VAT reduction is necessary but not tool used every recession: Canadian expert

VCN – The VAT reduction is necessary but is not a tool used in every recession said by the expert from the Canadian Ministry of Finance at the discussion session on fiscal policy within the framework of the Financial Policy Dialogue Workshop between the Vietnamese Ministry of Finance and the Canadian Ministry of Finance in 2024, held on September 25.
Customs implements VAT reduction policy from July 1st Customs implements VAT reduction policy from July 1st
Proposal on VAT reduction in electricity bills unreasonable Proposal on VAT reduction in electricity bills unreasonable
VAT reduction is necessary but not tool used every recession: Canadian expert
The discussion session at Ministry of Finance’s headquarters.

The main topic of the dialogue session focused on fiscal policy, including two main contents: sharing on fiscal policy management and state revenue forecasting models; sharing experiences on the fiscal risk management framework.

Exchanging Canada's experience in fiscal policy planning and tools to develop and adjust these policies, especially in the context of the Covid-19 pandemic and the complex international economic situation, Mr. Nelson, an expert from the Canadian Ministry of Finance, said that before the pandemic, Canada had developed fiscal policy packages suitable for recession scenarios. These policies include measures such as direct transfers to individuals and businesses, public investment in infrastructure.

Currently, Canada's fiscal policy focuses on building flexible fiscal instruments that can be quickly implemented or stopped when necessary. The Canadian Ministry of Finance researches and develops models to forecast and analyze the impact of policies at both the macro level and the level of specific target groups.

“The same as other countries, including Vietnam, we rely on stabilization programs integrated into the tax system. Our approach is to strengthen and enhance the capacity of forecasting models, combining both private sector forecasts as well as research from the Bank of Canada and other studies. Additionally, we research to find space to continue applying fiscal stimulus measures,” the expert said.

Sharing specifically about active stabilization programs, the expert said that the country has two programs including the employment insurance program and the support program based on the progressive tax system.

Regarding the employment insurance program, the expert said that unemployed workers will be provided with income support by the Government for a certain period of time, and this is a social security policy, not a macroeconomic stabilization program.

However, the program has limitations in terms of flexibility and the ability to adjust quickly in crisis situations. Expanding or adjusting this program requires certain changes and may lead to undesirable effects.

“The spending so much on the program, which may not encourage workers to resume work and not develop the labor market,” the expert noted.

The second program is implemented based on the income tax system. This is considered an automatic stabilizer. Accordingly, when income decreases, people's tax obligations also automatically decrease, helping to maintain disposable income. This system has a natural stabilizing effect, but it also has certain limits and is not the focus of the tax system.

At the discussion session, the representative of the Vietnamese Ministry of Finance said that one of the problems that countries are facing is the difficulty in returning to normal tax policies as before the Covid-19 pandemic. In Vietnam, in the 2021-2022 period, amid economic difficulties, the Government has implemented 2% VAT reduction to stimulate consumption. Currently, Vietnam considers solutions to shift tax policy from support to normal policy to avoid causing unwanted impacts.

Discussing this issue, the Canadian expert said that VAT is an important source of revenue, and if VAT is cut to stimulate the economy in a short time, it may still be acceptable. However, if the tax reduction is prolonged, it will affect the general revenue, because in addition to reducing VAT, governments also issue many other proactive support policies. Therefore, if there is no balance, difficulties may arise.

In addition, the expert said that the VAT reduction may lead to the situation that people may save money and wait for VAT reduction before spending. According to this expert, the policy of reducing consumer spending is not necessary a tool used in every recession. Therefore, tax policies need to be carefully balanced to avoid negatively affecting people's consumption behavior.

By Hoai Anh/Ngoc Loan

Related News

MoF proposes to abolish Article 35 on “on-the-spot import and export” in Decree No.08/2015/ND-CP

MoF proposes to abolish Article 35 on “on-the-spot import and export” in Decree No.08/2015/ND-CP

VCN - The Ministry of Finance (the General Department of Vietnam Customs) has received comments on the draft Decree amending and supplementing a number of articles of Decree No. 08/2015/ND-CP providing specific provisions and guidance on enforcement of the customs law on customs procedures, examination, supervision and control procedures. In addition to revision related to on-the-spot import and export activities, the draft also proposes to supplement new regulations to meet requirements of implementing digital customs, ensuring compliance with practical situations and promoting customs modernization.
Proposal on VAT reduction in electricity bills unreasonable

Proposal on VAT reduction in electricity bills unreasonable

VCN - At the question and answer session at the 36th Session of the National Assembly Standing Committee on August 21, 2024, the Minister of Finance and Minister of Industry and Trade clarified a number of important contents that the deputies concern related to electricity price calculation, including the issue of VAT in electricity bills.
Businesses fined for misdeclaration

Businesses fined for misdeclaration

VCN - From the beginning of 2024, Ho Chi Minh City Customs Department has sanctioned administrative violations for many cases of tax fraud in customs declarations for imported goods.
HCM City Customs refunds over VND 49 billion of VAT for foreign passengers

HCM City Customs refunds over VND 49 billion of VAT for foreign passengers

VCN – In the first half of 2024, HCM City Customs Department refunded over VND 49 billion for over 10,000 foreign passengers.

Latest News

Fifteen Vietnamese banks named in the global top 500 banking brands

Fifteen Vietnamese banks named in the global top 500 banking brands

Fifteen Vietnamese banks are named on the world’s top 500 banking brands, announced by the world’s leading brand valuation consultancy Brand Finance.
Digital infrastructure strategy approved

Digital infrastructure strategy approved

Permanent Deputy Prime Minister Nguyen Hoa Binh recently signed a decision approving the digital infrastructure by 2025 with a vision to 2030.
Drastically handle tax debts in the last months of the year

Drastically handle tax debts in the last months of the year

VCN – The General Department of Taxation has directed tax branches to closely supervise and control the implementation of enforcement measures to ensure the debt collection targets and limit new debts.
Realized social investment capital is estimated at VND2,417.2 trillion

Realized social investment capital is estimated at VND2,417.2 trillion

VCN - Lending interest rates tend to decrease, production for export has grown well; policies on tax exemption, reduction, extension and deferral continue to be implemented to support businesses and production establishments, promoting new investment and production expansion, increasing the attraction and implementation of total social investment capital.

More News

State-owned banks struggle to increase capital

State-owned banks struggle to increase capital

While private joint stock commercial banks have increased capital significantly so far this year, the capital for State-owned commercial banks has remained stagnant.
State budget revenue reached 85.1% of estimate

State budget revenue reached 85.1% of estimate

VCN - The Ministry of Finance said that in the first 9 months of 2024, the total state budget revenue is estimated at 1,448.2 trillion VND, equal to 85.1% of the estimate, of which many revenue items have achieved good collection progress and growth compared to the same period in 2023. However, in recent months, budget revenue has begun to face difficulties, etc.
Budget expenditure in the first three quarters of 2024 reached about VND 1,256.3 trillion

Budget expenditure in the first three quarters of 2024 reached about VND 1,256.3 trillion

VCN - The Ministry of Finance said that in the first 9 months of 2024, the state budget spent about VND 1,256.3 trillion, equal to 59.3% of current apropriation, an increase of 1.4% over the same period in 2023.
Increasing institutional investors – improving quality of corporate bond market

Increasing institutional investors – improving quality of corporate bond market

VCN - The structure and quality of investors have been one of the limitations of the corporate bond market in recent times. To improve the quality of the market, increasing institutional investors and improving the quality of investors, including individual investors, is one of the solutions that have been implemented by management agencies, thereby building a sustainable corporate bond market.
Urgent measures to restore production post-disaster

Urgent measures to restore production post-disaster

VCN - To quickly restore agricultural production after storm No. 3 and floods, the Prime Minister assigned the Ministry of Finance to guide the immediate implementation of financial support policies, tax exemptions, reductions, and extensions, land rents, water surface rents, etc. for those affected by storms and floods; continue to research to have policies to exempt and reduce fees and charges for those affected.
Risks for the economy when cash flow has not yet been put in to production and business

Risks for the economy when cash flow has not yet been put in to production and business

VCN - Investment channels in Vietnam have a lot of potential, but financial and banking expert Dr. Nguyen Tri Hieu, Director of the Institute for Research and Development of Global Financial and Real Estate Markets, said that cash flow into production and business is still modest, leading to risks for the economy.
An open banking system is essential for a smart city

An open banking system is essential for a smart city

Building a smart city with a smart payment system playing a key role has helped Hanoi gradually transform and make breakthroughs in the process of development, said Ha Minh Hai, Vice Chairman of the municipal People's Committee.
Tax sector focuses on simplifying tax administrative procedures

Tax sector focuses on simplifying tax administrative procedures

VCN - The tax sector is focusing on researching and proposing amendments to legal documents to simplify processes and procedures; promoting the modernization of information technology applications to support the settlement of tax refund dossiers more conveniently and quickly.
Individual customers' deposits in Jan-Jul see record high

Individual customers' deposits in Jan-Jul see record high

Total deposits from individual customers at banks had reached 6.8 quadrillion VND (276.3 billion USD) in the first seven months of this year, marking the highest level ever, according to the latest data released by the State Bank.
Read More

Your care

Latest Most read
Fifteen Vietnamese banks named in the global top 500 banking brands

Fifteen Vietnamese banks named in the global top 500 banking brands

Fifteen Vietnamese banks are named on the world’s top 500 banking brands, announced by the world’s leading brand valuation consultancy Brand Finance.
Digital infrastructure strategy approved

Digital infrastructure strategy approved

Permanent Deputy Prime Minister Nguyen Hoa Binh recently signed a decision approving the digital infrastructure by 2025 with a vision to 2030.
Drastically handle tax debts in the last months of the year

Drastically handle tax debts in the last months of the year

VCN - From the beginning of 2024, the General Department of Taxation requested and assigned tax departments to ensure the completion of tax debt collection targets in 2024, and enhance responsibility in tax debt management and collection, contributing to
Realized social investment capital is estimated at VND2,417.2 trillion

Realized social investment capital is estimated at VND2,417.2 trillion

Lending interest rates tend to decrease, production for export has grown well; policies on tax exemption, reduction, extension and deferral continue to be implemented to support businesses
State-owned banks struggle to increase capital

State-owned banks struggle to increase capital

While private joint stock commercial banks have increased capital significantly so far this year, the capital for State-owned commercial banks has remained stagnant.
Mobile Version