Increasing penalties to reduce violations in independent auditing

VCN - After 12 years of implementation, the Law on Independent Auditing has provided an important legal framework for the enforcement of policies and the transparent disclosure of financial reports by businesses. However, one limitation is that the penalties are not strong enough to ensure deterrence.
Ministry of Finance: Focusing on improving independent audits Ministry of Finance: Focusing on improving independent audits
Increasing penalties to reduce violations in independent auditing
Strengthening penalties can improve the quality of audited financial reports

Independent auditing exposes shortcomings

According to data from the Ministry of Finance, Vietnam currently has around 2,400 practicing auditors who are certified to perform audit services, with over 220 audit firms certified to provide these services.

As of May 2024, 6,387 individuals had been awarded Vietnamese auditor certificates, with 2,501 actively working in auditing firms. Since 2013, 114 auditors have been suspended, thrê auditing firms have been suspended from providing auditing services, and three auditing firms have had their business licenses for providing auditing services revoked.

The Law on Independent Auditing (Law No. 67/2011/QH12), passed by the National Assembly on March 29, 2011, took effect on January 1, 2012.

The law has contributed to preventing waste and corruption, supporting the government's management and oversight of businesses, especially in ensuring financial transparency for publicly listed companies. Additionally, the government's role in audit management has gradually improved, and legal compliance monitoring has been carried out effectively.

However, with the development of the economy, society, and international integration, the current legal framework for independent auditing has revealed several shortcomings. The penalties for violations are neither strong enough nor effective enough to regulate professional conduct, and administrative sanctions lack deterrence. The process for handling violations by auditing firms and auditors remains limited due to inconsistencies in other legal provisions. Furthermore, authorities responsible for auditing inspections lack the authority to impose penalties, and the statute of limitations for penalizing violations in the field of independent auditing is only one year, resulting in cases where penalties could not be imposed due to the expiration of the statute of limitations.

In addition, regulations concerning auditing firms, audit firm branches, and practicing auditors have proven inadequate, failing to meet the needs of the economy and the required quality standards for independent auditing. The current law does not fully encompass all entities that should be audited.

In practice, many large businesses with complex transactions, significant labor forces, and substantial revenues, which have a considerable impact on the economy, should have their financial statements audited annually to ensure financial transparency. This would aid regulatory authorities and tax agencies in monitoring and managing these businesses, ensuring full tax compliance and preventing tax evasion.

The Ministry of Finance asserts that excluding such businesses from mandatory audits creates risks of inaccurate financial information and non-compliance with accounting and financial discipline, potentially leading to hidden risks. Therefore, it is crucial and urgent to include these entities under mandatory audit requirements, particularly given recent serious corporate violations.

Increasing penalties

The Ministry of Finance has drafted a law amending and supplementing several articles in laws under its jurisdiction, including the Law on Independent Auditing. One proposed solution is to strengthen the effectiveness of penalties. The draft law proposes increasing the maximum fines from VND100 million to VND3 billion for organizations and from VND50 million to VND1.5 billion for individuals, extending the statute of limitations for violations from one year to ten years, and introducing additional penalties that better reflect current conditions.

The Vietnam Association of Certified Public Accountants (VACPA) has expressed concerns that the proposed fine of VND3 billion is too high given the nature of audit operations.

However, the Ministry of Finance argues that increasing penalties not only directly boosts state revenue but also helps improve the quality of audited financial reports. It ensures that audited businesses fulfill their obligations to the state, contributing significantly to proper tax collection and increasing state revenue, thereby promoting growth. Additionally, stronger penalties will help reduce violations by audit firms and auditors, forcing these firms to restructure and organize themselves to provide higher quality audit services.

By Huong Diu/ Ha Thanh

Related News

Preventing e-invoice fraud amid e-commerce boom

Preventing e-invoice fraud amid e-commerce boom

VCN - The situation of illegal invoice trading is extremely complicated, especially in the context of e-commerce growing. This not only negatively affects legitimate businesses but also causes many other losses to the economy.
Strictly handle violations of invoices in a timely manner to avoid budget losses

Strictly handle violations of invoices in a timely manner to avoid budget losses

VCN - The General Department of Taxation has just issued a document directing local tax authorities nationwide to conduct close and timely review and supervision of businesses showing signs of risks in the illegal trade and use of invoices.
Ho Chi Minh City: Many violations in e-commerce business

Ho Chi Minh City: Many violations in e-commerce business

VCN - Since the beginning of the year, Ho Chi Minh City authorities have inspected and detected many violations in online sales.
Ha Nam Customs actively fights fraud through customs declaration

Ha Nam Customs actively fights fraud through customs declaration

VCN - To help businesses comply with the law, Ha Nam Customs Branch (Ha Nam Ninh Customs Department) is strengthening inspection and supervision measures to prevent trade fraud and abuse of online declarations to commit acts of violations.

Latest News

Proposal to reduce 30% of land rent in 2024

Proposal to reduce 30% of land rent in 2024

VCN - The Ministry of Finance has finalized a draft Government Decree outlining the reduction of land rent for 2024. The draft is currently under review by the Ministry of Justice before being submitted to the Government for approval.
Resolve problems related to tax procedures and policies for businesses

Resolve problems related to tax procedures and policies for businesses

VCN - Immediately after the end of the Dialogue Conference between the Ministry of Finance and enterprises on tax and customs policies and administrative procedures in 2024, the General Department of Customs proactively removed obstacles related to tax procedures and policies for the business community.
New regulations on procurement, exploitation, and leasing of public assets

New regulations on procurement, exploitation, and leasing of public assets

VCN - Decree No. 114/2024/ND-CP, which amends and supplements certain articles of Decree No. 151/2017/ND-CP detailing the implementation of the Law on Management and Use of Public Assets, introduces significant changes. These include updates on authority, methods of asset exploitation in agencies and units, plans for leasing, joint ventures, and partnerships in public service units, as well as centralized procurement procedures.
Actively listening to the voice of the business community

Actively listening to the voice of the business community

VCN - Recognizing the Customs-business relationship as a long-term partnership, the Customs authority has organized hundreds of dialogues with businesses since the beginning of the year. These efforts aim to promptly address challenges, resolve obstacles, and facilitate import-export activities. Such meetings offer an opportunity for the Customs authority and the business community to exchange, share insights, and find solutions to enhance operational quality and efficiency.

More News

Step up negotiations on customs commitments within the FTA framework

Step up negotiations on customs commitments within the FTA framework

VCN - Promoting negotiations on customs commitments within the framework of free trade agreements (FTAs) plays an important role in facilitating import and export activities. These commitments not only help optimize the customs clearance process but also minimize costs and risks for businesses, opening up great opportunities for Vietnamese goods to access deeper into the international market.
Proposal to amend regulations on goods circulation

Proposal to amend regulations on goods circulation

VCN - To perfect the policy on customs procedures, inspection and supervision, enterprises and associations have contributed many ideas from practical activities. Thereby, the Drafting Committee (General Department of Customs) has more perspectives to build policies to meet the goal of facilitating trade and ensuring state management of customs.
Review of VAT exemptions for imported machinery and equipment

Review of VAT exemptions for imported machinery and equipment

VCN - The General Department of Vietnam Customs has directed provincial and municipal customs departments to review, inspect, and address issues related to the implementation of VAT exemption policies for specialized machinery and equipment used in agricultural production.
Customs tightens oversight on e-commerce imports

Customs tightens oversight on e-commerce imports

VCN - The General Department of Vietnam Customs has issued new directives to enhance the management of imported goods transacted through e-commerce platforms, addressing ambiguities and ensuring consistent enforcement across provincial and municipal customs departments.
Bringing practical experience into customs management policy

Bringing practical experience into customs management policy

VCN - At the workshop to collect opinions from Southern Customs units on the draft Decree amending and supplementing Decree 08/2015/ND-CP dated January 21, 2015 of the Government; the draft Circular amending and supplementing Circular 38/2015/TT-BTC dated March 25, 2015 and Circular 39/2018/TT-BTC dated April 20, 2018 of the Minister of Finance, organized by the General Department of Customs last weekend, many Southern Customs units contributed specific contents from practical operations in the locality.
Businesses anticipate new policies on customs procedures and supervision

Businesses anticipate new policies on customs procedures and supervision

VCN - With this year’s import-export turnover estimated at nearly US$800 billion and forecasting to surpass this milestone next year, the business community holds high expectations for upcoming amendments and supplements to customs management, procedures, and supervision policies. These changes are expected not only to facilitate trade but also to enhance state management efficiency and support economic development.
Do exported foods need iodine supplementation?

Do exported foods need iodine supplementation?

VCN - Currently, Vietnamese processed food products, including seafood products, have been exported to more than 160 countries, and no country has yet required that "salt used in food processing must be salt with added iodine".
Amendments to the Value-Added Tax Law passed: Fertilizers to be taxed at 5%

Amendments to the Value-Added Tax Law passed: Fertilizers to be taxed at 5%

VCN - With the majority of National Assembly deputies voting in favor, the National Assembly officially approved the revised Value-Added Tax (VAT) Law during its afternoon session on November 26, 2024, as part of the 8th session's agenda.
Proposal to change the application time of new regulations on construction materials import

Proposal to change the application time of new regulations on construction materials import

VCN - To comply with the circular on quality management of construction materials, many businesses importing this item are complaining about difficulties and asking for an extension of the implementation time.
Read More

Your care

Latest Most read
Proposal to reduce 30% of land rent in 2024

Proposal to reduce 30% of land rent in 2024

The Ministry of Finance has finalized a draft Government Decree outlining the reduction of land rent for 2024. The draft is currently under review by the Ministry of Justice before being submitted to the Government for approval.
Resolve problems related to tax procedures and policies for businesses

Resolve problems related to tax procedures and policies for businesses

VCN - Immediately after the end of the Dialogue Conference between the Ministry of Finance and enterprises on tax and customs policies and administrative procedures in 2024, the General Department of Customs proactively removed obstacles related to tax pr
New regulations on procurement, exploitation, and leasing of public assets

New regulations on procurement, exploitation, and leasing of public assets

Decree No. 114/2024/ND-CP, which amends and supplements certain articles of Decree No. 151/2017/ND-CP detailing the implementation of the Law on Management and Use of Public Assets, introduces significant changes.
Actively listening to the voice of the business community

Actively listening to the voice of the business community

Recognizing the Customs-business relationship as a long-term partnership, the Customs authority has organized hundreds of dialogues with businesses since the beginning of the year
Step up negotiations on customs commitments within the FTA framework

Step up negotiations on customs commitments within the FTA framework

VCN - In addition to promoting negotiations on customs commitments within the framework of FTAs ​​under negotiation, the General Department of Customs actively supports businesses to effectively utilize commitments in signed FTAs, especially CPTPP, EVFTA,
Mobile Version