Vietnam, US strike deal to end shrimp fight
Shrimp exports to UK plunge slightly | |
Export of farmed fish fetches nearly US$3.1 billion |
The litigation stemming from anti-dumping duties are: United States – Anti-dumping Measures on Certain Shrimp from Vietnam (DS404) and United States – Anti-dumping Measures on Certain Shrimp from Vietnam (DS429).
Under the terms of the settlement, the US will remove a Vietnamese shrimp exporter — Minh Phu Group — from a 2005 duty order on shrimp imports and repay the company for duty deposits.
Although the resolution amounts to a full reversal of the decision and punishment for Minh Phu, the anti-dumping duty order on Vietnamese shrimp will remain in place for all other producers.
The Vietnam government had launched a two-pronged assault on the US shrimp order, bringing one WTO case in 2010 and another in 2012 and the settlement represents a gigantic victory in both cases.
Most importantly, the government successfully argued two key issues in connection with the cases, for which the WTO disputes settlement panel sided with it— and the US acquiesced to them in the settlement.
First of all, the Vietnam government and subsequently the WTO took issue with the US reliance on a controversial duty calculation method known as zeroing. Zeroing is a complex practice that artificially inflates dumping margins.
The US in the negotiated settlement agreed to put an end to the practice.
Secondly, the government was triumphant on the central issue of what exactly is fair in determining the proper prices of exports from non-market economies like Vietnam into market economies like the US.
It is important to understand that Vietnam, like China, is considered by the WTO to be a non-market economy and as such the law in the US as applies to them is, in many respects, different than that applicable to market countries.
Market Economy vs Non-Market Economy
The WTO agreed with the Vietnam government and faulted the US practice in anti-dumping cases of starting with a ‘rebuttable presumption’ that all exporters from non-market economies are government controlled, state-sponsored entities.
In essence for non-market economies such as Vietnam, under GATT 1994, importing countries such as the US have the right to exercise significant discretion in the calculation of the normal value of products exported within the confines of anti-dumping disputes.
In short, this non-market status has up until this agreement allowed the US to skate by placing the burden on Vietnamese companies to prove they are not government controlled.
The WTO sided with the Vietnam government essentially shifting the burden from Vietnam to the US to prove that the Vietnamese company is government controlled, again a major victory favouring Vietnam, which was borne out in the final settlement.
Assistant US Trade Representative Barbara Weisel, who headed the US delegation in the settlement talks, applauded the deal as an important stepping stone for the future of Vietnam-US trade.
“We welcome the resolution of this long-standing issue,” she said in a statement “This agreement demonstrates the commitment of the United States and Vietnam to address outstanding issues as we work to take our relationship to the next level.”
Related News
Vietnam, Korea Customs sign AEO MRA
11:07 | 26/12/2024 Customs
Promoting agricultural exports to the Japanese market
13:55 | 22/12/2024 Import-Export
Paving the way for Vietnamese agricultural products in China
11:08 | 26/12/2024 Import-Export
Latest News
Nghệ An Province anticipates record FDI amidst economic upswing
15:49 | 26/12/2024 Import-Export
Green farming development needs supportive policies to attract investors
15:46 | 26/12/2024 Import-Export
Vietnamese enterprises adapt to green logistics trend
15:43 | 26/12/2024 Import-Export
VN seafood export surpass 2024 goal of $10 billion
14:59 | 25/12/2024 Import-Export
More News
Exporters urged to actively prepare for trade defence investigation risks when exporting to the UK
14:57 | 25/12/2024 Import-Export
Electronic imports exceed $100 billion
14:55 | 25/12/2024 Import-Export
Forestry exports set a record of $17.3 billion
14:49 | 25/12/2024 Import-Export
Hanoi: Maximum support for affiliating production and sustainable consumption of agricultural products
09:43 | 25/12/2024 Import-Export
Việt Nam boosts supporting industries with development programmes
13:56 | 24/12/2024 Import-Export
VN's wood industry sees chances and challenges from US new trade policies
13:54 | 24/12/2024 Import-Export
Vietnam's fruit, vegetable exports reach new milestone, topping 7 billion USD
13:49 | 24/12/2024 Import-Export
Aquatic exports hit 10 billion USD
13:45 | 24/12/2024 Import-Export
Hong Kong: A gateway for Vietnamese businesses to access the Greater Bay Area market
09:04 | 24/12/2024 Import-Export
Your care
Nghệ An Province anticipates record FDI amidst economic upswing
15:49 | 26/12/2024 Import-Export
Green farming development needs supportive policies to attract investors
15:46 | 26/12/2024 Import-Export
Vietnamese enterprises adapt to green logistics trend
15:43 | 26/12/2024 Import-Export
Paving the way for Vietnamese agricultural products in China
11:08 | 26/12/2024 Import-Export
VN seafood export surpass 2024 goal of $10 billion
14:59 | 25/12/2024 Import-Export