Preventing chain breakdown from P2P lending: There must be a legal corridor quickly

VCN - In recent days, the case of two peer-to-peer lending enterprises (P2P) falling into illiquidity, leading to the risk of chain breakdown, shows that the legal corridor and tight control of the financial technology sector (Fintech) is very important.
Lending interest rates are under increasing pressure Lending interest rates are under increasing pressure
Lending rates expected to be stable thanks to State support package Lending rates expected to be stable thanks to State support package
Regulatory sandbox for P2P lending needs strict requirements Regulatory sandbox for P2P lending needs strict requirements
The field of peer-to-peer lending does not yet have specific regulations for adjustment. Photo: Internet
The field of peer-to-peer lending does not yet have specific regulations for adjustment. Photo: Internet

Fear of risk

According to the statistics of the State Bank of Vietnam (SBV) as well as the Vietnam Fintech Market Report 2021, the number of Fintech companies increased four times, from 39 companies at the end of 2015 to more than 154 companies by the end of 2021.

Among Fintech companies in Vietnam, about 70% are start-ups. The year 2021 witnessed great leaps in the Vietnamese Fintech market when the internet economy reached a value of US$ 21 billion, standing at 14/50 in Asia and 70th in the global rankings. Fintech Vietnam had grown significantly thanks to the support of the Government on the expansion of digital payment forms as well as the increasing adoption of digital transactions and the development of the e-commerce market.

However, risks and negative incidents from Fintech enterprises have emerged. In the latest example, VO247 is a financial technology application that connects borrowers and lenders in Vietnam (P2P lending) owned and operated by VO247 Financial Technology Joint Stock Company. Launched in 2019, after more than two years of operation, VO247 has 6,000 investors and nearly 70,000 borrowers. According to the introduction of VO247, when investing, investors can receive interest up to 18.25%/year.

But with difficult economic reasons, the leader of VO247 declared that the company was insolvent, facing the risk of bankruptcy. Due to the fear of breaking the chain when investors repeatedly asked to return the invested capital, both principal and interest, about VND 150 billion, another P2P lending company, Fiin Credit, announced support.

But so far, this company is also facing the risk of falling into illiquidity, causing panic in the P2P lending community, fearing that the wave of withdrawals will spread to other P2P lending applications.

As a rule, a peer-to-peer lending company only acts as an intermediary to directly connect borrowers with lenders (investors), but in reality, many loan applications operate like credit institutions when mobilizing capital from organizations and individuals and then lending at high interest rates.

Meanwhile, many investors have no knowledge of finance - banking, they bring money to invest with high interest rates without understanding the bad debt ratio, loan appraisal capacity, leading to large bad debts, companies like VO247 will have to bear the interest of 18%/year to pay investors with additional debt from these lenders, so they will be insolvency.

The above case shows that P2P lending in particular and Fintech fields in general are facing many risks. According to Dr. Nguyen Quoc Hung, General Secretary of the Vietnam Banks Association (VNBA), the company's activities providing Fintech solutions, P2P lending, new payment models, cross-border money transfers, sharing user data through open application programming interfaces (Open APIs) are not adjusted in specific legal regulations and face many risks, such as security risks and data leaks, liquidity risk and credit risk, money laundering and terrorist financing risks, and illegal debt collection activities.

In the field of P2P lending, Dr. Nguyen Quoc Hung emphasized that this field had no legal regulations and only operated under the provisions of the Civil Code, according to the Law on Credit Institutions, capital mobilization in the lending process was a violation of the law and might be charged under criminal law. Therefore, he noted that enterprises must comply with the law, they should not do things to avoid risks to enterprises and the financial system.

Needing a strict legal corridor

With the above difficulties, the SBV has submitted to the Government to issue a Decree on a mechanism for controlling Fintech activities in the banking sector (Fintech Regulatory Sandbox), which is expected to bring P2P lending business to the group of conditional business lines, and it will stipulate the granting of credit on the technology platform, peer-to-peer lending.

This is very necessary because according to experts, Vietnam's P2P lending model is showing signs of falling in the footsteps of China. The Chinese government had to issue stricter regulations with P2P lending, including regulations on deposit, independent audit, disclosure of operating results, loan value limit, and a list of prohibited activities for P2P lending enterprises.

Many experts also said that the P2P model still had great significance for comprehensive finance in our country, especially in the context that people and enterprises need to diversify capital sources, was unable to be based solely on the banking system, P2P lending was one of the modern and innovative sources of capital. Therefore, there must be a clear legal framework as well as fundamental solutions for the sustainable development of P2P lending in general and Fintech enterprises in particular.

Currently, the Law on Electronic Transactions (amended) is still being consulted, so enterprises expect that when this Law is promulgated, it will complete the legal basis to facilitate the digital transformation process as well as developing new products, services, and economic models based on digital technology.

By Huong Diu/ Binh Minh

Related News

What do businesses need for digital transformation?

What do businesses need for digital transformation?

VCN - According to experts, to support businesses in successful digital transformation, the state needs to complete the policy framework and testing mechanism (sandbox) for the development of digital economy, green economy, circular economy and new business models. At the same time, reform institutions to attract investment in digital technology in the direction of maximizing convenience for capital contribution, share purchase, merger and acquisition of digital technology enterprises. Create a favorable environment to promote digital transformation and support business development.
Ensuring national public debt safety in 2024

Ensuring national public debt safety in 2024

VCN - Since the beginning of the year, public debt management has been conducted proactively and effectively, meeting the need of raising capital for development investment. At the same time, debt indicators by the end of 2024 are guaranteed within the ceiling and safety threshold approved by the National Assembly, ensuring national financial security, increasing proactive response to risks arising from external and internal causes of the economy.
The biggest challenges businesses are facing

The biggest challenges businesses are facing

VCN - Orders, cash flow, market information, loan approach... are still the difficulties when the Private Sector Development Research Board (abbreviated as IV Board) surveyed the business situation.
How does the Fed

How does the Fed's interest rate cut affect Vietnam?

VCN - In the latest meeting of the Federal Open Market Committee (FOMC), the Fed decided to cut interest rates by 50 basis points to a range of 4.75%-5%. Analysts have given different perspectives on this decision.

Latest News

VN

VN's food processing industry struggles to improve quality and value chain integration

Despite accounting for 19.1 per cent of Việt Nam’s processing sector, the food processing industry has been struggling with major issues such as poor-quality raw materials and subpar value chain integration, said industry insiders and economists.
Approach strategy of the seafood industry when implementing UKVFTA

Approach strategy of the seafood industry when implementing UKVFTA

VCN - As one of Vietnam's strong export industries to the UK, especially when the Vietnam - United Kingdom of Great Britain and Northern Ireland Free Trade Agreement (UKVFTA) comes into effect, with a detailed information approach strategy, it has created a great driving force to promote the export of Vietnamese seafood products to this market.
Mid-November: Vietnam

Mid-November: Vietnam's trade volume matches 2023 total, eyes record-breaking growth

VCN - By mid-November 2024, Vietnam's total import-export turnover reached an impressive US$681.48 billion, equaling the full-year trade figure for 2023
Vietnamese enterprises facing challenges from cross-border e-commerce platforms

Vietnamese enterprises facing challenges from cross-border e-commerce platforms

VCN – In recent years, with the rapid development of cross-border e-commerce (CBEC) platforms, domestic enterprises in Vietnam have been facing numerous difficulties and challenges.

More News

Vietnam, Malaysia eye new milestone in trade ties

Vietnam, Malaysia eye new milestone in trade ties

The official visit to Malaysia from November 21-23 by Party General Secretary To Lam is expected to open up new opportunities for and mark a new milestone in the economic and trade cooperation between Vietnam and Malaysia. Vietnam and Malaysia are key economic, trade, and investment partners. Their economic and trade ties have steadily grown since the two nations established diplomatic relations in 1973.
Shrimp exports surge in 10 months, generating 3.2 billion USD

Shrimp exports surge in 10 months, generating 3.2 billion USD

Vietnam’s shrimp exports in October reached US$394 million, a strong 24% increase year-on-year, according to the Vietnam Association of Seafood Exporters and Producers (VASEP).
Vietnam’s exports to the U.S. near US$100 billion milestone

Vietnam’s exports to the U.S. near US$100 billion milestone

VCN - By the end of October, Vietnam's exports to the United States approached US$100 billion, reaffirming its position as Vietnam's largest export market.
From the “abnormal” coffee price, worries about the new crop

From the “abnormal” coffee price, worries about the new crop

VCN - The Vietnamese coffee industry enters the new crop with the question of what is a reasonable price to ensure benefits for coffee growers while still retaining international consumers.
What obstacles limit the market share of Vietnamese goods in the UK?

What obstacles limit the market share of Vietnamese goods in the UK?

VCN - Vietnamese goods account for only about 1% of total imports into the UK market. One of the reasons is that they have not yet built their own brands and have not focused on effective strategies and approaches to market information.
Why seafood exports to some Middle Eastern Countries are stalled

Why seafood exports to some Middle Eastern Countries are stalled

VCN - Several shipments of seafood exported to certain Middle Eastern countries have been delayed due to legal challenges related to consular legalization procedures. This has created significant bottlenecks in accessing these markets.
Storm No. 3 destroys profits of many insurance companies

Storm No. 3 destroys profits of many insurance companies

VCN - Due to the impact of storm No. 3, the business results of the third quarter and the first 9 months of 2024 of the insurance sector have been significantly affected. This requires more efforts from businesses for the results of the whole year 2024.
Vietnam, Malaysia eye golden partnership opportunities in Halal industry

Vietnam, Malaysia eye golden partnership opportunities in Halal industry

Cooperation in the Halal industry can help Vietnamese products reach nearly 2 billion Muslim consumers worldwide, representing over 24% of the global population, according to Malaysia’s Minister of Investment, Trade, and Industry Zafrul Abdul Aziz.
Tra fish sector aiming for production, processing greening for sustainable development

Tra fish sector aiming for production, processing greening for sustainable development

Greening production and processing to meet export requirements is both a trend and a necessity for many industries, including the tra fish sector.
Read More

Your care

Latest Most read
VN

VN's food processing industry struggles to improve quality and value chain integration

Despite accounting for 19.1 per cent of Việt Nam’s processing sector, the food processing industry has been struggling with major issues such as poor-quality raw materials and subpar value chain integration, said industry insiders and economists.
Approach strategy of the seafood industry when implementing UKVFTA

Approach strategy of the seafood industry when implementing UKVFTA

VCN - Mr. Nguyen Hoai Nam, Deputy General Secretary, Vietnam Association of Seafood Exporters and Producers (VASEP), said that the advantage that UKVFTA brings is that the main products of the seafood industry enjoy 0% import tax to the UK, especially key
Mid-November: Vietnam

Mid-November: Vietnam's trade volume matches 2023 total, eyes record-breaking growth

By mid-November 2024, Vietnam's total import-export turnover reached an impressive US$681.48 billion, equaling the full-year trade figure for 2023
Vietnamese enterprises facing challenges from cross-border e-commerce platforms

Vietnamese enterprises facing challenges from cross-border e-commerce platforms

VCN - E-commerce platforms have emerged as crucial distribution channels, enabling goods to reach consumers quickly and conveniently.
Vietnam, Malaysia eye new milestone in trade ties

Vietnam, Malaysia eye new milestone in trade ties

The official visit to Malaysia from November 21-23 by Party General Secretary To Lam is expected to open up new opportunities for and mark a new milestone in the economic and trade cooperation between Vietnam and Malaysia. Vietnam and Malaysia are key economic, trade, and investment partners. Their economic and trade ties have steadily grown since the two nations established diplomatic relations in 1973.
Mobile Version