Supplementing sanction competence for Customs in handling intellectual property infringement

VCN- Because the sanction for the act of exporting goods infringing intellectual property was beyond the competence of Customs, thereby the Customs has to transfer the case to other authorities for handling, leading to prolonging the settlement  nearly 2 years.
supplementing sanction competence for customs in handling intellectual property infringement Discovering and handling over 43,500 cases of counterfeit and intellectual property infringement
supplementing sanction competence for customs in handling intellectual property infringement IP protection overseas: Let the grass grow under your feet
supplementing sanction competence for customs in handling intellectual property infringement Business "complain" because of trademark infringement
supplementing sanction competence for customs in handling intellectual property infringement
The shipments of milk infringing intellectual property right were seized at Cat Lai Port by the Customs.

In the end of December 2017, Ho Chi Minh City People's Committee issued Decision No. 6300/QD-XPHC to fine Pham Nguyen Confectionery and Food Processing Co., Ltd VND 162 million and destroy all the exported goods registered for trademark protection in Vietnam. This Decision closed the handling and long process of nearly 2 years with many stressful meetings between concerned parties.

Previously, in January 2016, Customs Branch of Sai Gon Zone 1 collaborated with Anti smuggling and Investigation Department (the General Department of Vietnam Customs) to implement physical inspection for shipment exported by Pham Nguyen Confectionery and Food Processing Co., Ltd and detected signs of infringing intellectual property rights with the Choco Pie trademark. Hence, Customs Branch of Sai Gon Zone1 issued a decision on suspending Customs clearance for this shipment.

The exported shipment included 1,200 boxes of Choco Pie weighed 3,825.6kg, valued at US $ 8,624.1. The assessment results by Vietnam Intellectual Property Research Institute (under the Ministry of Science and Technology) determined that Pham Nguyen Confectionery and Food Processing Co., Ltd were in breach of the intellectual property rights of Choco Pie trademark which was registered for trademark protection and granted by the Intellectual Property Department to Orion Corporation (South Korea). Because the sanction for exported goods infringing intellectual property was beyond the competence of the Customs, thereby, under the instruction by the Ho Chi Minh City People's Committee, the Customs transferred the case dossier to Market Management Branch of Ho Chi Minh City for consideration and settlement. However, due to the confusion in handling the case by competent authorities the case was prolonged.

In this case, the act of manufacturing products using trademarks which have been registered for trademark protection is clear. The producer as exporter did not hide its infringement, even sued Customs Branch of Sai Gon Zone 1 to the Administrative Court for compensation for damage due to the Decision on suspending Customs procedures for the above mentioned shipment.

According to Mr. Dang Thai Thien, Deputy Head of Customs Control and Supervision Division- Ho Chi Minh City Customs Department, Decision on handling of Ho Chi Minh City People's Committee closed the long process of nearly 2 years with many stressful meetings between concerned parties, even complaints and petitions to the Administrative Court. The case showed that the Customs have no competence to fine administrative violation for the act of exporting goods infringing intellectual property rights, leading to prolonging administrative settlement and arising difficulties and imposing pressures on the Customs. If the Customs was authorized to fine administrative violation for the above mentioned infringement cases, the settlement would not have been prolonged for nearly 2 years, troubling concerned parties. The competent authorities need to study to supplement competence for the Customs in this field.

supplementing sanction competence for customs in handling intellectual property infringement Enterprises have to create barriers protect IPRs by themselves

VCN - Intellectual Property Rights (IPRs) plays an increasingly important role for the economic and social development ...

In the settlement process, the Ho Chi Minh Science and Technology Department consulted the Inspectorate of the Ministry of Science and Technology. This authority said that the measures for administrative settlement were not applied to businesses producing goods infringing on trademark right for export and not for domestic consumption. Mr. Thien said that this facilitated the production of goods infringing intellectual property for export to other countries. If being detected by the countries, the reputation of Vietnam goods would be reduced, and Vietnam might become the manufacturing centre of counterfeit goods and of intellectual property infringement goods. If Vietnam’s law does not provide settlement for these acts as stated by Ministry of Science and Technology, with the role as the advisory authority in the implementation of the Law on Intellectual property in Vietnam, the Ministry must propose the Government to supplement it into Decree on administrative settlement in the field of intellectual property right to prevent the export of goods infringing intellectual property.

By Le Thu/Ngoc Loan

Related News

Customs sector collects over VND384 trillion in revenue

Customs sector collects over VND384 trillion in revenue

VCN - By the end of November, the Customs revenue exceeded the estimate by 2.6% and increased by 14.8% compared to the same period in 2023, the General Department of Vietnam Customs released on December 11.
Preliminary assessment of Vietnam international merchandise trade performance in the second half of October, 2024

Preliminary assessment of Vietnam international merchandise trade performance in the second half of October, 2024

The Vietnam Customs Statistics announced that in the second half of October, 2024 the total Vietnam’s exports of US dollars 19.39 billion and imports of nearly US dollars 17.63 billion resulted in a trade surplus of US dollars 1.76 billion. Accordingly, the total value of export and import turnover of Vietnam in the second half of October was over US dollars 37.02 billion, up by 16% as compared to the first half of October-2024. Furthermore, in the first 10 months of 2024, Vietnam was in trade surplus of USD 23.35 billion.
Share experiences in crime prevention coordination between Customs and Police

Share experiences in crime prevention coordination between Customs and Police

VCN - On December 6, 2024, the General Department of Customs and the People's Police Academy co-organized the scientific workshop "Improving the effectiveness of coordination between the People's Police force and the Customs force in the fight against smuggling, trade fraud, and drugs at border gates and border areas in the new situation".

Latest News

Smuggling forecast for the Lunar New Year 2025  will be complicated

Smuggling forecast for the Lunar New Year 2025 will be complicated

VCN - This is the assessment made by the Steering Committee 389 of the Ministry of Finance during the peak of the fight against smuggling, trade fraud and counterfeit goods before, during and after the Lunar New Year 2025.
Tax authorities crack down on invoice fraud to legalize smuggled goods

Tax authorities crack down on invoice fraud to legalize smuggled goods

VCN - As part of efforts to combat smuggling and trade fraud during the Lunar New Year season, the Steering Committee 389 of the Ministry of Finance has instructed the General Department of Taxation to intensify enforcement against illegal practices involving fraudulent invoices and tax evasion.
Challenges in preventing counterfeit goods and intellectual property violations in e-commerce

Challenges in preventing counterfeit goods and intellectual property violations in e-commerce

VCN - The open sale of counterfeit goods, items with unclear origins, and intellectual property (IP) infringing products on e-commerce websites has become a growing trend.
Customs sector strengthens anti-smuggling during Lunar New Year

Customs sector strengthens anti-smuggling during Lunar New Year

VCN – Smuggling and trade fraud activities are forecast to take place more complicated on routes, areas and cyberspace due to high consumer demand during the Lunar New Year.

More News

Counterfeit and intellectual property infringing goods are becoming more sophisticated

Counterfeit and intellectual property infringing goods are becoming more sophisticated

VCN - In recent times, several containers of counterfeit goods imitating well-known brands and violating intellectual property (IP) rights have been intercepted by Customs authorities at border checkpoints. In an interview with Customs Magazine, Vu Hoai Linh, Deputy Head of Intellectual Property Rights Protection Enforcement Unit (Unit 4) under the Anti-Smuggling and Investigation Department, shared critical solutions to combat and prevent these violations.
Mong Cai: Smuggling concerns amid sluggish business activities

Mong Cai: Smuggling concerns amid sluggish business activities

VCN - Amid a noticeable slowdown in business activities, the Customs Enforcement Units of the Quang Ninh Customs Department in Mong Cai City are stepping up their efforts to combat smuggling, ensuring the area does not become a hotspot for illicit trade.
Fight against smuggling, trade fraud and counterfeit goods at the end of the year

Fight against smuggling, trade fraud and counterfeit goods at the end of the year

VCN - VCN - On November 30, 2024, Deputy Prime Minister Nguyen Hoa Binh, Head of the National Steering Committee 389, signed and promulgated a peak plan for fight against smuggling, commercial fraud and counterfeit goods before, during and after the Lunar New Year 2025, from 1/12/2024 to 28/2/2025.
MoF Steering Committee 389 launches a peak campaign against smuggling during Lunar New Year 2025

MoF Steering Committee 389 launches a peak campaign against smuggling during Lunar New Year 2025

VCN - In the coming time, smuggling and trade fraud activities is forecast to take place complicatedly, especially before, during and after the Lunar New Year 2025.
Customs arrests a suspect for transporting about 69 kg of fireworks across Moc Bai Border Gate

Customs arrests a suspect for transporting about 69 kg of fireworks across Moc Bai Border Gate

VCN – On December 4, Moc Bai Border Gate Customs Branch (Tay Ninh Customs Department) said the branch has collaborated enforcement authorities to arrest a suspect transporting about 69kg of firework from Cambodia to Vietnam.
“Watching” authorities to transport smuggled cigarettes

“Watching” authorities to transport smuggled cigarettes

VCN - The methods and tricks of cigarette smugglers are not new, but they are still aggressive, causing difficulties for the authorities.
Ha Tinh Customs arrests two suspects transporting 52 kg of drugs

Ha Tinh Customs arrests two suspects transporting 52 kg of drugs

VCN – Enforcement authorities of Ha Tinh province has tackled special plan HT624 and arrested two suspects transporting 52 kg of drugs.
Vehicle transporting illegal fireworks detected by Nghe An enforcement authorities

Vehicle transporting illegal fireworks detected by Nghe An enforcement authorities

VCN – Enforcement authorities of Nghe An province have detected and seized a vehicle transporting 44.5 kg of illegal fireworks.
Ho Chi Minh City Customs: Timely detection of many cases of false declaration in import documents

Ho Chi Minh City Customs: Timely detection of many cases of false declaration in import documents

VCN - In addition to trade facilitation, Ho Chi Minh City Customs Department has also proactively inspected and controlled key goods and has detected and prevented many major tax fraud cases.
Read More

Your care

Latest Most read
Smuggling forecast for the Lunar New Year 2025  will be complicated

Smuggling forecast for the Lunar New Year 2025 will be complicated

VCN - The Steering Committee 389 of the Ministry of Finance assessed that in recent times, the situation of smuggling, trade fraud and counterfeit goods continues to develop complicatedly on border routes, sea areas and inland areas, with new and more sop
Tax authorities crack down on invoice fraud to legalize smuggled goods

Tax authorities crack down on invoice fraud to legalize smuggled goods

The Steering Committee 389 of the Ministry of Finance has instructed the General Department of Taxation to intensify enforcement against illegal practices involving fraudulent invoices and tax evasion.
Share experiences in crime prevention coordination between Customs and Police

Share experiences in crime prevention coordination between Customs and Police

VCN - Attending and chairing the Workshop were Deputy Director General of the General Department of Customs Luu Manh Tuong and Major General, Dr. Chu Van Dung, Deputy Director of the People's Police Academy.
Challenges in preventing counterfeit goods and intellectual property violations in e-commerce

Challenges in preventing counterfeit goods and intellectual property violations in e-commerce

The open sale of counterfeit goods, items with unclear origins, and intellectual property (IP) infringing products on e-commerce websites has become a growing trend.
Customs sector strengthens anti-smuggling during Lunar New Year

Customs sector strengthens anti-smuggling during Lunar New Year

VCN - The General Department of Customs (GDVC) has issued a peak plan to fight against smuggling, trade fraud and counterfeit goods before, during and after Lunar New Year 2025.
Mobile Version