Businesses worry about "revealing secrets" if reducing the proportion of shares with the right to access information

VCN- The Draft Law amending and supplementing a number of articles of the Law on Investment and the Enterprise Law has proposed to reduce the percentage of shares needed to have the right to access internal information from 10% to 1%, causing controversy among businesses and experts.
businesses worry about revealing secrets if reducing the proportion of shares with the right to access information Hindrances preventing FIEs from listing on stock market
businesses worry about revealing secrets if reducing the proportion of shares with the right to access information Consulting on IPO and transfer of State capital in the form of book building
businesses worry about revealing secrets if reducing the proportion of shares with the right to access information Equitised SOEs struggle to attract strategic investors
businesses worry about revealing secrets if reducing the proportion of shares with the right to access information
One percent of enterprise’s sharesare very big, no one is willing to risk their interest to make it difficult for businesses. Photo: Internet

Competitors cause difficulties

The Draft Law amending and supplementing a number of articles of the Law on Investment and the Law on Enterprises proposing amending Clause 2, Article 114 of the Law on Enterprises in the direction of reducing the percentage of owning shareholding by shareholders or groups of shareholders from 1% of the total number of common shares or a smaller percentage as stipulated in the company's charter has rights such as: requesting to review and extract the minutes book and resolutions of the Board of Directors, report semi-annual and annual financial statements according to the Vietnamese accounting system and reports of the Supervisory Board; requesting to convene an extraordinary General Meeting of Shareholders; requesting the Supervisory Board to examine each specific issue related to the management and administration of the company's operations ifnecessary.At the same time, the Draft Law also abolishes the condition of share ownership in the continuousperiod for at least 6 months.

According to Mr. Phan Le Hoang, Deputy General Director of the Pacific corporation, it is appropriate to remove the condition of owning shares for a continuous period of at least six months, because if they are a shareholder of the company, of course shareholders must immediately exercise their rights, regardless of if they are old or new shareholders.

However, he said that regulations on reducing the shareholding ratioof shareholders or groups of shareholders from 10% to 1% are not appropriate and does not guarantee a competitive environment for businesses.

According to Mr. Hoang, it is appropriate to protect the interests of small shareholders, but to stabilize the company, it needs to own a certain percentage to vote by the majority, ensuring the rights as well as the majorshareholders’ responsibilities.

Therefore, the representative of Pacific Corporation proposed to maintain the ownership rate of at least 10% of the total number of common shares of a shareholder or group of shareholders as prescribed in Clause 2, Article 114 of the current Enterprise Law.

Sharing the same view, Mr. Nguyen Thanh Viet, General Director of Intracom expressed his concern about the protection of business’s secrets.

“In corporate governance, professional management and protection of a business’ secrets are very important. If you do not think carefully, competitors will buy one percentand make difficult for businesses,”Mr. Viet said.

No one gets risks toharass businesses

According to Mr. Phan Duc Hieu, Deputy Director of the Central Institute for Economic Management (CIEM), corporate governance is one of the issues that needs special attention in the revision of this law. In particular, shareholder protection is the most important part of the corporate governance framework. Good shareholder protection regulations will make an important contribution to makebusinesses a safe business tool and thereby promoting and mobilizing investment capital.

Therefore, Mr. Hieu said that the above-mentioned amendment will help expand the rights of shareholders to access information about the operation of the company, creating more favorable conditions for shareholders to exercise their rights.

“In Japan, only one share is required to provide enterprise information. In Korea, the rate of 3% is applied. Therefore, we think the 1% is reasonable. We conducted a survey ofmore than three hundred companies on HoSE, and concluded that one percent of an enterprise’s shares isvery high, so no one will risk their rights related to one percent of shares to harass enterprises," Mr. Hieu stated.

In agreement, Mr. Dau Anh Tuan, Head of the Legal Department of the Chamber of Commerce and Industry (VCCI), said that the corporate governance in other countries pay shareholder rightsattention.The tendency of countries is to make people invest less capital but guarantee their benefits. However, according to Mr. Tuan, the reduction of the percentage of shareholding is still subject to scrutiny but the 1% ratio is reasonable, since 1% is not small for an investor, so they have to act based on that 1% interest.

By Huong Diu/Quynh Lan

Related News

Control of major shareholders in banks

Control of major shareholders in banks

VCN - In compliance with the provisions of the Law on Credit Institutions 2024, banks have made public the list of information on shareholders owning 1% or more of shares. This is expected to block the “octopus tentacles” of cross-ownership.
Note for businesses when converting green and digital

Note for businesses when converting green and digital

VCN - Green transformation and digital transformation have been identified by businesses as a mandatory path if they want to develop long-term. However, there are many issues that businesses need to pay attention to right from the start of the transformation if they want to achieve efficiency.
Businesses will be confident in exporting to the EU when they have enough green capacity

Businesses will be confident in exporting to the EU when they have enough green capacity

VCN - It is extremely necessary to grasp and understand the new EU regulations such as CBAM and EUDR. Thereby, businesses have plans, measures and roadmaps to adjust export production activities, maintain and develop export markets.
Vietnamese "heavyweight" competitors in overseas pangasius markets

Vietnamese "heavyweight" competitors in overseas pangasius markets

VCN - As a key export item of Vietnam's seafood industry, to maintain market share in some major markets, pangasius processing and exporting enterprises are managing to overcome "heavyweight" competitors.

Latest News

Ho Chi Minh City partners with nine provinces to boost import and export activities

Ho Chi Minh City partners with nine provinces to boost import and export activities

VCN - Ho Chi Minh City (HCMC) and nine provinces in the northern and north-central regions are cooperating in socio-economic development, leveraging each region's advantages and potential to boost import and export activities.
Vietnam

Vietnam's second rice brand enters picky Japanese market

Japonica - AAN has become the second Vietnamese rice brand to have entered Japan, with a ceremony held on October 9 to debut the produce.
Enterprises need to be ready to respond to trade defense

Enterprises need to be ready to respond to trade defense

VCN - According to the Department of Trade Defense, through the process of protecting the rights of Vietnamese manufacturing and exporting enterprises in each trade defense case, the outcome of the appeal depends largely on the quality of coordination between the parties involved.
Foreign investors interested in green development, semiconductor industry in Vietnam

Foreign investors interested in green development, semiconductor industry in Vietnam

Green, clean development and semiconductor chip production are among the sectors in Vietnam that foreign investors are interested in, according to VinaCapital CEO and Founding Partner Don Lam.

More News

Vietnam’s stainless steel exports under dual investigation

Vietnam’s stainless steel exports under dual investigation

The US Department of Commerce (DOC) has initiated an anti-dumping and countervailing duty investigation into corrosion-resistant steel (CORE) imported from Vietnam, alongside nine other countries and territories.
F&B industry to reach 30 billion USD in 2024

F&B industry to reach 30 billion USD in 2024

The Ministry of Industry and Trade (MoIT) forecasts that the revenue of the food and beverage (F&B) industry will grow by 10.92% this year, reaching more than 720 trillion VND (29.8 billion USD).
Self-sufficiency in raw materials critical for garment, footwear

Self-sufficiency in raw materials critical for garment, footwear

Vietnam needs breakthrough solutions to upgrade the value chains of the garment and footwear industries with the focus on achieving self-sufficiency in raw materials to increase added value and develop sustainably.
To successfully export fresh coconuts to China

To successfully export fresh coconuts to China

VCN - The large demand of the Chinese market not only exposes a "golden” opportunity to the Vietnamese coconut industry, but also poses potential risks for businesses if there is no systematic investment in raw material areas as well as strict control over the cultivation, harvesting, and processing processes...
Standardising fruit quality can open up new markets for Vietnam: Insiders

Standardising fruit quality can open up new markets for Vietnam: Insiders

There is plenty of room for Vietnamese fruit and vegetables to enter more stringent markets such as the US, Australia, and the EU by focusing on high-quality fruit, accurate origin certificates, and food safety standards, according to insiders.
Five amended laws to untie investment knots

Five amended laws to untie investment knots

VCN - According to Tran Quoc Phuong, Deputy Minister of Planning and Investment, numerous provisions within the draft Law on Public Investment (amended) and the Law amending and supplementing a number of articles of the Law on Planning, the Law on Investment, the Law on Public-Private Partnership Investment, and the Law on Bidding, will effectively remove practical obstacles and unleash resources for growth upon enactment.
Ho Chi Minh City: Determined to become the leading logistics center in the region

Ho Chi Minh City: Determined to become the leading logistics center in the region

VCN - Promoting the potential of the largest city in the country, Ho Chi Minh City has a plan to develop the logistics industry, aiming to improve the capacity of seaports and become the leading logistics center in the region.
Vietnam's rice export turnover up 23.5% in nine months

Vietnam's rice export turnover up 23.5% in nine months

Vietnam exported over 7 million tonnes of rice worth 4.37 billion USD in the first three quarters of 2024, up 9.2% in volume and 23.5% in value compared to the same period last year, the Ministry of Agriculture and Rural Development (MARD) has reported.
Responding to trade competition, businesses are forced to innovate technology

Responding to trade competition, businesses are forced to innovate technology

VCN - According to the Global Innovation Index (GII) 2024 Report published by the World Intellectual Property Organization (WIPO) a few days ago, Vietnam ranked 44th out of 133 countries, up from 46th in 2023 - continuing to improve its position since 2013.
Read More

Your care

Latest Most read
Ho Chi Minh City partners with nine provinces to boost import and export activities

Ho Chi Minh City partners with nine provinces to boost import and export activities

VCN - Specific cooperation programs, from promoting local products in HCMC to projects on human resource training and digital transformation, have yielded practical outcomes. Nearly 10 regional coordination activities have been implemented with the partic
Vietnam

Vietnam's second rice brand enters picky Japanese market

Japonica - AAN has become the second Vietnamese rice brand to have entered Japan, with a ceremony held on October 9 to debut the produce.
Enterprises need to be ready to respond to trade defense

Enterprises need to be ready to respond to trade defense

VCN - According to the Department of Trade Defense, through the process of protecting the rights of Vietnamese manufacturing and exporting enterprises in each trade defense case, the outcome of the appeal depends largely on the quality of coordination bet
Foreign investors interested in green development, semiconductor industry in Vietnam

Foreign investors interested in green development, semiconductor industry in Vietnam

Green, clean development and semiconductor chip production are among the sectors in Vietnam that foreign investors are interested in, according to VinaCapital CEO and Founding Partner Don Lam.
Vietnam’s stainless steel exports under dual investigation

Vietnam’s stainless steel exports under dual investigation

The US Department of Commerce (DOC) has initiated an anti-dumping and countervailing duty investigation into corrosion-resistant steel (CORE) imported from Vietnam, alongside nine other countries and territories.
Mobile Version