Need to check each case for clarifying acts of price transfer

VCN – Prof. Phan Huu Thang, former Director of Foreign Investment Department under the Ministry of Planning and Investment (picture) spoke with Customs News about the contribution of the FDI sector to the State budget as well as price transfer in this sector.
Need to check each case for clarifying acts of price transfer
Prof. Phan Huu Thang

According to the Ministry of Finance, FDI enterprises have contributed to the State budget. How do you evaluate about the contribution of FDI sector?

The contribution to the State budget revenue of FDI enterprises in 2019 is very impressive, especially when comparing this figure with the previous periods. The growth of the contribution to the State budget of the FDI sector shows the important role of this business sector in Vietnam's socio-economic development.

Do you have any comments on the situation that 55% of FDI enterprises report losses?

The figure of 55% of FDI enterprises reporting losses in 2019 was alarming and difficult to accept. It is necessary to investigate to clarify the reasons why so many enterprises suffered losses, to have solutions to overcome this phenomenon, bring efficiency in investment, production and business of FDI firms, ensuring the State's interests in attracting FDI, the interests of workers and especially to enhance the competitiveness of Vietnam's investment environment in the international arena when Vietnam must continue to attract and most effectively use this FDI source for socio-economic development in the coming years.

With businesses reporting on losses continuously for many years but still expanding production and business, in my opinion, it may be caused by these reasons.

Firstly, businesses that suffered losses continued to invest to overcome and eventually make profits when they were confident in their management, operation abilities and believe in the ability of the market that continues growing, opening up opportunities for growth.

Secondly, businesses committed tax evasion-transfer pricing. This was a phenomenon that tax authorities and FDI management have known. Transfer pricing is a cross-country pricing structure and is only possible when there is a structure between independent companies, between the investment country and host country to set prices of commodity and services much higher than normal price to avoid paying corporate income tax, avoiding the regulations on transferring profits abroad, quickly recovering investment capital. The sign was that enterprises report continuous losses for a number of years, but revenue had increased, expanded production. Maybe, businesses have been proactive to lose three years, then 1-2 years earning little profit, and then record accumulate losses.

The way to turn a profit into loss, or to arrange a low rate of profit, FDI enterprises could not do individually so they often coordinate and associate in the same group or corporation. These businesses arrange prices with each other through linked transactions, through which companies in the group could reduce the total value of their tax liability on a global scale, increasing profit after tax.

Besides that, many businesses have had the intention of transferring prices and using other "tricks" such as setting high input pricing and declaring low prices when exporting goods, increasing other costs and using costs of paying loan interest to transfer pricing. To sum up, facing with the phenomenon of reporting losses but increasing capital to expand production and business, it is necessary to conduct a case-by-case inspection to clarify.

The story of transfer pricing has been mentioned a lot in recent years. Besides the subjective factor of enterprises, have the inspection and supervision of FDI enterprises really played a role yet?

As mentioned above, the story of FDI enterprises' transfer pricing has been known for a long time by tax authorities and has been inspected and clarified in many cases, recovering billions of VND to the State budget from tax evasion acts. Actually, however, the fight against all the acts of price transfer was not easy because there have been cross-border transactions, belonging to enterprises in the same corporation or in an affiliated group so the transfer pricing acts are not easy to have evidence to accuse. Some tax authorities around the world have had to apply tax measures before accepting and allowing firms to invest in certain areas that were difficult to control inputs and outputs. Recently, the Government issued Decree No. 132/2020/ND-CP dated November 5, 2020, regulating the tax administration for enterprises with associated transactions, which will help more effectively prevent transfer pricing and tax evasion from FDI enterprises.

Are the legal provisions sufficient to deter and prevent this situation? Talking to Customs News, you suggested that an inter-ministerial working group specialised in anti-transfer pricing should be established. What are your current views on this matter?

As I mentioned above, to now, the provisions of Vietnam's legal system on taxation have been issued like the Law on Tax Administration dated June 13, 2019; Law on Corporate Income Tax dated June 3, 2008 and Law amending and supplementing articles of the Law on Corporate Income Tax dated June 9, 2013 and recently Decree 132/2020/ND-CP on management tax on enterprises with associated transactions. With their functions and capacities, tax authorities of Vietnam at central and local levels, on the basis of close coordination with relevant sectors in banking, investment and business registration trade, science and technology and customs would be able to handle and prevent the phenomenon of transfer pricing and tax evasion of FDI enterprises more effectively.

In my opinion, it is necessary to set up an inter-ministerial working group specialised in anti-transfer pricing of FDI enterprises to closely coordinate with localities in this work. For small-scale projects, the responsibility for anti-transfer pricing work must be assigned to localities, and to use independent international expertise when necessary.

By Thu Hiền/Thanh Thuy

Related News

Quang Ninh Customs collects 85.75% of the budget revenue through the seaport area

Quang Ninh Customs collects 85.75% of the budget revenue through the seaport area

VCN - In the first 9 months of 2024, Quang Ninh Customs Department collected VND 13,885.23 billion in revenue collection, reaching 111.08% of the assigned estimate (VND 12,500 billion), reaching 106.81% of the target assigned by Quang Ninh province (VND 13,000 billion), an increase of 8.67% over the same period in 2023
Trade in goods of FDI enterprises account for about 68% of the country

Trade in goods of FDI enterprises account for about 68% of the country's import-export turnover

VCN - As of October 15, 2024, the total import-export turnover of FDI enterprises increased by 14.8% year-on-year, the preliminary statistics from the General Department of Vietnam Customs releases.
HCM City Customs held a dialogue and supported on training FDI enterprises

HCM City Customs held a dialogue and supported on training FDI enterprises

VCN - In order to improve the effectiveness of cooperation and support for foreign direct investment (FDI) enterprises, the HCM City Customs Department has proactively coordinated with business associations to organize dialogue conferences and in-depth training programs on import-export regulations, customs procedures, and solutions to help enterprises overcome legal challenges during their operations in Vietnam.

Latest News

M&A activities show signs of recovery

M&A activities show signs of recovery

Mergers and acquisitions (M&A) activities in Vietnam have been showing signs of recovery in recent months as several large companies announced finished deals, which may create a ripple effect in the M&A market.
Fiscal policy needs to return to normal state in new period

Fiscal policy needs to return to normal state in new period

VCN - To recover the economy during and after the Covid-19 pandemic, fiscal policy has been flexibly and promptly managed, becoming a solid foundation to help businesses and the economy gradually overcome difficulties. After nearly 5 years, although there are still difficulties, the economy is gradually returning to a high growth trajectory. In that context, it is necessary to let fiscal policy return to normal state.
Ensuring national public debt safety in 2024

Ensuring national public debt safety in 2024

VCN - Since the beginning of the year, public debt management has been conducted proactively and effectively, meeting the need of raising capital for development investment. At the same time, debt indicators by the end of 2024 are guaranteed within the ceiling and safety threshold approved by the National Assembly, ensuring national financial security, increasing proactive response to risks arising from external and internal causes of the economy.
Removing many bottlenecks in regular spending to purchase assets and equipment

Removing many bottlenecks in regular spending to purchase assets and equipment

VCN - Decree No. 138/2024/ND-CP, which has just been issued, is expected to contribute to resolving bottlenecks in allocating funds for purchasing assets and equipment; renovating, upgrading, expanding, and constructing new construction items in projects that have been invested in and constructed in the past.

More News

Continue to handle cross-ownership in banks

Continue to handle cross-ownership in banks

VCN - The situation of excess share ownership, cross-ownership between credit institutions (CIs), CIs and enterprises, although has decreased significantly compared to previous periods, is still complicated and requires continued inspection and control.
Striving for average CPI not to exceed 4%

Striving for average CPI not to exceed 4%

VCN - According to the report of the Ministry of Finance, there are still some factors that put pressure on price levels in the remaining months of 2024, so the Ministry has updated 2 scenarios of average inflation in 2024 increasing in the range of 3.7-3.92%.
Delegating the power to the government to waive, lower, or manage late tax penalties is suitable

Delegating the power to the government to waive, lower, or manage late tax penalties is suitable

VCN - Discussing in groups about the project "1 law amending 7 laws" in the financial sector according to the program of the 8th Session on October 29, 2024, National Assembly delegates proposed that the Government should be assigned to make specific regulations on decentralization, granting the right to exempt and reduce taxes, and handling penalties for late payment of taxes...
Removing difficulties in public investment disbursement

Removing difficulties in public investment disbursement

VCN - According to the report of the Investment Department (Ministry of Finance), the estimated disbursement from the beginning of the year to October 31, 2024 is VND 355,616.1 billion, reaching 47.43% of the 2024 plan, reaching 52.29% of the plan assigned by the Prime Minister.
State-owned commercial banking sector performs optimistic growth, but more capital in need

State-owned commercial banking sector performs optimistic growth, but more capital in need

VCN - According to the report sent to the National Assembly before the 8th Session of the Government on investment, management and use of state capital in enterprises nationwide in 2023, the business performance of the state-owned commercial banking sector achieved positive growth.
Stipulate implementation of centralized bilateral payments of the State Treasury at banks

Stipulate implementation of centralized bilateral payments of the State Treasury at banks

VCN - The Ministry of Finance (MOF) gathers feedback on the draft Circular regulating the management and use of accounts of the State Treasury opened at the State Bank of Vietnam (SBV) and commercial banks.
Rush to finalize draft decree on public asset restructuring

Rush to finalize draft decree on public asset restructuring

VCN - According to the Ministry of Finance, the draft Decree regulating the rearrangement and handling of public assets is being urgently completed by the Ministry of Finance to submit to the Government for promulgation.
Inspection report on gold trading activities being complied: SBV

Inspection report on gold trading activities being complied: SBV

The State Bank of Vietnam (SBV) has announced that inspections on compliance with legal policies in gold trading activities of credit institutions and gold trading businesses have been completed and an inspection report is being compiled.
Budget revenue in 2024 is estimated to exceed the estimate by 10.1%

Budget revenue in 2024 is estimated to exceed the estimate by 10.1%

VCN -The Government estimates that state budget revenue in 2024 will exceed VND 172.3 trillion, up 10.1% over the estimate, of which tax and fee revenue will reach 13.1% of GDP.
Read More

Your care

Latest Most read
M&A activities show signs of recovery

M&A activities show signs of recovery

Mergers and acquisitions (M&A) activities in Vietnam have been showing signs of recovery in recent months as several large companies announced finished deals, which may create a ripple effect in the M&A market.
Fiscal policy needs to return to normal state in new period

Fiscal policy needs to return to normal state in new period

VCN - To recover the economy during and after the Covid-19 pandemic, fiscal policy has been flexibly and promptly managed, becoming a solid foundation to help businesses and the economy gradually overcome difficulties. After nearly 5 years, although there
Ensuring national public debt safety in 2024

Ensuring national public debt safety in 2024

VCN - Since the beginning of the year, public debt management has been conducted proactively and effectively, meeting the need of raising capital for development investment. At the same time, debt indicators by the end of 2024 are guaranteed within the ce
Removing many bottlenecks in regular spending to purchase assets and equipment

Removing many bottlenecks in regular spending to purchase assets and equipment

Decree No. 138/2024/ND-CP, which has just been issued, is expected to contribute to resolving bottlenecks in allocating funds for purchasing assets and equipment
Continue to handle cross-ownership in banks

Continue to handle cross-ownership in banks

VCN - The situation of excess share ownership, cross-ownership between credit institutions (CIs), CIs and enterprises, although has decreased significantly compared to previous periods, is still complicated and requires continued inspection and control.
Mobile Version