State-owned securities company trails competitors

Contrary to the outstanding performances in the banking sector, the securities subsidiaries of major banks have yet to fully leverage their potential, despite numerous inherent advantages.
VPS leads in brokerage market share (Photo: Vietnamnet)

VPS leads in brokerage market share (Photo: Vietnamnet)

Currently, the Big4 state-owned banks - Vietcombank, Vietinbank, Agribank and BIDV - continue to serve as effective extensions of state regulators in guiding the financial market and implementing monetary policies.

However, the securities subsidiaries of these Big4 banks remain relatively unremarkable, leaving limited impact on the market.

Among the top 10 securities brokerage firms by market share in the third quarter, as per the list published by the Ho Chi Minh Stock Exchange (HoSE), familiar names like VPS Securities, SSI Securities Corporation, Ho Chi Minh City Securities Corporation and VietCap led the rankings.

Despite a slight decline in market share, long-standing players such as VNDirect Securities Corporation and MB Securities retained their top ten status, while new entrants like Techcombank Securities and especially VPS have energised the brokerage market, intensifying competition.

Notably absent from this list are state-owned entities like Vietcombank Securities Company (VCBS), BIDV Securities (BSC), Vietinbank Securities (CTS) and Agribank Securities Corporation (Agriseco), which are backed by Vietcombank, BIDV, Vietinbank and Agribank, respectively.

This discrepancy raises questions within the investment community, especially since the Big4 banks, as primary stakeholders, continue to hold leading positions in the banking industry.

Backed by parent banks

State-owned securities companies were established long before most private securities firms in Vietnam. They received comprehensive support from their parent banks, which are key players in the Vietnamese financial system.

For instance, BSC, founded in 1999, was among the first two securities companies in Vietnam and the first one linked to a bank.

CTS and Agriseco were established in Hanoi in 2000 by their parent banks. Although VCBS joined later in 2002, nearly two years after the Ho Chi Minh Stock Exchange was officially launched, it was founded by a decision from Vietcombank’s board of directors.

These state-owned securities companies benefitted from their parent banks’ brand reputation, extensive business networks, high-quality human resources and abundant financial resources.

Additionally, their sales and service networks, present nationwide and continuously expanded since inception, provided a strategic advantage.
Underperformance

Despite their early market entry and competitive advantages, the growth of these securities subsidiaries has not matched the accomplishments of their parent banks.

The Big4 banks have continued to succeed in shaping the banking sector and have driven growth in pillar stocks with steady double-digit growth rates. In contrast, their securities subsidiaries have struggled to keep up with the broader securities industry.

These firms have not managed to break into the top ten in brokerage market share.

Their capital bases, essential for growth, remain modest at approximately 4.3 trillion VND or 169.3 million USD (BSC) (169.3 million USD), 2.5 trillion VND (VCBS), 2.16 trillion VND (Agriseco), and less than 1.5 trillion VND (CTS).

In comparison, private firms like SSI (nearly 20 trillion VND), Saigon - Hanoi Securities (17.1 trillion VND) and VIX Securities (nearly 15 trillion VND) far exceed these capital levels, sometimes surpassing the combined capital of the four state-owned firms.

The state-owned securities firms have largely stayed out of the industry’s intense capital race, which aims to prepare for Vietnam’s potential upgrade to emerging market status. Such an upgrade will require sufficient capital buffers and financial strength, especially for key growth areas like margin lending and proprietary trading.

Reflecting their modest capital bases, CTS and Agriseco report quarterly net profits of only a few dozen billions dong, while VCBS and BSC perform slightly better with quarterly profits of around 100 - 150 billion VND, about 10 - 20% of the profit levels achieved by leading private securities companies like SSI, TCBS, VPS and VNDirect.

Signs of transformation

In anticipation of a possible inflow of capital from an emerging market upgrade, some state-owned securities firms are starting to begin transformations.
BSC, for example, has been actively expanding its growth potential and quality. At the end of 2022, Hana Securities became BSC's second-largest shareholder, acquiring a 35% stake. This capital injection raised BSC’s charter capital from 1.22 trillion VND to 1.88 trillion VND, providing nearly 2.7 trillion VND to fund business activities.

Beyond capital, BSC and Hana are launching new projects, including digital transformation initiatives and IT infrastructure upgrades, like the KRX trading system (a Korean technology advantage) and expanding their domestic and international client network.

Early last year, BSC partnered with Edmond de Rothschild, part of the Rothschild family’s financial ecosystem, to establish a fund management company in Vietnam.

This joint venture aims to develop optimal investment products for Vietnamese investors, leveraging the combined expertise of BIDV, Edmond de Rothschild, Hana Securities and BSC. This collaboration is a stepping stone for BSC in its ambition to become Vietnam’s first fully-fledged investment bank.

CTS has also made steady strides in recent years, showing consistent growth in proprietary trading and margin lending by five to 10% each quarter. This firm has expanded its listed stock portfolio to more than 1 trillion VND, marking a record within its peer group./.

Source: VNA
en.vietnamplus.vn

Related News

Latest News

Focusing on inspecting inventory of public assets at units with large and complex assets

Focusing on inspecting inventory of public assets at units with large and complex assets

VCN - According to Official Dispatch No. 1456/BTC-QLCS on inspecting the preparation and implementation of the General Inventory of Public Assets recently issued by the Ministry of Finance, the inspection of the inventory of public assets focuses on units with large asset scale and large number of inventory items, complex assets, and slow implementation progress.
The government seeks approval for revised GDP, CPI targets

The government seeks approval for revised GDP, CPI targets

VCN - The Government submitted to the National Assembly for consideration and comments on adjusting the target for the growth rate of gross domestic product (GDP) to 8% or more; the average growth rate of the consumer price index (CPI) to about 4.5-5%.
Fiscal, monetary policies support demand stimulation, price stabilisation

Fiscal, monetary policies support demand stimulation, price stabilisation

These efforts, in conjunction with the implementation of monetary policies and other macroeconomic policies, aim to solve difficulties for businesses and the public, stabilise the macroeconomy, control inflation, ensure the balance of the economy, promote economic growth, and secure social welfare and people’s livelihoods.
Vietnam secures VND 157 billion from state enterprise divestment in 2024

Vietnam secures VND 157 billion from state enterprise divestment in 2024

VCN - The Ministry of Finance reported that in 2024, the divestment of state capital in 5 enterprises (F1) generated VND 157 billion from an initial value of VND 145 billion

More News

Vietnam gears up for potential inflation impact in 2025

Vietnam gears up for potential inflation impact in 2025

VCN - For sound price management and inflation control, Deputy Prime Minister Ho Duc Phoc directed officials to vigilantly track both domestic and international market dynamics. The goal is to proactively develop flexible strategies and solutions, enabling a swift response to any emerging challenges.
VN’s credit conditions in 2025 expected to be stable

VN’s credit conditions in 2025 expected to be stable

The credit conditions for Việt Nam will stabilise in 2025, after improving substantially over the past year, the rating agency VIS is forcasts.
State revenue in first month of the year equal to 14% of the estimate

State revenue in first month of the year equal to 14% of the estimate

VCN - According to the Ministry of Finance, in January - the first month of 2025, the total state budget revenue is estimated at VND275.9 trillion, equal to 14% of the estimate; meanwhile, the total state budget expenditure is estimated at VND134.4 trillion.
Securities 2025 expects a breakthrough in scale and quality

Securities 2025 expects a breakthrough in scale and quality

VCN – The positive factors inherent in the macro economy and the Vietnamese stock market will continue to create the foundation for the market to maintain stability, good liquidity, and growth in both scale and quality in the new year of At Ty 2025, Chairwoman of the State Securities Commission Vu Thi Chan Phuong said.
Cash reserves in stock accounts at six-quarter low amid margin rise

Cash reserves in stock accounts at six-quarter low amid margin rise

These funds are readily available in investor accounts, but remained undeployed as of the year-end.
Five solutions for developing stock market in 2025

Five solutions for developing stock market in 2025

VCN - On February 5, 2025, at the Gong-beating ceremony to open the stock trading at the Ho Chi Minh City Stock Exchange (HOSE), Deputy Minister of Finance Nguyen Duc Chi introduced five solutions for comprehensive development of the stock market.
Minister of Finance Nguyen Van Thang works with GDVC at the first working day after the Tet holiday

Minister of Finance Nguyen Van Thang works with GDVC at the first working day after the Tet holiday

VCN- On February 3, the first working day after the Tet holiday, Minister of Finance Nguyen Van Thang and the delegation visited and worked with the General Department of Vietnam Customs (GDVC).
The stock market after Tết 2025 presents both challenges and opportunities

The stock market after Tết 2025 presents both challenges and opportunities

Việt Nam’s stock market following the 2025 Lunar New Year (Tết Nguyên Đán) presents a complex landscape of risks and potential gains, driven by foreign capital inflows, economic resilience, and looming corporate bond maturity pressures, according to one securities expert.
Opportunities and challenges in Việt Nam

Opportunities and challenges in Việt Nam's crypto boom

Việt Nam boasts one of the most active investment communities in the cryptocurrency sector. However, protecting investors and promoting sustainable growth requires a robust legal framework.
Read More

Your care

Latest Most read
Focusing on inspecting inventory of public assets at units with large and complex assets

Focusing on inspecting inventory of public assets at units with large and complex assets

VCN - According to Official Dispatch No. 1456/BTC-QLCS on inspecting the preparation and implementation of the General Inventory of Public Assets recently issued by the Ministry of Finance, the inspection of the inventory of public assets focuses on units
The government seeks approval for revised GDP, CPI targets

The government seeks approval for revised GDP, CPI targets

The Government submitted to the National Assembly for consideration and comments on adjusting the target for the growth rate of gross domestic product (GDP) to 8% or more
Fiscal, monetary policies support demand stimulation, price stabilisation

Fiscal, monetary policies support demand stimulation, price stabilisation

These efforts, in conjunction with the implementation of monetary policies and other macroeconomic policies, aim to solve difficulties for businesses and the public, stabilise the macroeconomy, control inflation, ensure the balance of the economy, promote economic growth, and secure social welfare and people’s livelihoods.
Vietnam secures VND 157 billion from state enterprise divestment in 2024

Vietnam secures VND 157 billion from state enterprise divestment in 2024

The Ministry of Finance reported that in 2024, the divestment of state capital in 5 enterprises (F1) generated VND 157 billion from an initial value of VND 145 billion
Vietnam gears up for potential inflation impact in 2025

Vietnam gears up for potential inflation impact in 2025

For sound price management and inflation control, Deputy Prime Minister Ho Duc Phoc directed officials to vigilantly track both domestic and international market dynamics.
Mobile Version