Tax evasion “trick” makes it difficult for Vietnamese goods

VCN - Not only "scathed" by anti-dumping cases, subsidies, or safeguards from other countries,but there are also cases where Vietnam issued together with China, also known as tax evasion issuing. Whenever China issued, after a while Vietnam issued as well.
tax evasion trick makes it difficult for vietnamese goods
Lots of items including steel were once sued for tax evasion as suspected of being transferred from China

This significantly impacts on the domestic industry as well as the prestige of Vietnamese goods in the international market.

Involving in misfortune

In just one week, the Competition Administration Department (MOIT) has continuously broadcastinformation of US companies havingfiled a lawsuit for the tax evasion of anti-dumping and countervailing duty to the US Department of Commerce (DOC) with corrosion-resistant steel products, also known as galvanized steel and cold rolled steel products imported from Vietnam.

The cause of these two incidents comes from the fact that the US imposed anti-dumping and anti-subsidy dutyonChina steel products. Specifically, after the US enacted the duty imposing order, China's export volume for these two productsto the US hassignificantly decreased; however, the export of these products from Vietnam to the UShas increased suddenly. Therefore, the plaintiff requested the DOC to initiate an investigation and delay the liquidation of shipments importing galvanized steel and cold rolled steel products from Vietnam and require to depositthe shipments equal level to anti-dumping duties and countervailing duties against products from China.

Of course, according to the US regulations, to complement the third country’s product on the current duty imposing order (investigation of tax evasion), the DOC shall consider factors such as: Products imported from a third country under the same category with products subject to the tax; before importing into the US, this product has been completed or manufactured from products manufactured in countries subject to the tax; processing or finishing in a third country is "small or negligible"; value of goods produced in the tax imposed country "dominating a major part in the total value of the products are exported to the United States"; DOC determined that an investigation is necessary to prevent the evasion.

In addition, the DOC will also consider the following factors: trade trends; whether manufacturers export of inputs associated with the third countryusing these materials for processing/finishing products imported into the United States and whether the tax imposed country increases export inputmaterial to the third country after the DOC initiated an investigation and imposed taxes or not.

This is not the first time Vietnam has been accused of tax evasion. In July, the Vietnam Trade Office in France advised of information from the European Anti-fraud Office ofthe European Commission (OLAF) that, Portugal, Spain and Poland Customs in recent years have recorded a large number of coil coated steel products imported from Vietnam having signs of trade fraud. OLAF suspects the possibility that Chinese firms sell steel into Vietnam and then let Vietnam enterprises export to EU using the Vietnamese C/O to avoid the anti-dumping duty. If this suspicion is verified, OLAF will propose Customs authorities in import countries topay arrears of antidumping duty (58%) that the EU is applying for Chinese steel. For a fewyears, for some items such as wood, plastic, granite there have also been countries such as Turkey, India sued for antidumping duty evasion.

Prevention from the licensing stage

With the two steel products mentioned above, this is just an accusation from US enterprises. Under US regulations, the DOC will review and make decisions of initiating an investigation or not within 45 days of receipt of the application (expected date of 22/10/2016 for galvanized products, and 10/11/2016 for cold rolled steel) and issue a final decision within 300 days.

However, according to the Competition Management Department, tax evasion cases are unpredictable due to the fact that they depend on numerous factors. Currently this authority has notified the Vietnam Steel Association and enterprises to check the information from the Customs authority to catch up the export situation,and the situation of C/O for businesses.

This preparation is necessarysince the coordination, provision and transparency of information is of paramount importance to be able to win in any case. By the fact of the incident has happened shows that there were cases where Vietnam was imposed and also cases where Vietnam "got free" from the lawsuit. More noteworthy, the investigations of tax evasion have one thing in common in that almost all cases are related to Chinese products. Mrs. Tran Thi Thu Huong, Director of the Commercial Documents Confirmation Centre, Chamber of Commerce and Industry of Vietnam (VCCI), said once China itself was sued after a while Vietnam always got sued as well. Because, when China is the subject for imposing tax, that will facilitate for Vietnam enterprises exporting to those markets. So, after being sued, Chinese investors tend to redirect investment into Vietnam to produce, and avoid anti-dumping duties.

Establishing new enterprises or transferring their factories to Vietnam to produce but once being sued, these investors choose not to cooperate or "run away" leading to final decisions detrimental to Vietnam's manufacturing industry. According to the opinions of many experts, this is a form of commercial fraud of foreign companies when being taxed with high anti-dumping by markets, and also is the transfigured phenomenon of foreign investors. There is a case where the domestic enterprise worked with foreign companies in importing goods, packaging and then obtaining Vietnamese certificates of origin and export and then exporting. This has a huge influence on Vietnam when exporting goods, and companies doing business with honesty.

In future, cases of tax evasion investigations will certainly occur more with the Free trade agreements that Vietnam has been signingwith preferential tariff then the trade barriers will "grow" much more. In order to avoid this kind of case, according to Mrs.Huong, companies first need to do the right things, raise awareness to prevent being taken advantageof by foreign companies.

On the management side, she said, a Warning advisory and block trade through certificates of origin (C/O) councils of the VCCI has been established with the participation of several ministries such as MOIT, MOPI, the Police, andCustoms. The council meets regularly and gives warnings of risk, located in suspectitems, thereby helping the original licensing agency which is the Foreign Investment Department (Ministry of Planning and Investment) to warn, and advise enterprises. Thus, the stage of investment licensing needs more attention and be further tightened to avoid commercial fraud.

Sharing successful experience in the investigation of tax evasion of plywood items (Turkey initiated), Mr. Nguyen Ton Quyen, Secretary General of the Vietnam Association of Timber and Forest Products said the process of taxevasion anti-dumping investigation usually follows this schedule:

First, we must grasp the information that Vietnam enterprises are being sued for by the decision of the investigation party provided with the generic items.

Then, the Association coordinates with the Ministry of Industry and Trade, and the Ministry of Agriculture and Rural Development to invite companies to a meeting for giving notice. If the company does not have full records and papers, thenthey must be guided about contents such as where the goods were purchased, the origin situation, how is the bookkeeping.

The third step is to delve deeply into the content, records, and books to be able to explain. For complicated cases, they must also engage alawyer. Finally, invite partners to Vietnam to negotiate.

"These tax evasion investigations are very complex, and require businesses and authorities to stay close with the case since there isa deadline, if the explanation is not sufficient,the case islikely to be lost. It took 6 months for us to solve this case. In the future, tax evasion suing is an inevitable trend by many companies that do not perceive international law. It is important to collect information, records, with justification if we want to win", he stated.

By Phan thu/ Luong Ngoc

Related News

Tax sector achieves revenue target of about VND1.7 million billion

Tax sector achieves revenue target of about VND1.7 million billion

VCN – Motivated by the revenue collection by the end of December 2024, the General Department of Taxation has accomplished the revenue collection.
Achievements in revenue collection are a premise for breakthroughs in 2025

Achievements in revenue collection are a premise for breakthroughs in 2025

VCN – Motivated by great efforts and effective implementation of solutions, as of December 10 the total State revenue from imports and exports saw a year-on-year increase of 13.8% to VND397,861 billion, meeting 106.1% of the estimate. The revenue us estimated to reach VND420,000 billion, meeting 112 % of the estimate, up 13.9% over the same period in 2023. The achievements in 2024 are a premise for a breakthrough in revenue collection in 2025.
Answering many questions from businesses at dialogue conference on tax and customs policies

Answering many questions from businesses at dialogue conference on tax and customs policies

VCN - Many opinions and recommendations related to tax and customs issues were raised by the business community at the dialogue on tax and customs policies and administrative procedures in 2024, organized by the Ministry of Finance.Representatives of the Ministry of Finance, the General Department of Taxation, and the General Department of Customs provided specific responses, and affirmed that they will continue to research and advise on the assessment, review, and amendment and supplementation of appropriate regulations.
Tax authorities crack down on invoice fraud to legalize smuggled goods

Tax authorities crack down on invoice fraud to legalize smuggled goods

VCN - As part of efforts to combat smuggling and trade fraud during the Lunar New Year season, the Steering Committee 389 of the Ministry of Finance has instructed the General Department of Taxation to intensify enforcement against illegal practices involving fraudulent invoices and tax evasion.

Latest News

Top 10 Reputable Animal Feed Companies in 2024: Efforts to survive the challenges of nature

Top 10 Reputable Animal Feed Companies in 2024: Efforts to survive the challenges of nature

VCN - In the Report announcing the Ranking of Top 10 Reputable Animal Feed Companies in 2024 on December 12, 2024, Vietnam Report Joint Stock Company said that Vietnam's animal feed industry has faced many challenges from natural disasters and epidemics. But overcoming all, the industry continues to survive and has confidence in the future.
Vietnam's import-export surges 15.3%

Vietnam's import-export surges 15.3%

Vietnam's total import-export turnover reached 745 billion USD as of December 14, marking a robust 15.3% growth compared to the same period in 2023, according to the General Department of Vietnam Customs.
More Vietnamese firms interested in Saudi Arabia: Ambassador

More Vietnamese firms interested in Saudi Arabia: Ambassador

An increasing number of Vietnamese enterprises are showing interest in Saudi Arabia, particularly in the sectors of Vietnam's advantages and the Middle East country's needs, a diplomat has said.
“Give and Take” in the Value Chain of the CPTPP Market

“Give and Take” in the Value Chain of the CPTPP Market

VCN - Vietnamese businesses have many opportunities and advantages if they take advantage of resources from imports and technology transfers when joining the supply chains of FDI companies within the CPTPP.

More News

Binh Dinh province works to attract investment from Japan

Binh Dinh province works to attract investment from Japan

The People’s Committee of Binh Dinh province on December 18 inked a cooperation deal with the Japan - Vietnam Friendship Association of Sakai city as part of the south-central province’s efforts to attract more investment and development resources from the Northeast Asian country.
Agricultural, forestry and fishery exports “reach the target” early

Agricultural, forestry and fishery exports “reach the target” early

VCN - According to a report from the Ministry of Agriculture and Rural Development, the export turnover of agricultural, forestry and fishery products in November 2024 is estimated at US $5.3 billion, up 13.9% compared to November 2023. It is notable that it not only “reaching the finish line” early, the agricultural sector also exceeded the annual plan by over US $ one billion.
Thailand remains Vietnam’s biggest trading partner in ASEAN

Thailand remains Vietnam’s biggest trading partner in ASEAN

The activities conducted by the Vietnam Trade Office in Thailand in 2024 have enriched the trade and investment relations between the two countries, contributing to helping Thailand maintain its position as Vietnam's largest trading partner in the Association of Southeast Asian Nations (ASEAN), according to Le Huu Phuc, Vietnam's Trade Counsellor in Thailand.
Rubber value soars in 2024: VRA

Rubber value soars in 2024: VRA

All Vietnam's rubber’s top 15 export markets saw growth in export values in 2024, with Malaysia recording the highest increase, expanding fivefold, followed by Sri Lanka at 3.7 times, according to the Vietnam Rubber Association (VRA).
Vietnamese businesses struggle to access green finance

Vietnamese businesses struggle to access green finance

VCN - Green finance is gradually becoming an indispensable tool in Vietnam to support businesses, promote sustainable development, and move towards the goal of Net Zero. However, the path to accessing green capital is full of barriers, especially for small and medium enterprises.
E-commerce: a gateway to boost Vietnamese commodities in the UK market

E-commerce: a gateway to boost Vietnamese commodities in the UK market

E-commerce stands out as a promising channel to further enhance Việt Nam’s trade presence in this dynamic market.
Agro-forestry-fisheries exports top 62 billion USD in 2024

Agro-forestry-fisheries exports top 62 billion USD in 2024

Vietnam’s agro-forestry-fisheries exports are projected to reach over 62 billion USD in 2024, and continue to grow next year, heard at a conference in Ho Chi Minh City on December 16.
Removing “bottlenecks” for digital transformation in industrial production

Removing “bottlenecks” for digital transformation in industrial production

VCN - Although implementing digital transformation towards smart production creates many opportunities, it also poses significant challenges for businesses, especially in terms of investment costs and human resources.
UKVFTA facilitates Việt Nam

UKVFTA facilitates Việt Nam's tuna exports to UK market

Việt Nam is the 13th largest tuna product supplier to the UK, according to the Vietnam Association of Seafood Exporters and Producers (VASEP).
Read More

Your care

Latest Most read
Top 10 Reputable Animal Feed Companies in 2024: Efforts to survive the challenges of nature

Top 10 Reputable Animal Feed Companies in 2024: Efforts to survive the challenges of nature

VCN - In the Report announcing the Ranking of Top 10 Reputable Animal Feed Companies in 2024 on December 12, 2024, Vietnam Report Joint Stock Company said that Vietnam's animal feed industry has faced many challenges from natural disasters and epidemics.
Vietnam's import-export surges 15.3%

Vietnam's import-export surges 15.3%

Vietnam's total import-export turnover reached 745 billion USD as of December 14, marking a robust 15.3% growth compared to the same period in 2023, according to the General Department of Vietnam Customs.
More Vietnamese firms interested in Saudi Arabia: Ambassador

More Vietnamese firms interested in Saudi Arabia: Ambassador

An increasing number of Vietnamese enterprises are showing interest in Saudi Arabia, particularly in the sectors of Vietnam's advantages and the Middle East country's needs, a diplomat has said.
“Give and Take” in the Value Chain of the CPTPP Market

“Give and Take” in the Value Chain of the CPTPP Market

Vietnamese businesses have many opportunities and advantages if they take advantage of resources from imports and technology transfers when joining the supply chains of FDI companies within the CPTPP.
Binh Dinh province works to attract investment from Japan

Binh Dinh province works to attract investment from Japan

The People’s Committee of Binh Dinh province on December 18 inked a cooperation deal with the Japan - Vietnam Friendship Association of Sakai city as part of the south-central province’s efforts to attract more investment and development resources from the Northeast Asian country.
Mobile Version