Are foreign-invested firms enjoying too many incentives in Vietnam?

Preferential treatments including tax and land use incentives are a key factor in the Vietnamese government s bid to attract foreign investment however domestic enterprises are beginning to voice their complaints.

Foreign companies in Vietnam are enjoying massive tax and other incentives, giving them an advantage over already less-competitive domestic businesses.

For example, Samsung, which is operating in Vietnam through various entities, topped the Vietnamese finance ministry’s list of 100 foreign companies with the biggest tax reductions in 2016.

All of Samsung’s various subsidiaries in Vietnam collectively had their taxes reduced by nearly US$1 billion last year. Of these, Samsung Electronics Vietnam Thai Nguyen alone enjoyed total tax incentives worth VND10.36 trillion (US$456.39 million), according to finance ministry data.

are foreign invested firms enjoying too many incentives in vietnam

Employees make their way to work at the Samsung factory in Thai Nguyen Province, north of Hanoi, Vietnam October 13, 2016. Photo: Reuters

A finance ministry official said that these incentives are legally granted as per Vietnam’s policy of attracting foreign investment and boosting productivity.

The incentives are available to any company meeting specific criteria, but the problem is that very few Vietnamese companies qualify, the official added.

While the tax reductions foreign companies can enjoy can total as much as 91.9% of their corporate income tax bill, Vietnamese companies and state enterprises can be entitled to a mere 17.8% and 4.8% reduction respectively, according to the same finance ministry official.

Another expert from the finance ministry said that besides reductions in corporate income tax, some foreign businesses are also given incentives in import and value-added taxes.

“For a few foreign businesses, the total amount of tax reductions they have enjoyed since beginning operations in Vietnam is larger than their total investment in the country,” he added.

Unfairness

Firms that benefit from the preferential treatment in Vietnam say they are doing nothing wrong.

A Samsung Electronics Vietnam representative told Tuoi Tre (Youth) newspaper that Samsung is receiving the same tax breaks as other foreign tech companies in the country.

The incentives include a corporate income tax exemption for the first four years of operations, and a preferential tax rate of five percent over the next nine years. From the 14th year of operations onward, the tax rate will be set at ten percent.

However, experts believe that the current preferential treatment of foreign companies is weakening the competitive edge of local enterprises, both private and state-run.

Lawyer Bui Quang Tin, who is regarded as an economic expert, said that Vietnamese companies are being treated unfairly.

“Offering incentives to attract foreign investment is the right policy, but the other side of the coin is that local businesses will become less competitive,” he said.

Tin suggested that the government review the policy to ensure fairness between domestic and foreign enterprises.

“We should focus on enabling domestic companies to grow, rather than only on attracting foreign investment,” he said.

Dinh The Hien, another economist, echoed Tin’s view that there is unfairness between foreign and domestic businesses when it comes to tax incentives.

Hien recommended that the government give fewer preferential treatments to foreign companies, so all companies, domestic or foreign, can compete equally.

“Tax incentives should be given to companies based on their field of investment rather than whether they are domestic or foreign,” he added.

Source: TuoitreNews

Related News

Vietnam is ready to welcome a new wave of investment in the semiconductor industry

Vietnam is ready to welcome a new wave of investment in the semiconductor industry

VCN - Deputy Minister of Planning and Investment Tran Duy Dong (Photo) gave an interview to Customs Magazine about Vietnam's preparations to attract FDI into the semiconductor industry.
Opportunities for Vietnam to participate in the global semiconductor industry value chain

Opportunities for Vietnam to participate in the global semiconductor industry value chain

VCN - The global chip race is heating up, and Vietnam has a unique opportunity to assert itself as one of the participants in the semiconductor industry value chain.
Ho Chi Minh City: Enterprises overcome difficulties, exports lead the country

Ho Chi Minh City: Enterprises overcome difficulties, exports lead the country

VCN - HCM City led the nation in exports. In order to get this result, in addition to the market's recovery signal, there are also the efforts of businesses to overcome difficulties.
What to do to develop Vietnam

What to do to develop Vietnam's creative economy?

VCN - According to MSc. Nguyen Anh Duong (photo), Director of the Department for General Economic Issues and Integration Studies under the Central Institute for Economic Management (CIEM), to develop the creative economy in Vietnam, it is necessary to first improve the institutional framework and policies to create a legal framework suitable for the development of the creative economy, creative industries and culture, and creative cultural markets.

Latest News

Imports and exports achieve US$239 billion by the end of April

Imports and exports achieve US$239 billion by the end of April

VCN - The import-export turnover in April witnessed a slight decrease compared to the previous month but it is still high with more than US$60 billion.
Spending more than US$31 billion for importing computers and electronic products in 4 months

Spending more than US$31 billion for importing computers and electronic products in 4 months

VCN - Computers, electronic products, and components are the group of imported commodities with the largest scale in the country.
Multi-dimensional picture of textile and garment enterprises

Multi-dimensional picture of textile and garment enterprises

VCN - Despite a quite positive start in the first quarter of 2024, the textile and garment industry has still faced many challenges from new requirements of importing countries, requiring enterprises to have proactive solutions to respond.
Promoting Vietnamese pharmaceutical industry

Promoting Vietnamese pharmaceutical industry

Vietnamese pharmaceutical market grew from $2.7 billion in 2015 to $7 billion in 2022 and is forecast to reach more than $10 billion by 2026.

More News

HCM City to host iTech Expo 2024 in July

HCM City to host iTech Expo 2024 in July

The first-ever international technology exposition (iTech Expo) 2024 will take place in Ho Chi Minh from July 10-12, featuring 500 booths from leading technology countries and territories around the world, heard a press conference on May 20.
Pangasius exports are forecasted to bounce back at the end of the year

Pangasius exports are forecasted to bounce back at the end of the year

VCN - It is forecasted that pangasius exports is forecasted to be better from the third and fourth quarters of 2024, leading to the uptrend being adjusted to increase by at least about 10% compared to the current price.
Exports to the US reaches over US$6 billion

Exports to the US reaches over US$6 billion

VCN - The US continues to be Vietnam's largest export market and achieves positive growth.
Market diversification key for enterprises to expand exports

Market diversification key for enterprises to expand exports

Vietnamese enterprises need to meet quality requirements and rules of origin, increase value-added content, and diversify markets, as production and business activities are forecast to face many challenges due to the unpredictable global economy and climate change.
Businesses advised to focus on brand protection in online export

Businesses advised to focus on brand protection in online export

As more and more Vietnamese businesses are using international e-commerce platforms such as Amazon, eBay and Alibaba to expand market, experts have advised domestic firms to pay greater attention to the protection of trademark in the cyberspace, especially during online exporting activities.
Find solutions to attract goods through the first specialized container port in Vietnam

Find solutions to attract goods through the first specialized container port in Vietnam

VCN- As the first specialized container port in Vietnam with 25 years of operation, the volume of goods passing through the international container port of Vietnam (VICT) is still very modest. Mr. Truong Nguyen Linh, Deputy General Director of VICT port, has shared solutions to attract cargo through this port.
Textiles and footwear in a greening spiral

Textiles and footwear in a greening spiral

VCN - More and more regulations on sustainable development are issued in major markets such as the US and EU, imposing pressure on Vietnamese textile and garment enterprises to be faster on the green roadmap.
Agricultural, forestry and fishery product exports continue to "scoring points"

Agricultural, forestry and fishery product exports continue to "scoring points"

VCN - In the first four months of 2024, the country's total export turnover of agricultural, forestry and fishery products is estimated to reach more than US$19 billion, an increase of 23.7 percent compared to the same period last year. Most key agricultural and forestry export products increased higher than the same period last year as well as the export value to all markets increased.
Build and protect the rice value chain against market fluctuations

Build and protect the rice value chain against market fluctuations

VCN - Due to recent risks and challenges,business performancehave been badly hurt andmany chain links have been under threats ..., the rice industry needs to enhance the role of ministries, branches, localities, and farmers and businesses in building and protecting the rice value chain against market fluctuations.
Read More

Your care

Latest Most read
Imports and exports achieve US$239 billion by the end of April

Imports and exports achieve US$239 billion by the end of April

The import-export turnover in April witnessed a slight decrease compared to the previous month but it is still high with more than US$60 billion.
Spending more than US$31 billion for importing computers and electronic products in 4 months

Spending more than US$31 billion for importing computers and electronic products in 4 months

Computers, electronic products, and components are the group of imported commodities with the largest scale in the country.
Multi-dimensional picture of textile and garment enterprises

Multi-dimensional picture of textile and garment enterprises

VCN - The financial report of Thanh Cong Textile - Investment - Trading Joint Stock Company recorded revenue of more than VND 934 billion in the first quarter 2024, an increase of 7% compared to the same period in 2023; Net profit reached over VND 62 bill
Promoting Vietnamese pharmaceutical industry

Promoting Vietnamese pharmaceutical industry

Vietnamese pharmaceutical market grew from $2.7 billion in 2015 to $7 billion in 2022 and is forecast to reach more than $10 billion by 2026.
HCM City to host iTech Expo 2024 in July

HCM City to host iTech Expo 2024 in July

The first-ever international technology exposition (iTech Expo) 2024 will take place in Ho Chi Minh from July 10-12, featuring 500 booths from leading technology countries and territories around the world, heard a press conference on May 20.
Mobile Version