Remove gold monopoly to bounce back its normal state

VCN - According to Dr. Le Xuan Nghia, member of the National Financial and Monetary Policy Advisory Council, gold should be allowed to return to its normal state because the fear of "goldization" only occurs when gold is deposited in commercial banks as a form of deposit. The most radical solution to eliminate the unreasonably huge gap in domestic and international gold prices is still to allow gold imports.
Prof. Le Xuan Nghia
Prof. Le Xuan Nghia

Since 2021, world and domestic gold prices have recorded many fluctuations. How do you assess this situation and what do you think is the cause?

Globally, gold is a very common commodity. In contrast, Vietnam market highly appreciate gold and many times Vietnam are "panic" because of gold. In fact, the fear of "goldization" only occurs when gold is deposited in commercial banks (gold becomes deposits or loans). Meanwhile, the State Bank (SBV) has separated gold from the banking system, prohibiting the use of gold as a means of mobilization and lending, so the risk of goldization no longer exists, even if gold is used to buy real estate, that is not called goldization.

The gold monopoly began in 2013, but for the entire period from 2014 to 2019, the market was quite stable, with no significant difference in domestic and world gold prices. However, since 2020 due to the global gold price increase, domestic gold prices increased faster, leading to a gap. In this context, we need to fully analyze and evaluate many factors, because from 2014 until now the market is still subject to the same policy, but market developments in the period 2014 - 2019 and the period 2020 - 2024 are completely different. In my opinion, the reason is because from 2020, the gold supply has been in shortage, which also partly creates a price difference.

Besides, currently, the quality of SJC gold bars is there is no difference between the quality of SJC gold bars and other gold bar brands, so the large price difference is unreasonable. Therefore, it is necessary to remove the monopoly on SJC gold bars so that businesses can do business on an equal basis like other businesses.

Although the State Bank of Vietnam conducted 7 SJC gold bar auction to increase supply to the market, the gap difference between domestic and world gold prices and the "gold fever" still show no signs of stopping. So is gold auction a solution to deal with "dancing" gold prices and what solutions do we need to implement to control gold prices, sir?

The record increase in world gold prices is due to rushing buying of overseas central banks to increase reserves. In that context, the State Bank should have studied increasing purchases of gold reserves rather than putting gold up for auction. Because the bidding method is not a complete solution but can only be a short-term temporary solution rather than a fundamental, long-term measure.

To eliminate the difference between domestic gold and world gold, commercial measures are needed, which is a fundamental solution and according to international practice. That is, it will allow qualified companies to import and export gold, using taxes and electronic customs for management. Because gold bidding is not a measure to increase supply; therefore, we can allow gold businesses to import and export gold and the State controls it with taxes. In this way, within 1 week, domestic and world gold prices are immediately equal. Because, gold and silver imports from Singapore, Hong Kong (China), and Thailand to Vietnam are very quickly.

However, it is a common thinking that if gold is imported and exported, it will affect the exchange rate as well as concerns about the source of foreign currency to import gold. What is your opinion on this issue?

In fact, the amount of foreign currency used to import gold is estimated to be not large, only about 3 billion USD, much lower than importing petroleum, less than 50% of vegetables or 20% of remittances, so we will not be too worried about this exchange rate. However, the tax level needs to be considered moderate to prevent gold smuggling due to high tax.

In particular, Vietnam is famous for processing gold jewelry. If the domestic gold price is equal to the world price, Vietnam can export jewelry like China and India do. This is also an important export item for these two countries. If the difference in domestic and world gold prices can be "valued", foreign currency from jewelry exports can compensate for imported raw materials.

Thank you, Sir!

Xuan Thao (record)/ Thu Phuong

Related News

Finding investment direction for market fluctuations

Finding investment direction for market fluctuations

VCN - Many indicators show that there are still many variables that can impact financial investment activities in the second half of 2024. However, the economy is still in recovery, so calculating and choosing investment channels appropriately, closely monitoring and evaluating new developments are important for investors to pay attention to.
Ha Tinh Customs strictly controls smuggling and illegal transportation of gold across border

Ha Tinh Customs strictly controls smuggling and illegal transportation of gold across border

VCN - If the past gold smugglers used to choose the southwest border provinces to bring smuggled gold into Vietnam, there has been a shift in location. On May 11, Ha Tinh Customs seized 4 kg of gold transported across the border of Cau Treo international border gate. Customs Magazine reporter had an interview with Mr. Nguyen Dinh Long (photo), Deputy Director of Ha Tinh Customs Department about anti-gold smuggling work.
Drastically combat gold smuggling

Drastically combat gold smuggling

VCN – The Customs industry has closely managed customs control area, contributing to ensuring stability and safety of the gold market, protecting consumers, and preventing the state revenue.
Customs takes drastic measures to prevent gold and foreign currency smuggling

Customs takes drastic measures to prevent gold and foreign currency smuggling

VCN – The General Department of Vietnam Customs (GDVC) has requested the Anti-Smuggling and Investigation Department and relevant units to actively and strictly control and handle gold and foreign currency smuggling across borders.

Latest News

PM asks for solutions towards 95% of public investment disbursement rate

PM asks for solutions towards 95% of public investment disbursement rate

Prime Minister Pham Minh Chinh has asked for breakthrough solutions to fulfil the target of 95% in the disbursement rate of public investment capital in 2024.
Industrial production has not yet been able to fully recover as before the Covid-19 pandemic

Industrial production has not yet been able to fully recover as before the Covid-19 pandemic

VCN - Industrial production in the second quarter of 2024 grew more positively than in the first quarter of 2024, the value added growth rate was estimated at 8.55% over the same period last year. In the first six months of the year, the added value of the industrial sector increased by 7.54% over the same period last year, of which the processing and manufacturing industry increased by 8.67%.
PM urges measures to remove obstacles to e-commerce

PM urges measures to remove obstacles to e-commerce

Prime Minister Pham Minh Chinh has stressed the need to implement specific tasks in order to untangle knots in e-commerce development, according to the Government Office.
European firms hope for Vietnam’s continuous policy adjustments: EuroCham survey

European firms hope for Vietnam’s continuous policy adjustments: EuroCham survey

The European Chamber of Commerce in Vietnam (EuroCham) on July 15 released its Business Confidence Index (BCI) report for the second quarter of 2024, which reveals a marginal decline from 52.8 in Q1 to 51.3 in Q2, underscoring the necessity for ongoing policy adjustments to maintain momentum.

More News

Six factors positively impact economic growth in 2024

Six factors positively impact economic growth in 2024

VCN- Minister of Planning and Investment (MPI) Tran Quoc Phuong said there are 6 factors that will positively impact economic growth in the remaining months of 2024.
Vietnam attends 14th annual East Sea conference in US

Vietnam attends 14th annual East Sea conference in US

A Vietnamese delegation led by Vice President of Diplomatic Academy of Vietnam Nguyen Hung Son attended the 14th annual conference on East Sea (also known as South China Sea) held by the Washington DC-based Centre for Strategic and International Studies (CSIS) on July 11.
President’s state visits contribute to strengthening Vietnam-Laos-Cambodia cooperation: FM

President’s state visits contribute to strengthening Vietnam-Laos-Cambodia cooperation: FM

Vietnamese President To Lam’s state visits to Laos and Cambodia from July 11-13 have contributed to enhancing the traditional and effective cooperation among the three countries, Minister of Foreign Affairs Bui Thanh Son has said.
HCM City gears up for future workforce challenges

HCM City gears up for future workforce challenges

A recently approved labour and employment strategy of Ho Chi Minh City outlines potential challenges and opportunities for its workforce between 2023 and 2030.
Important innovation in the draft Law on Management and Investment of State Capital at Enterprises

Important innovation in the draft Law on Management and Investment of State Capital at Enterprises

VCN - Continue to collect comments on the draft Law on Management and Investment of State Capital at Enterprises, representatives of state-owned enterprises all said that the work of developing the Law needs to pay attention to avoid overlap when implementing with other related laws.
Vietnamese economy recovers rapidly thanks to drastic actions: IMF expert

Vietnamese economy recovers rapidly thanks to drastic actions: IMF expert

Vietnam's economy recovered rapidly in the first half of 2024 after a challenging period at the end of 2022 and early 2023, thanks to its government’s drastic actions, according to Paulo Medas, head of the International Monetary Fund (IMF)’s 2024 Article IV Mission to Vietnam.
President arrives in Phnom Penh, beginning state visit to Cambodia

President arrives in Phnom Penh, beginning state visit to Cambodia

State President To Lam arrived at the Phnom Penh International Airport on July 12 afternoon, starting his two-day state visit to Cambodia at an invitation of King Preah Bat Samdech Preah Boromneath Norodom Sihamoni.
Government unveils plan to empower intellectual workforce for national growth

Government unveils plan to empower intellectual workforce for national growth

The Government has issued a resolution outlining its action programme to continue building and elevating the role of intellectual workforce for national rapid and sustainable development in the new era.
President To Lam sets off for state visits to Laos, Cambodia

President To Lam sets off for state visits to Laos, Cambodia

President To Lam and a high-ranking delegation of Vietnam left Hanoi on July 11 morning for three-day state visits to Laos and Cambodia.
Read More

Your care

Latest Most read
PM asks for solutions towards 95% of public investment disbursement rate

PM asks for solutions towards 95% of public investment disbursement rate

Prime Minister Pham Minh Chinh has asked for breakthrough solutions to fulfil the target of 95% in the disbursement rate of public investment capital in 2024.
Industrial production has not yet been able to fully recover as before the Covid-19 pandemic

Industrial production has not yet been able to fully recover as before the Covid-19 pandemic

Industrial production in the second quarter of 2024 grew more positively than in the first quarter of 2024, the value added growth rate was estimated at 8.55% over the same period last year.
PM urges measures to remove obstacles to e-commerce

PM urges measures to remove obstacles to e-commerce

Prime Minister Pham Minh Chinh has stressed the need to implement specific tasks in order to untangle knots in e-commerce development, according to the Government Office.
European firms hope for Vietnam’s continuous policy adjustments: EuroCham survey

European firms hope for Vietnam’s continuous policy adjustments: EuroCham survey

The European Chamber of Commerce in Vietnam (EuroCham) on July 15 released its Business Confidence Index (BCI) report for the second quarter of 2024, which reveals a marginal decline from 52.8 in Q1 to 51.3 in Q2, underscoring the necessity for ongoing policy adjustments to maintain momentum.
Six factors positively impact economic growth in 2024

Six factors positively impact economic growth in 2024

VCN - Analyzing more specifically the basis for this recommendation, according to the representative of the Ministry of Planning and Investment, there are 6 factors that create a positive impact on economic growth in the remaining months of 2024.
Mobile Version