Will new rule eliminate "chaos" of maintenance fee disputes?

VCN - The Ministry of Construction has proposed many solutions to eliminate the "chaos" of maintenance fee disputes related to apartments.
will new rule eliminate chaos of maintenance fee disputes The 1,000th online public service on National Online Public Service Portal is belonged to Tax sector
will new rule eliminate chaos of maintenance fee disputes EU increases purchases of Vietnamese coffee
will new rule eliminate chaos of maintenance fee disputes Seaport fees should be increased: say insiders
will new rule eliminate chaos of maintenance fee disputes
Controversy about investors voluntarily using the maintenance fee and late handing over the maintenance fee of the building to the Management Board has caused more disputes in apartment projects. Photo: ST

Terminate arbitrary use of maintenance fee

To prevent investors from arbitrary use of the maintenance fee in apartment projects, the Ministry of Construction is revising Decree 99/2015/ND-CP detailing and guiding the implementation of some articles of the Housing Law.

According to the Ministry of Construction, based on the provisions of Decree 99, investors must set up an account for apartment buyers and tenants to pay 2% of the maintenance of the apartment building. However, in reality, there are some cases in which investors voluntarily used this account before handing it over to the Management Board, leading to difficulties in the settlement and recovery of this fund to hand it to the Management Board.

Moreover, according to the current regulations, apartment buyers have to directly pay the maintenance fee to the account stated in the contract or submit it to the investor for the investor to transfer it into the maintenance budget account. However, the regulation of the two forms of payment above also leads to the fact that the investor has used this fund before handing it over to the Management Board, leading to difficulties in handover.

To end this situation, according to the Ministry of Construction, it is necessary to remove the regulation on the form of direct payment to investors. Furthermore, some localities suggested that in the revised Decree, it is necessary to specify the maintenance budget account as a "closed" account, the investor is not allowed to use it until it is handed over to the Management Board. Accordingly, the Ministry of Construction proposed investors set up a specialized capital account for buyers, tenants, and investors to pay 2% of the maintenance fee into this account. This modification ensures that the specialized capital account is implemented as a "closed" account, investors cannot arbitrarily use it for other purposes. At the same time, the Ministry of Construction proposed to provide a way for apartment buyers to pay directly into the account for the maintenance of shared portions of the apartment building and remove the regulation to pay directly to investors.

The amendment is expected to remedy the situation in which investors have full control over the maintenance budget, leading to abuse of this fund, causing fierce disputes in many apartment projects.

According to Nguyen The Diep, Hanoi Real Estate Club, if the proposal to set up a closed account for residents to pay 2% of the maintenance fund, then hand over the maintenance fund to residents is implemented, it will be a good solution to ensure interests of buyers, a good step in building an apartment management process, reducing complaints and disputes over the maintenance fund of the apartment building as in the past.

Regarding this issue, Nguyen Minh Tuan, Chairman and General Director of VietBuildings Co., Ltd., said up to now, apartment buyers have paid the maintenance fee directly to investors. Meanwhile, the maintenance fund of large projects can be up to several hundred billion VND, for example, Times City project (VND600 billion) and Royal City (more than VND400 billion). For small projects, the maintenance fee can be from VND5-10 billion. Therefore, it will be difficult to avoid the desire to appropriate the capital, causing disputes in the management process.

“The positive part of the draft amendment is forcing investors to set up a separate account for the maintenance fee, bank designation and no cash payment regulations. In the detailed guidance circular, it is necessary to clearly stipulate the sanctions for blocking that account to avoid appropriation as before,” said Tuan.

Drastic measures for slow handover of the fund

Regarding the shortcomings in the handover of the maintenance fee, the Ministry of Construction also mentioned problems related to the case of the investor's property disposal to recover the maintenance cost for the Management Board. The Ministry of Construction said that according to current regulations, in the decision to enforce the withdrawal, the provincial People's Committee must clearly state the measures to handle the property. However, during implementation, localities encountered problems because they did not know how to handle the property, which made it difficult to force the handover of the maintenance fund to the Management Board.

Accordingly, within three days from the date of receiving the decision on enforcement from the provincial People's Committee, the credit institution that is managing the deposit account for apartment building maintenance or other investor's accounts under the enforcement decision will transfer the fund to the account established by the Management Board to manage and use it in accordance with the law on housing and the enforcement decision. In case the investor's property must be handled to recover the maintenance cost for the Management Board, the provincial People's Committee will sanction the administrative violation for the investor's failure to hand over the maintenance fee according to the regulation. In the decision to sanction the administrative violation, it must clearly state the investor's measure of distraining the property for auction in accordance with the law on property auction to recover the maintenance fund to the Management Board.

According to experts, this proposal is a drastic measure by the Ministry of Construction to effectively deal with the fact that investors are slow to return the maintenance fund to the Management Board. Nguyen The Diep stated that property auctions are a tough, drastic and necessary solution to ensure interests of apartment buyers, creating a healthy real estate market and ensuring the integrity of the law. However, this expert also noted that the property enforcement and property auction was just a temporary solution, the implementation would not be simple. Account blockade was a more viable solution.

According to Truong Anh Tu, Chairman of TAT Law firm, this measure is new, demonstrating the determination of lawmakers to recover the maintenance fee of apartment buildings from investors who violated the law. However, practical application can face difficulties. Because, in fact, the implementation of this content has not been effective in the past. The reason is that credit institutions or tax authorities do not provide information and cannot determine whether the investor's account has money or not. This results in an enforcement decision being irrevocable or a very small amount recovered.

“The strong handling related to the enforcement of this property may cause a reaction from investors. However, this is a necessary regulation to prevent and solve the investor's violations against the people in the management of apartment buildings,” said Tu.

By Hoai Anh/ Ha Thanh

Related News

Credit package of VND120 trillion: must be disbursed as soon as conditions are met

Credit package of VND120 trillion: must be disbursed as soon as conditions are met

VCN - According to the State Bank of Vietnam (SBV), so far, only 28 out of 63 provincial People's Committees have sent documents or announced the list of projects participating in the VND120 trillion credit package, including 30 out of 68 projects with capital borrowing needs.
Tighten regulations on insurance contracts

Tighten regulations on insurance contracts

VCN - The Law on Insurance Business is amended and supplemented towards transparency in contracts to minimize misunderstandings leading to disputes and lawsuits.
Industrial real estate is still the fertile land

Industrial real estate is still the fertile land

VCN- Assessing the real estate market in 2021 by market segment, according to experts and firms in the survey of Vietnam Report Joint Stock Company (Vietnam Report), some segments that will continue to attract cash flow areindustrial real estate, mid-range apartments priced from 25 - 30 million/square metres serving real needs, real estate services, housing associated with industrial zones with prices from 1-3 billion and mountain resort real estate.
Banking fees reduced for businesses providing transportation services

Banking fees reduced for businesses providing transportation services

The National Payment Corporation of Vietnam NAPAS and the Joint Stock Commercial Bank for Foreign Trade of Vietnam Vietcombank on April 16 announced a COVID 19 discount programme for businesses providing transportation services

Latest News

VN

VN's food processing industry struggles to improve quality and value chain integration

Despite accounting for 19.1 per cent of Việt Nam’s processing sector, the food processing industry has been struggling with major issues such as poor-quality raw materials and subpar value chain integration, said industry insiders and economists.
Approach strategy of the seafood industry when implementing UKVFTA

Approach strategy of the seafood industry when implementing UKVFTA

VCN - As one of Vietnam's strong export industries to the UK, especially when the Vietnam - United Kingdom of Great Britain and Northern Ireland Free Trade Agreement (UKVFTA) comes into effect, with a detailed information approach strategy, it has created a great driving force to promote the export of Vietnamese seafood products to this market.
Mid-November: Vietnam

Mid-November: Vietnam's trade volume matches 2023 total, eyes record-breaking growth

VCN - By mid-November 2024, Vietnam's total import-export turnover reached an impressive US$681.48 billion, equaling the full-year trade figure for 2023
Vietnamese enterprises facing challenges from cross-border e-commerce platforms

Vietnamese enterprises facing challenges from cross-border e-commerce platforms

VCN – In recent years, with the rapid development of cross-border e-commerce (CBEC) platforms, domestic enterprises in Vietnam have been facing numerous difficulties and challenges.

More News

Vietnam, Malaysia eye new milestone in trade ties

Vietnam, Malaysia eye new milestone in trade ties

The official visit to Malaysia from November 21-23 by Party General Secretary To Lam is expected to open up new opportunities for and mark a new milestone in the economic and trade cooperation between Vietnam and Malaysia. Vietnam and Malaysia are key economic, trade, and investment partners. Their economic and trade ties have steadily grown since the two nations established diplomatic relations in 1973.
Shrimp exports surge in 10 months, generating 3.2 billion USD

Shrimp exports surge in 10 months, generating 3.2 billion USD

Vietnam’s shrimp exports in October reached US$394 million, a strong 24% increase year-on-year, according to the Vietnam Association of Seafood Exporters and Producers (VASEP).
Vietnam’s exports to the U.S. near US$100 billion milestone

Vietnam’s exports to the U.S. near US$100 billion milestone

VCN - By the end of October, Vietnam's exports to the United States approached US$100 billion, reaffirming its position as Vietnam's largest export market.
From the “abnormal” coffee price, worries about the new crop

From the “abnormal” coffee price, worries about the new crop

VCN - The Vietnamese coffee industry enters the new crop with the question of what is a reasonable price to ensure benefits for coffee growers while still retaining international consumers.
What obstacles limit the market share of Vietnamese goods in the UK?

What obstacles limit the market share of Vietnamese goods in the UK?

VCN - Vietnamese goods account for only about 1% of total imports into the UK market. One of the reasons is that they have not yet built their own brands and have not focused on effective strategies and approaches to market information.
Why seafood exports to some Middle Eastern Countries are stalled

Why seafood exports to some Middle Eastern Countries are stalled

VCN - Several shipments of seafood exported to certain Middle Eastern countries have been delayed due to legal challenges related to consular legalization procedures. This has created significant bottlenecks in accessing these markets.
Storm No. 3 destroys profits of many insurance companies

Storm No. 3 destroys profits of many insurance companies

VCN - Due to the impact of storm No. 3, the business results of the third quarter and the first 9 months of 2024 of the insurance sector have been significantly affected. This requires more efforts from businesses for the results of the whole year 2024.
Vietnam, Malaysia eye golden partnership opportunities in Halal industry

Vietnam, Malaysia eye golden partnership opportunities in Halal industry

Cooperation in the Halal industry can help Vietnamese products reach nearly 2 billion Muslim consumers worldwide, representing over 24% of the global population, according to Malaysia’s Minister of Investment, Trade, and Industry Zafrul Abdul Aziz.
Tra fish sector aiming for production, processing greening for sustainable development

Tra fish sector aiming for production, processing greening for sustainable development

Greening production and processing to meet export requirements is both a trend and a necessity for many industries, including the tra fish sector.
Read More

Your care

Latest Most read
VN

VN's food processing industry struggles to improve quality and value chain integration

Despite accounting for 19.1 per cent of Việt Nam’s processing sector, the food processing industry has been struggling with major issues such as poor-quality raw materials and subpar value chain integration, said industry insiders and economists.
Approach strategy of the seafood industry when implementing UKVFTA

Approach strategy of the seafood industry when implementing UKVFTA

VCN - Mr. Nguyen Hoai Nam, Deputy General Secretary, Vietnam Association of Seafood Exporters and Producers (VASEP), said that the advantage that UKVFTA brings is that the main products of the seafood industry enjoy 0% import tax to the UK, especially key
Mid-November: Vietnam

Mid-November: Vietnam's trade volume matches 2023 total, eyes record-breaking growth

By mid-November 2024, Vietnam's total import-export turnover reached an impressive US$681.48 billion, equaling the full-year trade figure for 2023
Vietnamese enterprises facing challenges from cross-border e-commerce platforms

Vietnamese enterprises facing challenges from cross-border e-commerce platforms

VCN - E-commerce platforms have emerged as crucial distribution channels, enabling goods to reach consumers quickly and conveniently.
Vietnam, Malaysia eye new milestone in trade ties

Vietnam, Malaysia eye new milestone in trade ties

The official visit to Malaysia from November 21-23 by Party General Secretary To Lam is expected to open up new opportunities for and mark a new milestone in the economic and trade cooperation between Vietnam and Malaysia. Vietnam and Malaysia are key economic, trade, and investment partners. Their economic and trade ties have steadily grown since the two nations established diplomatic relations in 1973.
Mobile Version