Handling of collateral assets: Law has not respected creditors

VCN- Handling of collateral assets to collect debt is an important solution to speed up bad debt settlement. However, this problem is facing many obstacles in reality stemming from the incomprehensible legal system that is not creating mechanisms to respect legal creditors’ rights of lenders etc.
handling of collateral assets law has not respected creditors
The right to dispose of collateral assets is still facing many problems (Illustration).

Legislation is not enough

Regarding this issue, according to Mr. Pham Manh Thang, Deputy General Director of the Vietnam Foreign Trade Joint Stock Commercial Bank (Vietcombank), the key to handling collateral assets is to determine the value and responsibility of handling. There are some cases where banks approv for customers to borrow with collateral assets of about 60-70% value of the loan, but when requesting repayment, the legislation still considers the collateral asset belong to the borrower, the banks do not have responsibility in handling, while it is clear that the banks have spent a great fortune, so that they should have the full right of handling that asset.

Not only that, Mr. Thang is also pressing to assume that, in principle, collateral asset value is considered to be equal with the loan account, but the current legislation regulates that the collateral asset is not lower than the loans and does not affect the rights of the borrowers when the banks handling the loans. Thus, in the process of debt collecting, if the borrower does not cooperate, and refuses to sign an agreement on price, or does not accept the deal etc., the banks cannot recover the debt.

In addition, representatives of Vietcombank also shared that, with the loans guaranteed by a third party, when the borrowers cannot repay, the legislation requires the banks to handle the collateral assets of the borrowers first instead of the third party. If the collateral assets of the borrower cannot be handled then the property of third parties is the same so that the debt handling will be suspended and wasteful.

"Collateral asset also has a risk ratio, so with the case of three parties as mentioned above, it is necessary to firstly handle the easy collateral asset to quickly recover capital, then returning the capital flows to other manufacturing and business activities", Mr. Pham Manh Thang proposed.

Also experiencing the same problem, Mrs. Bui Nhu Y, Deputy Director of the Industry and Trade Joint Stock Bank of Vietnam (VietinBank) adds, the handling of collateral assets in housing investment projects still does not have specific guidelines. Therefore, when the bank accepts a collateral asset for housing investment projects, the handling may be prolonged, causing difficulties and confusion in the implementation process.

The implementation process is prolonged

It is from such problems, according to the statistics of Vietcombank, in 2016, the average time for civil enforcement agencies at all levels to recover debt for this bank with the collateral asset are housing (35% of cases), the collateral as a means of transportation, machinery and equipment (33% of cases) took over 24 months. But there are cases that took 5 years for handling with nearly 30 times of discounting. This process is not only time-consuming but also caused cost to the bank, significantly impacting business activities.

According to statistics of the Vietnam Technological and Commercial Joint Stock Bank (Techcombank), debt settlement is delayed or stalled because of the complex and prolonged litigation procedure and enforcement. The majority of the debt to be recovered by way of court and judgment usually lasts for more than 2 years creating a bad effect.

Mr. Thieu Anh Duong, General Director of the Techcombank AMC said the seizure, sale, transfer of ownership, and some collateral asset debt collection of Techcombank lasted for years. Particularly, there are many cases of property auctions having taken place since 2013, but until now, the property has not been transferred to the auction winner since the guarantors did not cooperate and local authorities could not agree.

In fact, Decree 163/2006/NĐ-CP on the right to handle collateral assets has allowed credit institutions to proactively deal with collateral assets or sue. But this method has not yet been effective, the main reason is because the current law does not have specific regulations, clearly and correctly identifying the responsibilities for processing of the lender and the borrower. Besides, representatives of the banks also indicated the status of "overdue", deliberately prolonging the execution time of not only the borrower but also the enforcement agencies.

"Although the banks previously submitted records and plans to seize property in accordance with local government regulations, but the local government still disagrees to support, even to prevent collateral asset handling of the banks by "inviting” the bank officials for testimony overnight; or ask the bank not to seize or require them to go out of the property area; in many cases, the banks are required to return the property that they just seized from the borrowers", said Mr. Anh Duong Thieu.

From this situation, Mr. Pham Manh Thang said, the thinking of managers has not changed, when they see that the banks as "the rich" while the borrowers are “the poor”, so that they only protect the collateral assets of the borrowers instead of the banks, then not defining this property is parity, not fully allocated to the bank to handle. Therefore, if this thinking does not change in the process of enacting and promulgating the law, the banks will suffer, and many debts will not be recovered quickly, turn into bad debts, affecting the banks activities.

By Hương Dịu/ Huu Tuc

Related News

Quang Ninh Customs: making efforts to help businesses improve compliance

Quang Ninh Customs: making efforts to help businesses improve compliance

VCN - Quang Ninh Customs Department has synchronously deploys support activities, guidance, answers questions, provided information, and warned of risks to help businesses proactively prevent and avoid violations, and voluntarily improve their compliance with customs laws.
Amending the Law on Corporate Income Tax, not giving preferential treatment to overlapping and spreading industries

Amending the Law on Corporate Income Tax, not giving preferential treatment to overlapping and spreading industries

VCN - The promulgation of the Law on Corporate Income Tax (amended) is necessary, in line with international practice, associated with restructuring revenue sources, expanding the tax base in line with the context of socio-economic development.
Revising the title of a draft of 1 Law amending seven finance-related laws

Revising the title of a draft of 1 Law amending seven finance-related laws

VCN - On November 19, 2024, the Standing Committee of the National Assembly (SCNA) discussed amendments and refinements to the draft of a law revising seven existing finance-related laws. Concluding the session, Vice Chairman of the National Assembly Nguyen Duc Hai emphasized the need for the Government to direct the drafting body and relevant agencies to collaborate closely to finalize a persuasive and widely supported report, ensuring the quality of the draft law for the National Assembly's consideration and decision.
Removing difficulties in public investment disbursement

Removing difficulties in public investment disbursement

VCN - According to the report of the Investment Department (Ministry of Finance), the estimated disbursement from the beginning of the year to October 31, 2024 is VND 355,616.1 billion, reaching 47.43% of the 2024 plan, reaching 52.29% of the plan assigned by the Prime Minister.
Comment

Latest News

Embracing green exports: a pathway to enter global supply chains

Embracing green exports: a pathway to enter global supply chains

This shift presents both a challenge and an opportunity for Vietnamese businesses to innovate and enhance their competitive edge in the international arena.
New policy proposed to prevent transfer pricing, tax evasion of FDI enterprises

New policy proposed to prevent transfer pricing, tax evasion of FDI enterprises

The ministry proposes to issue a decree on the establishment, management and use of the Investment Support Fund to stabilise the investment environment, encourage and attract strategic investors and multinational corporations.
Việt Nam’s durian exports to China plummet by 80%

Việt Nam’s durian exports to China plummet by 80%

This sharp decline has had a direct impact on Việt Nam’s fruit and vegetable export revenue, which stood at US$416 million in January 2025, marking a 11.3 per cent decrease month-on-month and a 5.2 per cent drop year-on-year.
Coconut exports reach 14-year high

Coconut exports reach 14-year high

In 2024, fresh coconut and coconut product exports surpassed US$1 billion, marking the highest figure in the past 14 years.

More News

Shrimp exports grow in the first month of 2025

Shrimp exports grow in the first month of 2025

According to data from the Việt Nam Association of Seafood Exporters and Producers (VASEP), shrimp products recorded a 13 per cent increase in export value in January 2025, reaching a total of $273.3 million.
Rice export prices drop, but decline expected to be short-term

Rice export prices drop, but decline expected to be short-term

Việt Nam’s rice export prices have declined, reaching their lowest level in three years.
Key agro products expected to maintain export growth this year

Key agro products expected to maintain export growth this year

At present, agricultural exports, such as rice, coffee and seafood, have steadily secured a stable place in major global markets.
EU issues 12 warnings against Việt Nam’s food and agricultural exports

EU issues 12 warnings against Việt Nam’s food and agricultural exports

The Việt Nam SPS Office has reported that some Vietnamese export products failed to meet the EU’s stringent standards.
Việt Nam to impose VAT on low-value express-imported goods

Việt Nam to impose VAT on low-value express-imported goods

Việt Nam will end a previous policy that exempted imported goods valued under VNĐ1 million (US$39.4) from taxes when shipped via express delivery.
Exchange rate risks need attention in near future

Exchange rate risks need attention in near future

VCN - Exchange rate developments in 2025 are considered to be quite complicated due to US policies related to trade and investment.
Vietnam kicked off the year with a strong start in trade, exceeding US$63 billion in the first month

Vietnam kicked off the year with a strong start in trade, exceeding US$63 billion in the first month

VCN - Data from the General Department of Vietnam Customs indicates a softening of both exports and imports in January 2025, relative to the same month in 2024.
Import and export turnover reaches about US$29 billion in the second half of January 2025

Import and export turnover reaches about US$29 billion in the second half of January 2025

VCN - Vietnam's total import and export turnover in the second half of January 2025 (January 16-31, 2025) reached US$28.9 billion, the latest preliminary statistics of the General Department of Vietnam Customs reported.
Market edges up slightly as liquidity remains low

Market edges up slightly as liquidity remains low

Market breadth remained positive, with 161 gainers outnumbering 144 decliners.
Read More

Your care

The system has not recorded your reading habits.

Please Login/Register so that the system can provide articles according to your reading needs.

Latest Most read
Embracing green exports: a pathway to enter global supply chains

Embracing green exports: a pathway to enter global supply chains

This shift presents both a challenge and an opportunity for Vietnamese businesses to innovate and enhance their competitive edge in the international arena.
New policy proposed to prevent transfer pricing, tax evasion of FDI enterprises

New policy proposed to prevent transfer pricing, tax evasion of FDI enterprises

The ministry proposes to issue a decree on the establishment, management and use of the Investment Support Fund to stabilise the investment environment, encourage and attract strategic investors and multinational corporations.
Việt Nam’s durian exports to China plummet by 80%

Việt Nam’s durian exports to China plummet by 80%

This sharp decline has had a direct impact on Việt Nam’s fruit and vegetable export revenue, which stood at US$416 million in January 2025, marking a 11.3 per cent decrease month-on-month and a 5.2 per cent drop year-on-year.
Coconut exports reach 14-year high

Coconut exports reach 14-year high

In 2024, fresh coconut and coconut product exports surpassed US$1 billion, marking the highest figure in the past 14 years.
Shrimp exports grow in the first month of 2025

Shrimp exports grow in the first month of 2025

According to data from the Việt Nam Association of Seafood Exporters and Producers (VASEP), shrimp products recorded a 13 per cent increase in export value in January 2025, reaching a total of $273.3 million.
Mobile Version