI firms, especially for the enterprises that are low-tech, space-consuming, high energy-consuming, environmental risks and lack a plan to operate long term in Vietnam; changing preferential policies, focusing only on high-tech enterprises with technology transfer and association with domestic companies.
By Hoai Anh/Ngoc Loan

Related News

Fiscal policy needs to return to normal state in new period

Fiscal policy needs to return to normal state in new period

VCN - To recover the economy during and after the Covid-19 pandemic, fiscal policy has been flexibly and promptly managed, becoming a solid foundation to help businesses and the economy gradually overcome difficulties. After nearly 5 years, although there are still difficulties, the economy is gradually returning to a high growth trajectory. In that context, it is necessary to let fiscal policy return to normal state.
State-owned commercial banking sector performs optimistic growth, but more capital in need

State-owned commercial banking sector performs optimistic growth, but more capital in need

VCN - According to the report sent to the National Assembly before the 8th Session of the Government on investment, management and use of state capital in enterprises nationwide in 2023, the business performance of the state-owned commercial banking sector achieved positive growth.
Ba Ria-Vung Tau Customs cultivates a stronger relationship with enterprises

Ba Ria-Vung Tau Customs cultivates a stronger relationship with enterprises

VCN - Ba Ria - Vung Tau Customs Department held a conference to review the development of Customs - Business partnership.
Tax sector determines to take enterprises as the center of service

Tax sector determines to take enterprises as the center of service

VCN - That was the affirmation of Deputy General Director of the General Department of Taxation Mai Son at the Tax - Customs forum in 2024 organized by Vietnam Financial Times on the afternoon of October 16, 2024.

Latest News

Import and export are expected to reach 800 billion USD

Import and export are expected to reach 800 billion USD

VCN - Although the import and export turnover of goods slowed down in September 2024, in general, import and export activities, especially exports, still grew positively in the first 9 months of 2024. It is expected that import and export of goods in 2024 will reach a record of 800 billion USD.
Fresh coconuts quenching new overseas markets

Fresh coconuts quenching new overseas markets

Vietnam’s fresh coconuts are being increasingly consumed in international markets such as the US, China, and the UK, highlighting a bright spot in Vietnam's fruit export sector with many opportunities for breakthroughs in the near future.
Rice exports likely to set new record in 2024

Rice exports likely to set new record in 2024

Vietnam sold 800,000 tonnes of rice overseas for 505 million USD in October, bringing the country's total export volume and value in the first ten months to nearly 7.8 million tonnes and 4.86 billion USD, up 10.2% and 23.4% year-on-year, respectively.
Vietnamese goods conquer halal market through trust and quality

Vietnamese goods conquer halal market through trust and quality

VCN - According to the Ministry of Agriculture and Rural Development, Vietnam's capacity to export over 50 billion USD worth of agricultural products annually, coupled with established supply chains, provides a significant advantage for Vietnamese agricultural and aquatic products to penetrate the Halal market.

More News

Exporters urged to have strategies to take advantage of UKVFTA for expansion

Exporters urged to have strategies to take advantage of UKVFTA for expansion

The UK is concerned by sustainable development, labour issues, environmental protection and social responsibility. Therefore, when exporting to the UK, enterprises should not just be concerned about being competitive in terms of price and quality.
Fresh coconuts quenching new overseas markets

Fresh coconuts quenching new overseas markets

Vietnam’s fresh coconuts are being increasingly consumed in international markets such as the US, China, and the UK, highlighting a bright spot in Vietnam's fruit export sector with many opportunities for breakthroughs in the near future.
Vietnam and UAE trade sees billion-dollar growth

Vietnam and UAE trade sees billion-dollar growth

VCN - According to General Department of Vietnam Customs by the end of September 2024, bilateral trade between Vietnam and the United Arab Emirates (UAE) reached nearly US$5 billion, an increase of more than US$1.4 billion over the same period last year.
Sharing responsibility for ensuring security and safety of the supply chain

Sharing responsibility for ensuring security and safety of the supply chain

VCN – Post - clearance audit is carried out in a planned, focused and key manner, avoiding widespread and ineffective inspections, thereby creating convenience for the business community and improving the effectiveness of state management of customs.
Many factors affecting tuna exports in the last months of the year

Many factors affecting tuna exports in the last months of the year

VCN - Tensions between Israel and Iran escalate, tuna businesses are worried, they may have to stop export orders to the Israeli market in the last months of the year.
Vietnam still dominates Philippine rice import

Vietnam still dominates Philippine rice import

Vietnam continues to assert its dominance as the top rice exporter to the Philippines, with 2.91 million tonnes shipped as of the late October, or over 79% of the Philippines' total rice imports, according to the Vietnam Trade Office in the Philippines.
Vietnam cements ties with partners to engage in global semiconductor, AI industries

Vietnam cements ties with partners to engage in global semiconductor, AI industries

By boosting cooperation with reputable partners across the globe, Vietnam is taking steps to gain a foothold in the world’s semiconductor and artificial intelligence (AI) industries.
Aquatic exports expected to rise in year-end despite challenges

Aquatic exports expected to rise in year-end despite challenges

Aquatic exports is expected to surge in the remaining months of this year, as the year-end festive season comes, despite many challenges in the international markets, according to insiders.
Trade Defense: The Key to Success for Vietnamese Businesses

Trade Defense: The Key to Success for Vietnamese Businesses

VCN - From losses and near bankruptcy, many domestic enterprises have recovered thanks to timely application of trade defense measures. Trade defense is also an effective shield for Vietnamese enterprises against a series of lawsuits from importing countries, thereby maintaining advantages and developing on "away grounds".
Read More

Your care

Latest Most read
Import and export are expected to reach 800 billion USD

Import and export are expected to reach 800 billion USD

VCN - At the regular Government meeting in September 2024, Minister of Industry and Trade Nguyen Hong Dien assessed: import and export continued to be a bright spot, recording a positive recovery compared to the same period last year.
Fresh coconuts quenching new overseas markets

Fresh coconuts quenching new overseas markets

Vietnam’s fresh coconuts are being increasingly consumed in international markets such as the US, China, and the UK, highlighting a bright spot in Vietnam's fruit export sector with many opportunities for breakthroughs in the near future.
Rice exports likely to set new record in 2024

Rice exports likely to set new record in 2024

Vietnam sold 800,000 tonnes of rice overseas for 505 million USD in October, bringing the country's total export volume and value in the first ten months to nearly 7.8 million tonnes and 4.86 billion USD, up 10.2% and 23.4% year-on-year, respectively.
Vietnamese goods conquer halal market through trust and quality

Vietnamese goods conquer halal market through trust and quality

According to the Ministry of Agriculture and Rural Development, Vietnamese agricultural and aquatic products could penetrate the Halal market.
Exporters urged to have strategies to take advantage of UKVFTA for expansion

Exporters urged to have strategies to take advantage of UKVFTA for expansion

The UK is concerned by sustainable development, labour issues, environmental protection and social responsibility. Therefore, when exporting to the UK, enterprises should not just be concerned about being competitive in terms of price and quality.
Mobile Version