Monetary policy must prioritize inflation control

VCN - According to Assoc. Prof. Dr Pham The Anh, Chief Economist of the Vietnam Center for Economic and Strategic Studies (VESS), states that economic growth tends to slow down, while the growth rate of public debt is higher than the economic growth. The reason is due to the consequences of weak macro policies in the previous period, the impact of the unfavorable international economic environment, the economic growth in breadth reaching its limit and the impact of the Covid-19 pandemic.
Assoc. Prof. Dr Pham The Anh.
Assoc. Prof. Dr Pham The Anh.

How do you assess the growth of Vietnam's economy in recent years?

From 1991-2021, Vietnam's economy has made impressive progress, with GDP increasing by 6.57% per year on average. GDP growth rate is high and stable compared to the world. The economic scale in 2021 will reach about US $ 363 billion, entering the top 40 largest economies in the world. Over the years, the inflation rate has been kept in single digits; the trade balance has continuously been surplus since 2016; stable foreign investment; foreign currency reserves increased ten times from 2010-2021.

However, Vietnam's economy also faces many challenges. GDP growth has been on a downward trend in recent years. Specifically, ten years after the renovation (1991-2000), Vietnam's GDP grew by 7.6%/year. However, in the next 10 years (2001-2010), GDP growth decreased to 6.6 %/year; in ten recent years (2011-2021), GDP has decreased to 5.6 %/year. The cause of the slowdown in growth is the result of weak macroeconomic policies in the previous period, the influence of the unfavorable international economic environment, the economic growth in the breadth is reaching its limit, and the impact of the economic growth on the economy is limited and impact of the Covid-19 pandemic.

Besides, the Vietnamese economy also faces a burden of public debt that could destabilize the economy in the next decade. Accordingly, from 2010-2021, Vietnam's public debt has increased 3.2 times (from VND 1,144 to 3,655 million billion), and the growth rate is 11.3 %/year, much higher than the economic growth rate. On the other hand, monetary policy is heavy on administrative intervention; Shortages of qualified labor could impede growth spurts.

Another challenge is that Vietnam's growth relies on exports and foreign direct investment (FDI). Accordingly, the export growth rate will reach 18.4 %/year in 2001-2021. The export/GDP ratio exceeds 100%. Vietnam participates in many FTAs. Disbursed FDI in recent years has reached approximately US $ 20 billion /year, twice as much as ten years ago.

Regarding Vietnam's state budget revenue, the revenue growth rate has slowed but remained high, from 11.5%/year in the 2011-2015 period to 8.8%/year in the 2016-2020 period. The budget revenue/GDP ratio increased from 23.6% to 25.2% in the same period, the highest in 5-ASEAN. The tax and fee revenue rate decreased rapidly, from 88% in 2011 to 72% in 2020. The proportion of corporate income tax decreased rapidly to only about 17% recently. VAT accounts for the most significant proportion and tends to decrease slightly. The import and export tax proportion decreased to only half in the period 2016-2020 compared to 2011-2015.

In your opinion, what should Vietnam's fiscal policies focus on to promote economic recovery and continue to grow in the coming period?

Monetary policy must prioritize inflation control. To achieve this goal, controlling the money supply growth rate suitable for economic growth is necessary, not to jump too high like in previous periods.

On the other hand, monetary policy must be especially compliant with the rules, be transparent and have clear explanations. This is a huge disadvantage of Vietnam's monetary policy. An unpredictable, non-transparent policy often surprises the economy. Therefore, it creates a very negative shock. In contrast, monetary policies that are carried out according to certain rules, such as raising or lowering interest rates, must have a reason.

Looking at the US economy, before market policy adjustment, businesses could predict it. It means they know the tendency of interest rates that would increase and how much to increase based on information about the economy, inflation, financial market movements, exchange rates, and unemployment rate. Therefore, the country's adjustments are not surprising. There are no adverse shocks.

However, Vietnam's monetary policy is almost unaccountable. For example, we can see that, for a long time, interest rates have not been raised, but "all of a sudden" increased by 1%, and a few weeks later, increased by 1%, causing an unexpected shock to the market. Such unexpected policies make the economic environment very risky, and people and businesses cannot make long-term business plans stably.

Besides the above recommendations, to ensure macroeconomic stability, what do we need to do?

In my opinion, monetary policy should focus on stabilizing the macro-economy, They are policies that monitor the system's safety. For example, it can monitor the minimum capital adequacy ratio, medium and long-term mobilization/lending, bad debt, etc.

Vietnam's monetary policy over the past decade has pursued many goals. However, in addition to controlling inflation and stabilizing the exchange rate, it must also contribute to growth. As a result, the monetary policies of the State Bank of Vietnam (SBV) have gained more credibility, including exchange rate issues. The exchange rate was constantly volatile in the last decade with sharp devaluations, but this phenomenon has disappeared in the last ten years. Therefore, monetary policy should pursue a managed floating exchange rate regime instead of the current rigid exchange rate anchoring policy.

ASEAN-5 countries pursue a managed floating exchange rate policy. Since the beginning of the year, their currencies have depreciated by 9-10%, equivalent to Vietnam, but they have not encountered any problems with interest rates. Meanwhile, we try to raise interest rates to keep the exchange rate under control. Currently, Vietnam's interest rate environment is quite high compared to ASEAN-5 countries (currently up to 2 digits), while interest rates are quite high. The rate of other countries in the region remains at 4-5%/year.

In addition, Vietnam's monetary policy must eliminate administrative interventions. The highest goal of inflation control is to control the money supply, especially the base money (newly printed money issued by the state budget), not credit control. Because credit is an activity subject to market rules, as long as banks comply with systemic safety norms, they will be allowed to freely trade the capital they raise.

The application of a credit ceiling will make the banking industry less competitive. This is because good or bad banks are divided into limits, and no bank's market share decreases; in other words, the bank's market share is not associated with competitiveness when entangled in the lending limit. In addition, applying the credit limit also means that capital flows can be "disguised" in other forms. Since then, it has led to other administrative interventions, limiting the development of the financial system. At the same time, facing the risk of shifting domestic savings/assets abroad.

Therefore, Vietnam should soon end the use of credit ceilings and other direct administrative interventions in the capital/money market. Instead, control the base money and supply and regulate it indirectly through the target interest rate. At the same time, closely supervise commercial banks including minimum capital adequacy ratio (CAR); loan-to-deposit ratio (LTD); bad debt ratio; a ratio of short-term deposits for medium and long-term loans.

Thank you very much!

By Xuân Thảo/Quynhlan

Related News

Creating breakthrough solutions to attract large-scale FDI projects

Creating breakthrough solutions to attract large-scale FDI projects

VCN - Attracting foreign investment (FDI) in the first two months of 2024 is at a high level, so it is expected to be a good signal affecting economic growth in 2024 as well as 2025.
Good management of public debt creates room to implement expansionary fiscal policy

Good management of public debt creates room to implement expansionary fiscal policy

VCN - Public debt safety indicators continue to be strictly controlled in the safe limit. With a lower debt level than the current ceiling rate, and a favorable debt structure, Vietnam has a lot of room to implement expansionary fiscal policy to allocate loans for large projects as an economic growth engine.
Lang Son: Bustling with exports at the beginning of the year

Lang Son: Bustling with exports at the beginning of the year

VCN - Lunar New Year Giap Thin 2024 is approaching. Bustling cargo trucks arriving at border gates in Lang Son province seem to paint a vivid picture of spring at the border.
Financial policy promotes green economic development

Financial policy promotes green economic development

VCN - To realize the goal of reducing net emissions to zero by 2050 as committed at COP26, Vietnam is urgently concretizing this commitment before the international community. Regarding the Finance sector, recently, the Ministry of Finance has promoted the completion of financial policies to concretize policies and create conditions for green economic development.

Latest News

PM demands strengthened gold market management

PM demands strengthened gold market management

Prime Minister Pham Minh Chinh has asked the State Bank of Vietnam (SBV) to keep a close watch on international and domestic gold prices, and put in place measures and tools in a timely and effective way to regulate the gold market in line with regulations.
Budget expenditures reached VND393.5 trillion, growing 8.3% over the same period in the first quarter

Budget expenditures reached VND393.5 trillion, growing 8.3% over the same period in the first quarter

VCN - The Ministry of Finance said that the total balance of budget expenditure in March was estimated at VND140.3 trillion; accumulated budget expenditures in the first quarter of 2024 reached VND393.5 trillion, equal to 18.6% of current appropriation, an increase of 8.3% over the same period in 2023.
Inflationary pressure stems  from commodity price fluctuations

Inflationary pressure stems from commodity price fluctuations

VCN – According to a report from the Ministry of Finance, the domestic market prices in the first quarter were stable and fluctuated in accordance with the price management scenario of the Price Management Steering Committee. However, the current impact from adjusting the prices of essential goods is a pressure on inflation control.
SMEs offered loans at preferential rates of 1.2-4.4%

SMEs offered loans at preferential rates of 1.2-4.4%

To create additional capital mobilisation channels for small- and medium-sized enterprises (SMEs), Vietnam’s Small- and Medium-sized Enterprise Development Fund under the Ministry of Planning and Investment is offering SMEs loans at preferential interest rates of 1.2-4.4% per year.

More News

Public investment disbursement needs to be accelerated to boost growth: insiders

Public investment disbursement needs to be accelerated to boost growth: insiders

Public investment is currently still an important growth driver, which needs to be accelerated so as to help the economy achieve a 6.5% growth this year, according to insiders.
Banks seek to attract foreign capital

Banks seek to attract foreign capital

VCN - Banks are actively developing plans to attract capital from foreign investors through various methods, aiming to enhance their capital "buffers" and improve their management and operational standards to meet international levels.
Budget revenue collection for the first quarter of 2024 achieved quite well compared to current appropriation

Budget revenue collection for the first quarter of 2024 achieved quite well compared to current appropriation

VCN - In the first 3 months of 2024, total revenue collection is estimated to reach VND539.5 trillion, equal to 31.7% of current appropriation, an increase of 9.8% over the same period in 2023. According to the Ministry of Finance's assessment, revenue of the first quarter of 2024 is quite good compared to current appropriation, mainly due to the concentration of revenues arising in the fourth quarter of 2023 and the difference according to the tax finalization 2023 following the regime of declaration and payment to the state budget in the first quarter of 2024.
Continue to implement and complete important customs cooperation initiatives in ASEAN

Continue to implement and complete important customs cooperation initiatives in ASEAN

VCN - Talking to the press on the sidelines of the 28th ASEAN Finance Ministers' Meeting (AFMM 28) taking place in Luang Prabang, Laos, Vietnam’s Minister of Finance Ho Duc Phoc emphasized that the meeting affirms the determination of ASEAN financial agencies to strengthen cooperation and work together to solve common challenges of the region in the context of the world and the region facing many changes, difficulties and challenges.
28th AFMM, 11th AFMGM gain great success

28th AFMM, 11th AFMGM gain great success

VCN - In the framework of ASEAN 2024 Financial Cooperation, the 28th ASEAN Finance Ministers' Meeting, the 11th ASEAN Finance Ministers' and Central Bank Governors’ Meetings and related conferences were held in Luang Prabang, Laos from April 4-5. Minister of Finance Ho Duc Phoc led the delegation of the Ministry of Finance of Vietnam to attend the meetings.
Many positive signals from stock market upgrade

Many positive signals from stock market upgrade

VCN - Many crucial knots in the process of upgrading the stock market are being untangled by the Government and relevant agencies. Thanks to proactive moves from the management agencies, experts assessed that the stock market was likely to be upgraded according to the set objectives.
Promote the implementation of audit recommendations to prevent violations in public financial management

Promote the implementation of audit recommendations to prevent violations in public financial management

VCN - Recently, besides many ministries, branches, localities and units that have made efforts to implement audit conclusions and recommendations, there are still many conclusions and recommendations that have not been implemented. Many audit recommendations have been "on hold" for many years, leading to a backlog of financial resolution recommendations amounting to trillions of dong. For the implementation of recommendations to achieve high results and prevent violations in the management of public finances and public assets, there needs to be a synchronous solution from many sides.
The State Treasury ensures budget balance by effectively mobilizing Government bonds

The State Treasury ensures budget balance by effectively mobilizing Government bonds

VCN – The State Treasury continues to mobilize Government bonds effectively, thereby supporting budget management to promptly meet public spending demands.
Pressure on Corporate bond maturity will fall in mid-2024

Pressure on Corporate bond maturity will fall in mid-2024

VCN – In the first quarter of 2024, the Corporate bond placement has achieved positive results. According to assessment, in 2024, the gradual recovery of the real estate market will promote bond placement from real estate businesses as well as solve problems of late repayment of bond principal and interest in the new cycle.
Read More

Your care

Latest Most read
PM demands strengthened gold market management

PM demands strengthened gold market management

Prime Minister Pham Minh Chinh has asked the State Bank of Vietnam (SBV) to keep a close watch on international and domestic gold prices, and put in place measures and tools in a timely and effective way to regulate the gold market in line with regulations.
Budget expenditures reached VND393.5 trillion, growing 8.3% over the same period in the first quarter

Budget expenditures reached VND393.5 trillion, growing 8.3% over the same period in the first quarter

The Ministry of Finance said that the total balance of budget expenditure in March was estimated at VND140.3 trillion
Inflationary pressure stems  from commodity price fluctuations

Inflationary pressure stems from commodity price fluctuations

VCN - According to the Ministry of Finance, prices of essential goods are relatively stable in March 2024 because the supply is still quite abundant while demand is not high.
SMEs offered loans at preferential rates of 1.2-4.4%

SMEs offered loans at preferential rates of 1.2-4.4%

To create additional capital mobilisation channels for small- and medium-sized enterprises (SMEs), Vietnam’s Small- and Medium-sized Enterprise Development Fund under the Ministry of Planning and Investment is offering SMEs loans at preferential interest rates of 1.2-4.4% per year.
Public investment disbursement needs to be accelerated to boost growth: insiders

Public investment disbursement needs to be accelerated to boost growth: insiders

Public investment is currently still an important growth driver, which needs to be accelerated so as to help the economy achieve a 6.5% growth this year, according to insiders.
Mobile Version