Surrogate country and surrogate value promote Vietnamese exports to US
The high quality Vietnamese goods exported to US market have benefitted the Vietnamese producers as well as US consumers.
In the meantime, a litany of US Anti-dumping (“AD”) cases were filed in order to stymie the Vietnamese exports of goods. In such difficult times, surrogate value experts have played an important role in promoting Vietnamese exports to the USA.
In AD Investigations, the Vietnamese goods are alleged to be exported to the US market at less than their fair market value. Since the US Department of Commerce (“DOC”) treats Vietnam as a non-market economy (“NME”) country, it rejects all the cost and price data reported from Vietnam and determines the fair market value by constructing the cost of goods in a third country, called surrogate country.
As such, the choice of a surrogate country and surrogate value data holds the key to the outcome in the Vietnamese AD proceedings.
To illustrate, in the US AD case on pangasius frozen fish fillets from Vietnam, up until the fifth administrative review of the AD Order, Bangladesh was consistently selected as the surrogate country.
The fair value based on the Bangladeshi surrogate values yielded reasonable AD margins, which was not to the liking of the Petitioners, Catfish Farmers of America (“CFA”).
Therefore, in the sixth administrative review, CFA argued that DOC reject Bangladesh as the surrogate country. In the preliminary results, DOC preferred the Philippines as the surrogate country, citing its superior fish price data. This switch resulted in very high preliminary AD margin.
At this point, VASEP’s surrogate value expert from GDLSK LLP has diligently worked in Bangladesh and discovered a new price data source published by the Bangladeshi Department of Agricultural Marketing (“DAM”) to value whole live pangasius fish. He also persuaded DAM to officially release its price data along with several clarificatory letters. All of these information were then submitted before DOC.
In the Final results issued in March 2011, in a remarkable turnaround, the DOC switched its surrogate country choice back to Bangladesh, citing the robustness of the DAM data for whole fish. As a result, the AD margins in the sixth review swung back to near zero level and the moribund Vietnamese exports to US was reinvigorated.
In the preliminary results of the subsequent seventh administrative review, DOC selected Indonesia as the surrogate country. This time, VASEP’s surrogate value expert undertook extensive field trips in Bangladesh and Indonesia. In Bangladesh, he persuaded the government to publish the DAM data online. In Indonesia, he had the then Director General of Indonesian Aquaculture Statistics (“IAS”), Mr. Ketuk Sugama, issue a detailed affidavit, clarifying the IAS data for whole fish.
In an encore, in the Final results issued in March, 2012, the Department switched back to Bangladesh. Commerce was persuaded to make this improbable switch solely on account of new and invaluable information obtained by the surrogate value expert from Bangladesh and Indonesia.
Notably, Commerce’s final results in the sixth and seventh administrative reviews have also been affirmed by the Court of International Trade (“CIT”).
In recent AD proceedings, DOC has preferred Indonesia over Bangladesh, notwithstanding that Indonesia was not even economically comparable to Vietnam. These decisions are pending in litigation. For future AD proceedings, VASEP’s surrogate value expert is engaged in a global research to identify the most suitable surrogate country.
Let’s hope that with excellent work of surrogate value experts, the future would be brighter for Vietnamese exports to the US.
Related News
Enhance the core values of the national brand
15:36 | 02/05/2024 Import-Export
Vietnam has a trade deficit of over US$17 billion with China
15:34 | 24/04/2024 Import-Export
Export turnover reaches over US$200 billion in the first half of April
15:04 | 28/04/2024 Import-Export
Developing a strong brand contributes to increased export revenue
07:49 | 29/04/2024 Import-Export
Latest News
More businesses to join Vietnam E-Pavilion
16:34 | 05/05/2024 Import-Export
Cooperatives urged to focus on branding to expand exports of organic tea
16:32 | 05/05/2024 Import-Export
Seafood enterprises encounter problems with specialized inspection
10:37 | 05/05/2024 Import-Export
Three groups of export commodities achieved billions of USD
10:36 | 05/05/2024 Import-Export
More News
Speed up the process of issuing "passports" for durian exports
15:14 | 04/05/2024 Import-Export
Vietnamese pomelo likely to be exported to Australia
15:12 | 04/05/2024 Import-Export
Take advantage of E-commerce leverage for export.
13:48 | 04/05/2024 Import-Export
Central beach city to lure investment from potential partners
14:54 | 03/05/2024 Import-Export
Vietnam to have enough 8 million tonnes of rice for export
14:47 | 03/05/2024 Import-Export
Binh Duong: Fertile ground for logistics businesses
10:16 | 03/05/2024 Import-Export
Some 51,600 new firms established in four months
17:17 | 02/05/2024 Import-Export
Agro-forestry-aquatic product exports post trade surplus of 4.74 billion USD in four months
17:13 | 02/05/2024 Import-Export
Solutions for maintaining Vietnam's position as a bright spot for foreign direct investment
15:36 | 02/05/2024 Import-Export
Your care
More businesses to join Vietnam E-Pavilion
16:34 | 05/05/2024 Import-Export
Cooperatives urged to focus on branding to expand exports of organic tea
16:32 | 05/05/2024 Import-Export
Seafood enterprises encounter problems with specialized inspection
10:37 | 05/05/2024 Import-Export
Three groups of export commodities achieved billions of USD
10:36 | 05/05/2024 Import-Export
Speed up the process of issuing "passports" for durian exports
15:14 | 04/05/2024 Import-Export