Guaranteed returns ploy driving condotel craze fraught with risk

Ignoring analysts warnings investors bought thousands of condotels lured by developers promises of high guaranteed returns each year.
guaranteed returns ploy driving condotel craze fraught with risk

A part of Cocobay Da Nang. Photo courtesy of Empire Group.

Shock waves swept through the investors a few days ago as Empire Group, the developer of the Cocobay Da Nang Complex, announced that it will stop paying shophouse and condotel buyers the annuity it had promised them, citing financial difficulties. It had earlier guaranteed these payments until 2026.

The promise of guaranteed annual returns has been a primary factor in attracting thousands to invest in condotels.

The first condotel project in Vietnam came up in 2013 on a seaside street in the central resort town of Nha Trang. A year later another was developed in Da Nang City. But the concept of condotels was still new to Vietnamese investors and the guaranteed return policy had yet to appear.

It was not until 2016 that the craze really took root, with condotels appearing at coastal resorts alongside villas and more modest houses.

These term became well-known across the country as many developers, small and big, entered the condotel sector with projects dotting the country's entire coastline. According to real estate services firm CBRE, about 30,000 condotel units had been launched by the end of 2018 and another 3,000 units have been added to the market this year.

With increase number of condotel projects coming up, competition became fierce and developers started offering higher guaranteed returns.

Major developers of condotel units or resort villas began to promise guaranteed returns of 5-10 percent per year for 5-10 years. Newer developers upped the game by promising up to 15 percent per year for 5-15 years.

Soon enough, investors were lining up to buy condotels and the projects' open sales events attracted hundreds of potential customers and registered hundreds of successful transactions. In some projects, investors were able to resell their units just 1-2 months after buying for profits of hundreds of millions of dong (VND100 million = $4,300).

Some investors even bought multiple units or an entire block in hope of receiving large payments in guaranteed returns for little effort.

In addition to stirring up the coastal tourism markets, the strategy of promising guaranteed returns was also a key factor in the mushrooming of condotel and resort villa projects in mountainous areas such as the northern resort town of Sa Pa or emerging markets with tourism potential like the northern provinces of Bac Ninh, Hoa Binh, Lang Son and Hai Duong.

Even in recent years, when these models started facing ownership challenges and disputes because of the lack of a legal framework, the guaranteed returns proved to be an effective bait, resulting in small-scale crazes for certain projects. Just this year, a developer promised guaranteed returns for 60 years with the margin increasing yearly, and the project successfully sold over 3,000 units in just a few months.

The race to be the developer with the best offer in the resort property market has long been a hotly discussed topic among the market's participants, with many expressing doubts and worrying that these agreements would collapse.

Since the last 3-4 years, experts from the real estate services provider Savills have already been warning that guaranteed returns of over 10 percent per year was extremely high and tough to achieve. In comparison, a profit of 5 percent per year was already considered a good figure for condotels in Thailand and Indonesia.

Duong Thuy Dung, Senior Director of property consultancy CBRE Vietnam, suggested that profits of 8-12 percent per year could only be achieved if there was no competition in the market, and in case of fierce competition, the maximum guaranteed return that could be offered would be 6 percent.

She said this strategy was only a selling gimmick with great risks as there was still no mechanism to protect buyers should the developers not deliver on their promise.

A CEO in the real estate sector also calculated that tourist accommodation establishments usually suffer losses in the first 3-5 years after opening. Inexperienced operators therefore would find it difficult to maintain operations if they had to pay a minimum guaranteed profit of 14 percent for five years while shouldering the losses accumulated in the first 3-5 years.

Additionally, if they hired international management companies, they would have to shoulder additional costs of 13-15 percent. The total cost for the first few years, therefore, would make it difficult for them to even survive, and sharing profits with buyers as promised would be almost impossible, the CEO added, declining to be named.

Many of these predictions have since become reality.

After operating for 2-3 years, many condotel developers are already struggling to maintain the payment of guaranteed returns and some projects have even collapsed.

Cocobay Da Nang is not the first condotel project to stop paying buyers the promised returns. The developer of the Bavico condotel project in Nha Trang had to negotiate with buyers to reduce the guaranteed returns from 15 percent per year down to 8 percent, and it could not even pay the revised amount.

Nguyen Duc Thanh, chairman of Empire Group, has admitted that after beginning operations, Cocobay Da Nang suffered losses in the first two years and after that, it only generated profits of 5-6 percent per year.

He claimed that his company had signed partnership agreements with two major firms, but had to make many adjustments to the project's design to meet the partners' requests, causing the project to be significantly delayed and making the promised returns of 12 percent per year impossible to achieve.

Troy Griffiths, Deputy Managing Director of Savills Vietnam, said the fact of condotel developers breaking their promises to buyers has also occurred in other markets around the world, and it's certain that more such cases would continue to occur in Vietnam.

Investors and buyers need to be careful whenever developers promise huge profits because market fluctuations during the long repayment period are ever present risks, he added.

Griffiths also said that many second-home resort projects have been adopting the model of sharing profits between the owner and the developer/operator instead of guaranteed returns. He suggested that this could be a more stable and less risky direction for Vietnam's resort market.

Source: vnexpress

Related News

Risk prevention solutions for export processing and production enterprises

Risk prevention solutions for export processing and production enterprises

VCN - Identifying common errors to comply with regulations, prevent risks, and limit mistakes arising in preparing final settlement reports is an issue which many export processing and production enterprises concern.
Risk prevention solutions for processing and export manufacturing businesses

Risk prevention solutions for processing and export manufacturing businesses

VCN - Identifying common errors to comply with regulations, prevent risks, and limit errors arising in preparing final settlement reports is an issue of concern to many export processing and manufacturing enterprises.
Early warnings reduce risks in trade defense

Early warnings reduce risks in trade defense

VCN - In the first months of 2024, export turnover of goods grew strongly, continuing the recovery momentum from the end of 2023. Along with that, the risk of trade defense investigations also escalated
Domestic HRC hot-rolled steel "supply does not meet demand", should imports be restricted?

Domestic HRC hot-rolled steel "supply does not meet demand", should imports be restricted?

VCN - According to the General Department of Customs, in the first two months of 2024, the country imported 2.65 million tons of iron and steel of all kinds, an increase of 85.4% over the same period in 2023, of which the main import market is from China. However, the use of measures to restrict the import of steel materials is a controversial issue.

Latest News

PM urges measures to remove obstacles to e-commerce

PM urges measures to remove obstacles to e-commerce

Prime Minister Pham Minh Chinh has stressed the need to implement specific tasks in order to untangle knots in e-commerce development, according to the Government Office.
European firms hope for Vietnam’s continuous policy adjustments: EuroCham survey

European firms hope for Vietnam’s continuous policy adjustments: EuroCham survey

The European Chamber of Commerce in Vietnam (EuroCham) on July 15 released its Business Confidence Index (BCI) report for the second quarter of 2024, which reveals a marginal decline from 52.8 in Q1 to 51.3 in Q2, underscoring the necessity for ongoing policy adjustments to maintain momentum.
Six factors positively impact economic growth in 2024

Six factors positively impact economic growth in 2024

VCN- Minister of Planning and Investment (MPI) Tran Quoc Phuong said there are 6 factors that will positively impact economic growth in the remaining months of 2024.
Vietnam attends 14th annual East Sea conference in US

Vietnam attends 14th annual East Sea conference in US

A Vietnamese delegation led by Vice President of Diplomatic Academy of Vietnam Nguyen Hung Son attended the 14th annual conference on East Sea (also known as South China Sea) held by the Washington DC-based Centre for Strategic and International Studies (CSIS) on July 11.

More News

President’s state visits contribute to strengthening Vietnam-Laos-Cambodia cooperation: FM

President’s state visits contribute to strengthening Vietnam-Laos-Cambodia cooperation: FM

Vietnamese President To Lam’s state visits to Laos and Cambodia from July 11-13 have contributed to enhancing the traditional and effective cooperation among the three countries, Minister of Foreign Affairs Bui Thanh Son has said.
HCM City gears up for future workforce challenges

HCM City gears up for future workforce challenges

A recently approved labour and employment strategy of Ho Chi Minh City outlines potential challenges and opportunities for its workforce between 2023 and 2030.
Important innovation in the draft Law on Management and Investment of State Capital at Enterprises

Important innovation in the draft Law on Management and Investment of State Capital at Enterprises

VCN - Continue to collect comments on the draft Law on Management and Investment of State Capital at Enterprises, representatives of state-owned enterprises all said that the work of developing the Law needs to pay attention to avoid overlap when implementing with other related laws.
Vietnamese economy recovers rapidly thanks to drastic actions: IMF expert

Vietnamese economy recovers rapidly thanks to drastic actions: IMF expert

Vietnam's economy recovered rapidly in the first half of 2024 after a challenging period at the end of 2022 and early 2023, thanks to its government’s drastic actions, according to Paulo Medas, head of the International Monetary Fund (IMF)’s 2024 Article IV Mission to Vietnam.
President arrives in Phnom Penh, beginning state visit to Cambodia

President arrives in Phnom Penh, beginning state visit to Cambodia

State President To Lam arrived at the Phnom Penh International Airport on July 12 afternoon, starting his two-day state visit to Cambodia at an invitation of King Preah Bat Samdech Preah Boromneath Norodom Sihamoni.
Government unveils plan to empower intellectual workforce for national growth

Government unveils plan to empower intellectual workforce for national growth

The Government has issued a resolution outlining its action programme to continue building and elevating the role of intellectual workforce for national rapid and sustainable development in the new era.
President To Lam sets off for state visits to Laos, Cambodia

President To Lam sets off for state visits to Laos, Cambodia

President To Lam and a high-ranking delegation of Vietnam left Hanoi on July 11 morning for three-day state visits to Laos and Cambodia.
Consumption index of the entire processing and manufacturing industry increased by 10.8%

Consumption index of the entire processing and manufacturing industry increased by 10.8%

VCN - In the first 6 months of 2024, the consumption index of the entire processing and manufacturing industry increased by 10.8% compared to the same period in 2023 (the same period last year decreased by 2.2%), while the decrease of the inventory index is the positive signal that shows the recovery of industrial production.
Higher GDP forecasts on robust economic recovery and new growth drivers

Higher GDP forecasts on robust economic recovery and new growth drivers

Recent forecasts are optimistic about the Vietnamese economy in 2024, with the gross domestic product (GDP) growth rate poised to reach around 7 per cent for the full year, higher than the National Assembly’s target set at 6.5 per cent.
Read More

Your care

Latest Most read
PM urges measures to remove obstacles to e-commerce

PM urges measures to remove obstacles to e-commerce

Prime Minister Pham Minh Chinh has stressed the need to implement specific tasks in order to untangle knots in e-commerce development, according to the Government Office.
European firms hope for Vietnam’s continuous policy adjustments: EuroCham survey

European firms hope for Vietnam’s continuous policy adjustments: EuroCham survey

The European Chamber of Commerce in Vietnam (EuroCham) on July 15 released its Business Confidence Index (BCI) report for the second quarter of 2024, which reveals a marginal decline from 52.8 in Q1 to 51.3 in Q2, underscoring the necessity for ongoing policy adjustments to maintain momentum.
Six factors positively impact economic growth in 2024

Six factors positively impact economic growth in 2024

VCN - Analyzing more specifically the basis for this recommendation, according to the representative of the Ministry of Planning and Investment, there are 6 factors that create a positive impact on economic growth in the remaining months of 2024.
Vietnam attends 14th annual East Sea conference in US

Vietnam attends 14th annual East Sea conference in US

A Vietnamese delegation led by Vice President of Diplomatic Academy of Vietnam Nguyen Hung Son attended the 14th annual conference on East Sea (also known as South China Sea) held by the Washington DC-based Centre for Strategic and International Studies (CSIS) on July 11.
President’s state visits contribute to strengthening Vietnam-Laos-Cambodia cooperation: FM

President’s state visits contribute to strengthening Vietnam-Laos-Cambodia cooperation: FM

Vietnamese President To Lam’s state visits to Laos and Cambodia from July 11-13 have contributed to enhancing the traditional and effective cooperation among the three countries, Minister of Foreign Affairs Bui Thanh Son has said.
Mobile Version