Surrogate country and surrogate value promote Vietnamese exports to US

After signing of a Bilateral Trade Agreement (“BTA”) in 2000, the trade between Vietnam and US flourished.
surrogate country and surrogate value promote vietnamese exports to us

The high quality Vietnamese goods exported to US market have benefitted the Vietnamese producers as well as US consumers.

In the meantime, a litany of US Anti-dumping (“AD”) cases were filed in order to stymie the Vietnamese exports of goods. In such difficult times, surrogate value experts have played an important role in promoting Vietnamese exports to the USA.

In AD Investigations, the Vietnamese goods are alleged to be exported to the US market at less than their fair market value. Since the US Department of Commerce (“DOC”) treats Vietnam as a non-market economy (“NME”) country, it rejects all the cost and price data reported from Vietnam and determines the fair market value by constructing the cost of goods in a third country, called surrogate country.

As such, the choice of a surrogate country and surrogate value data holds the key to the outcome in the Vietnamese AD proceedings.

To illustrate, in the US AD case on pangasius frozen fish fillets from Vietnam, up until the fifth administrative review of the AD Order, Bangladesh was consistently selected as the surrogate country.

The fair value based on the Bangladeshi surrogate values yielded reasonable AD margins, which was not to the liking of the Petitioners, Catfish Farmers of America (“CFA”).

Therefore, in the sixth administrative review, CFA argued that DOC reject Bangladesh as the surrogate country. In the preliminary results, DOC preferred the Philippines as the surrogate country, citing its superior fish price data. This switch resulted in very high preliminary AD margin.

At this point, VASEP’s surrogate value expert from GDLSK LLP has diligently worked in Bangladesh and discovered a new price data source published by the Bangladeshi Department of Agricultural Marketing (“DAM”) to value whole live pangasius fish. He also persuaded DAM to officially release its price data along with several clarificatory letters. All of these information were then submitted before DOC.

In the Final results issued in March 2011, in a remarkable turnaround, the DOC switched its surrogate country choice back to Bangladesh, citing the robustness of the DAM data for whole fish. As a result, the AD margins in the sixth review swung back to near zero level and the moribund Vietnamese exports to US was reinvigorated.

In the preliminary results of the subsequent seventh administrative review, DOC selected Indonesia as the surrogate country. This time, VASEP’s surrogate value expert undertook extensive field trips in Bangladesh and Indonesia. In Bangladesh, he persuaded the government to publish the DAM data online. In Indonesia, he had the then Director General of Indonesian Aquaculture Statistics (“IAS”), Mr. Ketuk Sugama, issue a detailed affidavit, clarifying the IAS data for whole fish.

In an encore, in the Final results issued in March, 2012, the Department switched back to Bangladesh. Commerce was persuaded to make this improbable switch solely on account of new and invaluable information obtained by the surrogate value expert from Bangladesh and Indonesia.

Notably, Commerce’s final results in the sixth and seventh administrative reviews have also been affirmed by the Court of International Trade (“CIT”).

In recent AD proceedings, DOC has preferred Indonesia over Bangladesh, notwithstanding that Indonesia was not even economically comparable to Vietnam. These decisions are pending in litigation. For future AD proceedings, VASEP’s surrogate value expert is engaged in a global research to identify the most suitable surrogate country.

Let’s hope that with excellent work of surrogate value experts, the future would be brighter for Vietnamese exports to the US.

Source: VOV

Related News

In the first 15 days of 2025, total import-export turnover reached more than US$34 billion

In the first 15 days of 2025, total import-export turnover reached more than US$34 billion

VCN - Total import-export turnover in the first half of January 2025 reached more than US$34 billion, the trade balance had a deficit of nearly US$2 billion.
Highlights of imports and exports in 2024

Highlights of imports and exports in 2024

VCN – In 2024, import and export set a new record of US$786.29 billion, including many outstanding results from key markets and industries.
Vietnam-China trade hits record of US$200 billion

Vietnam-China trade hits record of US$200 billion

VCN – Vietnam-China trade reached a new record of US$ 200 billion in 2024. However, the country’s deficit grows, the General Department reports.
Complying with regulations of each market for smooth fruit and vegetable exports

Complying with regulations of each market for smooth fruit and vegetable exports

VCN - According to Mr. Dang Phuc Nguyen (photo), General Secretary of the Vietnam Fruit and Vegetable Association (Vinafruit), with the development momentum and increasing consumption demand from the Chinese market, the Vietnamese fruit and vegetable industry is setting new records and is expected to reach an export turnover of US $10 billion by 2030. With great potential and advantages in developing agricultural products, Vietnam has been affirming its position as one of the world's leading agricultural exporters.

Latest News

VN

VN's car industry to diversify supply chain

While China remains a significant supplier, recent trade data highlights Việt Nam’s efforts to diversify supply to meet industry demands.
Exports of agro-forestry-aquatic products down nearly 5 per cent in January

Exports of agro-forestry-aquatic products down nearly 5 per cent in January

Việt Nam’s export value of agro-forestry-aquatic products was estimated at US$5.08 billion in January, marking a 4.9 per cent decline compared to the same period last year.
Thailand reviews anti-dumping tax on Vietnamese steel

Thailand reviews anti-dumping tax on Vietnamese steel

TRAV recommended that the Việt Nam Steel Association (VSA) notify relevant local manufacturers and exporters to answer the investigation questionnaire within the prescribed deadline.
Pangasius fetch record price in early 2025

Pangasius fetch record price in early 2025

Currently, larger pangasius weighing over 1.2kg, are selling at VNĐ32,440 (US$1.29) per kilogram, a record high not seen since 2022.

More News

Việt Nam and India trade reached $15 billion in 2024

Việt Nam and India trade reached $15 billion in 2024

Trade relations between Việt Nam and India continue to flourish, with bilateral trade turnover reaching around US$15 billion in 2024.
Việt Nam

Việt Nam's port firms thrive in 2024

Strategic investments and expansions are expected to further enhance the sector’s performance.
Software exporter looks to new pace of growth

Software exporter looks to new pace of growth

FPT Software (F-Soft) Đà Nẵng plans to earn VNĐ3.6 trillion (US$144 million) in exports in 2025 after introducing a third campus at the FPT Complex and signing a strategic deal with the city.
Việt Nam

Việt Nam's exports to EU see impressive recovery in 2024

Việt Nam’s exports to the EU made an impressive recovery in 2024, reaching nearly US$51.7 billion, an increase of $8.08 billion compared to 2023.
Việt Nam–CPTPP trade turnover exceeds $100 billion

Việt Nam–CPTPP trade turnover exceeds $100 billion

The turnover accounts for 13.1 per cent of Việt Nam’s total import-export turnover last year.
E-commerce, a game changer for textile manufacturers

E-commerce, a game changer for textile manufacturers

According to a Việt Nam Textile and Apparel Association (VITAS) report, the proportion of textile businesses adopting e-commerce strategies has increased from 7-8 per cent in 2021, to over 20 per cent by the end of last year.
China remains the largest market for Việt Nam’s cassava and cassava products

China remains the largest market for Việt Nam’s cassava and cassava products

China accounted for 92.85 per cent of the total export volume and 91.77 per cent of the total export value, amounting to 2.43 million tonnes worth $1.06 billion.
Hải Phòng seaport system strives to handle 112 million tonnes of cargo this year

Hải Phòng seaport system strives to handle 112 million tonnes of cargo this year

The Hải Phòng Maritime Port Authority will coordinate with the municipal People’s Committee and relevant sides to find locations for dumping waste from construction, dredging, and maintenance activities.
Việt Nam’s exports stay strong during Tết holiday

Việt Nam’s exports stay strong during Tết holiday

During this period, various strategic measures have been implemented to boost exports to China.
Read More

Your care

Latest Most read
VN

VN's car industry to diversify supply chain

While China remains a significant supplier, recent trade data highlights Việt Nam’s efforts to diversify supply to meet industry demands.
Exports of agro-forestry-aquatic products down nearly 5 per cent in January

Exports of agro-forestry-aquatic products down nearly 5 per cent in January

Việt Nam’s export value of agro-forestry-aquatic products was estimated at US$5.08 billion in January, marking a 4.9 per cent decline compared to the same period last year.
Thailand reviews anti-dumping tax on Vietnamese steel

Thailand reviews anti-dumping tax on Vietnamese steel

TRAV recommended that the Việt Nam Steel Association (VSA) notify relevant local manufacturers and exporters to answer the investigation questionnaire within the prescribed deadline.
In the first 15 days of 2025, total import-export turnover reached more than US$34 billion

In the first 15 days of 2025, total import-export turnover reached more than US$34 billion

VCN - Total import-export turnover in the first half of January 2025 reached more than US$34 billion, the trade balance had a deficit of nearly US$2 billion.
Pangasius fetch record price in early 2025

Pangasius fetch record price in early 2025

Currently, larger pangasius weighing over 1.2kg, are selling at VNĐ32,440 (US$1.29) per kilogram, a record high not seen since 2022.
Mobile Version