Clean water business: public or private?

VCN - Immediately after the oil contamination at the Da River water plant making Hanoi citizens miserable, public opinions continued to be "hot" because the Duong River surface water plant, which has not yet completed acceptance has been put into operation, and its selling price of water was higher than other facilities. A series of shortcomings in clean water production and business happened, raising concerns about the big "gap" in managing this type of business.
tin nhap 20191209150606 Assessing the compliance of customs declarants
tin nhap 20191209150606 Nearly 6,000 agricultural products granted traceability codes
tin nhap 20191209150606 More 451 businesses carry out customs procedures at Quang Ninh Customs
tin nhap 20191209150606
The image of people waiting in line for each drop of clean water is clear evidence for the shortcomings in the management of this item. Photo: ST

Exclusive and "lucrative"?

Currently, clean water in Hanoi is being provided by five enterprises namely: Hanoi Water Limited Company (Hawacom); Ha Dong Water Limited Company, Fresh Water Business and Construction Investment Joint Stock Company (Viwaco), Duong River Surface Water Joint Stock Company and Da River Clean Water Investment JSC (Viwasupco).

According to some economic experts, clean water is a highly profitable product. Nguyen Si Dung, a public management expert and former Vice Chairman of the National Assembly's Office, said clean water was a "lucrative" market because if coffee could be drunk today or another day, travelling could be gone this year or another year, water or electricity, like rice and clothes, was anindispensable need, and almost unchanged.

Regarding the "lucrative" feature in the production and trading of clean water, Viwasupco’s financial report for the third quarter of 2019 showed its revenue and profit increased sharply, much higher than the annual profit plan. Specifically, the revenue increased 17 percent over the same period in 2018, at VND138 billion; the EAT increased 28 percent, reaching VND72 billion. In the first nine months, Viwasupco's revenue increased by 21 percent to more thanVND400 billion, while its profit after tax increased by 30 percent to nearly VND200 billion, much higher than the profit goalfor the whole year, which was VND75.5 billion.

In addition to Viwasupco, in the last two years, Hanoi Water Limited Company (Hawacom) produced a total 230 million m3 per year, equivalent to production capacity in excess of650,000m3 per day and night. In 2018, Hawacom achieved net profit of VND356 billion with an increase in profit margin of 19 percent.

Economic experts are also concerned about the monopoly in producing and supplying clean water. On the one hand, this is a specific commodity, not all businesses are capable of producing clean water. On the other, people sometimes cannot buy water even if they have money, they cannot choose their water supplier, and businesses cannot arbitrarily sell to the customers that they want to.In short, neither seller nor buyer has "self-determination" and the decision maker is the city government. The government decides which producers supply water to which areas, which means people in that area must use water from a specific supplier. Therefore, although the Da River’s water is polluted, people in areas using Da River water cannot buy water from other suppliers. Therefore, when answering the press in the days of Da River water crisis, even Minister of Natural Resources and Environment Tran Hong Ha said he and his family had sufferedthree days of dirty water.

Fair competition

According to many economic experts, clean water should be strictly controlled by the State but the management of clean water is "floating" when giving full authority to enterprises. Regarding the case that the Duong River clean water plant was bought by a Thai person, many experts suggested the State should review the conditional business list. Accordingly, it is necessary to restrict the transfer of some industries outside the Vietnamese border, particularly clean water. Some experts said clean water business should be kept in the conditional business list. Simultaneously, it is required to set standards and regulations for strict management when registering investment in clean water business.

In addition, to avoid the "floating" clean water business, Bui ThiAn, Director of the Institute of Natural Resources Environment and Community Development, said regulations on proving capital sources should be prescribed when investing in the production and trading of clean water.

According to An, once the legality of the capital is proved, every enterprise, regardless of economic sectors, can produce and supply clean water, on the basis of ensuring water quality. “The State will buy water from any business that meets those factors. There may be a number of focal points but there should be only one management and coordination agency,” said An.

Sharing the same opinion, Nguyen Si Dung said there should be the participation of private enterprises because if there was no competition for quality in the market of public services, the risk of quality assurance would be large. "Enterprises will put quality criteria below profits and the Da River incident may happen again," said the expert.

According to Dung, the monopoly of production and supply should be abolished and the principle of market economy, open and transparent bidding should be applied. When bidding, financial capacity should be checked to ensure the effective investment progress, said Dung.

Another expert, Nguyen Xuan Lai, Vice President cum General Secretary, Vietnam Water Supply and Environment Association, said although water was a specific type, it should not be given to only a few enterprises that leave people with no choice. Therefore, when an incident occurs, people only have two options, one is to stop using water and the other is to use unsafe water.

According to the Hanoi Water Supply Plan to 2030, vision to 2050 approved by the Prime Minister, it is forecasted that by 2030, Hanoi's water demand will reach 1,939,000 m3 per day and night; and reach 2,576,000 m3 per day and night by 2050. In particular, the water supply comes from three surface water plants including Da River, Red River and Duong River (supplied to Hanoi). The supply location and the goal of upgrading the capacity for the plants are also clearly defined.

By D. Ngan/ Ha Thanh

Related News

Note for businesses when converting green and digital

Note for businesses when converting green and digital

VCN - Green transformation and digital transformation have been identified by businesses as a mandatory path if they want to develop long-term. However, there are many issues that businesses need to pay attention to right from the start of the transformation if they want to achieve efficiency.
Businesses will be confident in exporting to the EU when they have enough green capacity

Businesses will be confident in exporting to the EU when they have enough green capacity

VCN - It is extremely necessary to grasp and understand the new EU regulations such as CBAM and EUDR. Thereby, businesses have plans, measures and roadmaps to adjust export production activities, maintain and develop export markets.
State earns nearly VND1,200 trillion in first seven months

State earns nearly VND1,200 trillion in first seven months

VCN - According to the General Statistics Office, state budget revenue in the first seven months of 2024 is estimated to increase by 14.6% year-on-year. State budget spending is estimated to increase by 0.6% year-on-year, meeting the needs of socio-economic development, national defense, security, state management, payment of due debts as well as timely payments for beneficiaries.
Vung Ang Customs earns VND4,482.87 billion

Vung Ang Customs earns VND4,482.87 billion

VCN - According to statistics from Vung Ang Port Border Gate Customs Branch (Ha Tinh Customs Department), as of July 15, 2024, total import-export turnover through the area rose by 12.9% and budget revenue also rose by 15.2% over the same period in 2023.

Latest News

Vietnam’s stainless steel exports under dual investigation

Vietnam’s stainless steel exports under dual investigation

The US Department of Commerce (DOC) has initiated an anti-dumping and countervailing duty investigation into corrosion-resistant steel (CORE) imported from Vietnam, alongside nine other countries and territories.
F&B industry to reach 30 billion USD in 2024

F&B industry to reach 30 billion USD in 2024

The Ministry of Industry and Trade (MoIT) forecasts that the revenue of the food and beverage (F&B) industry will grow by 10.92% this year, reaching more than 720 trillion VND (29.8 billion USD).
Self-sufficiency in raw materials critical for garment, footwear

Self-sufficiency in raw materials critical for garment, footwear

Vietnam needs breakthrough solutions to upgrade the value chains of the garment and footwear industries with the focus on achieving self-sufficiency in raw materials to increase added value and develop sustainably.
To successfully export fresh coconuts to China

To successfully export fresh coconuts to China

VCN - The large demand of the Chinese market not only exposes a "golden” opportunity to the Vietnamese coconut industry, but also poses potential risks for businesses if there is no systematic investment in raw material areas as well as strict control over the cultivation, harvesting, and processing processes...

More News

Standardising fruit quality can open up new markets for Vietnam: Insiders

Standardising fruit quality can open up new markets for Vietnam: Insiders

There is plenty of room for Vietnamese fruit and vegetables to enter more stringent markets such as the US, Australia, and the EU by focusing on high-quality fruit, accurate origin certificates, and food safety standards, according to insiders.
Five amended laws to untie investment knots

Five amended laws to untie investment knots

VCN - According to Tran Quoc Phuong, Deputy Minister of Planning and Investment, numerous provisions within the draft Law on Public Investment (amended) and the Law amending and supplementing a number of articles of the Law on Planning, the Law on Investment, the Law on Public-Private Partnership Investment, and the Law on Bidding, will effectively remove practical obstacles and unleash resources for growth upon enactment.
Ho Chi Minh City: Determined to become the leading logistics center in the region

Ho Chi Minh City: Determined to become the leading logistics center in the region

VCN - Promoting the potential of the largest city in the country, Ho Chi Minh City has a plan to develop the logistics industry, aiming to improve the capacity of seaports and become the leading logistics center in the region.
Vietnam's rice export turnover up 23.5% in nine months

Vietnam's rice export turnover up 23.5% in nine months

Vietnam exported over 7 million tonnes of rice worth 4.37 billion USD in the first three quarters of 2024, up 9.2% in volume and 23.5% in value compared to the same period last year, the Ministry of Agriculture and Rural Development (MARD) has reported.
Responding to trade competition, businesses are forced to innovate technology

Responding to trade competition, businesses are forced to innovate technology

VCN - According to the Global Innovation Index (GII) 2024 Report published by the World Intellectual Property Organization (WIPO) a few days ago, Vietnam ranked 44th out of 133 countries, up from 46th in 2023 - continuing to improve its position since 2013.
How does the Fed

How does the Fed's interest rate cut affect Vietnam?

VCN - In the latest meeting of the Federal Open Market Committee (FOMC), the Fed decided to cut interest rates by 50 basis points to a range of 4.75%-5%. Analysts have given different perspectives on this decision.
Vietnam-France trade, investment ties expected to grow further

Vietnam-France trade, investment ties expected to grow further

The official visit to France by Party General Secretary and State President To Lam and his attendance at the 19th Francophonie Summit are expected to give a boost to the bilateral economic, trade, and investment ties.
Nine-month agro-forestry-fisheries exports rise 21%

Nine-month agro-forestry-fisheries exports rise 21%

Vietnam earned 46.28 billion USD from exporting agricultural, forestry and fishery products, while spending 32.42 billion USD importing them in the first nine months of 2024, up 21% and 7.5% year-on-year, respectively.
Vietnamese fruits have room to penetrate deeper into the Chinese market

Vietnamese fruits have room to penetrate deeper into the Chinese market

VCN - On September 29, the first Vietnam Fruit Festival opened in Beijing, China. The event is expected to open up more opportunities for fruit exports to this large market.
Read More

Your care

Latest Most read
Vietnam’s stainless steel exports under dual investigation

Vietnam’s stainless steel exports under dual investigation

The US Department of Commerce (DOC) has initiated an anti-dumping and countervailing duty investigation into corrosion-resistant steel (CORE) imported from Vietnam, alongside nine other countries and territories.
F&B industry to reach 30 billion USD in 2024

F&B industry to reach 30 billion USD in 2024

The Ministry of Industry and Trade (MoIT) forecasts that the revenue of the food and beverage (F&B) industry will grow by 10.92% this year, reaching more than 720 trillion VND (29.8 billion USD).
Self-sufficiency in raw materials critical for garment, footwear

Self-sufficiency in raw materials critical for garment, footwear

Vietnam needs breakthrough solutions to upgrade the value chains of the garment and footwear industries with the focus on achieving self-sufficiency in raw materials to increase added value and develop sustainably.
To successfully export fresh coconuts to China

To successfully export fresh coconuts to China

The large demand of the Chinese market not only exposes a "golden” opportunity to the Vietnamese coconut industry, but also poses potential risks for businesses
Standardising fruit quality can open up new markets for Vietnam: Insiders

Standardising fruit quality can open up new markets for Vietnam: Insiders

There is plenty of room for Vietnamese fruit and vegetables to enter more stringent markets such as the US, Australia, and the EU by focusing on high-quality fruit, accurate origin certificates, and food safety standards, according to insiders.
Mobile Version