Good bidding mechanism, ensuring transparency will attract investors

VCN - This is the opinion of Prof. Nguyen Mai (photo), Chairman of the Association of Foreign Investment Enterprises in an interview with Customs Newspaper about the issue of attracting foreign investment into the public-private partnership (PPP) projects.

good bidding mechanism ensuring transparency will attract investors Break down bidding packages to allow businesses to participate more in public investment projects
good bidding mechanism ensuring transparency will attract investors New round of bidding to be opened to buy insufficient quantity of reserve rice under Prime Minister's direction
good bidding mechanism ensuring transparency will attract investors Assoc. Prof. Dr. Tran Chung, VaRSI Chairman: Only a number of urgent bidding packages should be appointed
good bidding mechanism ensuring transparency will attract investors
Prof. Nguyen Mai, Chairman of Association of Foreign Investment Enterprises


The PPP Law will be discussed at the 9th Session of the XIV National Assembly. Do you have any comments on the enactment of the PPP bill in the context that Vietnam is in urgent need of attracting investment, especially foreign investment in key projects?

PPP is not a new issue. Since 1994, we have approved the first PPP project of Sao Mai - Ben Dinh port project (Vung Tau) in the form of Build-Operate-Transfer (BOT), which has a total investment of US$650 million.However, in the wake of the regional economic crisis, Singaporean investors were unable to carry out this project.

By 2011, the Ministry of Planning and Investment has begun sending officials to the UK to study PPP investment. Up to now, it can be affirmed that success in PPP in Vietnam is not significant, there are many obstacles in the field of transportation.

The Association of Foreign Investment Enterprises has also submitted a document to the Government and the National Assembly, saying that the promulgation of the PPP Law is very necessary, but it is advisable to study the practical situation of the implementation of PPP investment projects in Vietnam. For more than 20 years, a suitable PPP Law has attracted huge investment resources from the private sector, especially foreign investors. PPP investment as well as any other form of investment is not only the experience of the world but also has its own characteristics and adaptability to each country.

Is the PPP Law currently attractive to foreign investors? What do foreign investors really care about in the PPP Law?

Currently, there are three issues that foreign investors as well as domestic investors are interested in.

First of all, it is the guarantee issue. PPP investment is the distribution of benefits between investors and the Government. With PPP investment, no investor will invest 100% of the capital. Besides, the capital amount invested by the investor, the State may contribute by the state budget or loans, capital from the issuance of projected bonds. As far as I know, the arrangement between investors, the Government and banks faces many difficulties. Banks always care about protecting, recovering capital, not allowing overdue debts. But in PPP investment, the calculation of capital recovery is much harder, so if the two parties are not in good faith, they must always submit to the Prime Minister; when in trouble, this is very troublesome. If we do not have a clear legal mechanism, it is very difficult to solve.

Secondly, in terms of benefit sharing of the project, the draft mentions two possibilities: more profit or loss than the contract option. In the National Assembly, there is a view that this is a market mechanism – profit and loss. This expression is not wrong. But, given the evidence in the field of transport, I think it is difficult to accurately predict the flow of vehicles traveling a certain distance at a given time, because it depends on many factors. In my opinion, there should be a provision in the PPP contract, in case of failure to comply with the estimate; it should be handled according to the principle of benefit sharing. As far as the benefit-sharing threshold is concerned, we need to calculate it appropriately, not just losing a few percent of risk-sharing. This needs to be public and transparent.

Thirdly, the issue that foreign investors are currently interested in is the bidding mechanism. We do not currently have foreign investors involved in the transport sector. One of the reasons is the story "lining up", the bidding council in the process of bid evaluation and decision making. We recommended that an organization be mobilized by leading experts with professional qualifications, experience in road work to consider PPP projects, and then set up an independent council to bid on the projects. If doing it, it will create a good bidding mechanism, ensure transparency, new foreign investors will join in.

In your opinion, what are foreign investors concerned about in the formulation, enactment and implementation of the PPP Law?

A concern of foreign investors is that the upcoming PPP Law, after being passed by the National Assembly, will assign the Government to issue a decree, then the Government will assign the ministry or sector to issue a circular. Currently, there is a situation that the National Assembly is making a general law, the Government's decree resolves a number of issues and has to wait for the circular promulgated before the Law will officially take effect. However, many cases of circulars are not appropriate or consistent with the decree because the legislators are not the Government or the National Assembly but the ministries.There are some things the ministries do not include in the law, they will be included in decree or circular. This is what investors fear the most. Therefore, I do not understand why since 2011 we have started to allow PPP investment pilots, but so far over10 years, we do not have a full review to institutionalize in a detailedway, publicity, transparency, clarity and confidence for domestic investors and especially foreign investors. If we can overcome this, it will attract more foreign investors to PPP projects.

The draft PPP Law is hardening five investment sectors. Many foreign-invested enterprises recommend that the field of investment should be open because new fields can arise. Whatdo you think about this issue?

Regarding the field of investment, I think it is advisable to consistently implement the state policy to do projects related to national defense and security.The remaining project which private enterprises can do, or foreign investors can do, let them do it; to focus its limited resources on what needs the role of the state. I was very surprised that the Minister of Industry and Trade recently proposed to involve the private sector in power transmission. There are two comments on this issue. Firstly, power transmission is national security, so the private sector is not done. Another idea is that power transmission is not national security. Currently, this issue has been decided that, in the first phase, the 500KV high-voltage power transmission axis, the state makes, can do in the form of BT, and transmit electricity from this 500KV line to households for use,and industrial zones for private use.

It is argued that future PPP projects, especially in the field of renewable energy, may need access to the sea. It is essential that the State guarantees access to the sea surface to attract international investors for projects. However, this is a relatively sensitive issue. What is your view on this issue?

Renewable energy projects, including wind power or solar power, need a large area of ​​land. In the world, the importance of renewable energy technologies on the water is important, the benefit of not wasting land, especially when using agricultural land to produce food for power projects. However, asthe sea surface is related to national security, I think that to solve this problem; we need to choose a partner. Not only energy projects, but we cannot overlook national security. Regarding the energy sector, as I mentioned, we are facing the situation, one side requires very fast energy development, so we develop coal power, one side thinks we need to grow fast on recycled energy. Currently, 6,000 MW of renewable energy has been put into use, while hundreds of thousands of MW are waiting to be put into use. Whether or not the recent price cut has caused foreign investors to invest in renewable energy is unclear, but it is clear that there have been no new projects in June 2019 in this area.

By Thu Hien/Bui Diep 

Related News

The Minister of Finance chaired the Vietnam - Korea Financial Investment Promotion Conference

The Minister of Finance chaired the Vietnam - Korea Financial Investment Promotion Conference

VCN - On March 7, in Seoul Capital, South Korea, the State Securities Commission (SSC) organized a financial investment promotion conference with the theme "Vietnam - Investment destination". Minister of Finance Ho Duc Phoc attended and chaired the Conference.
Positive economic outlook in 2024

Positive economic outlook in 2024

VCN - Dr. Le Duy Binh, CEO of Vietnam Economica gives an interview.
Many real estate businesses face difficulties of cash flow

Many real estate businesses face difficulties of cash flow

VCN - Although many policies to overcome difficulties have been put forward by the Government, ministries and branches but many real estate businesses face the situation of being "thirsty for money". Finding solutions to unlock capital sources for the real estate market to promote recovery and development is essential.
Export growth supports the economy and stock market

Export growth supports the economy and stock market

VCN - Vietnam's export growth is on the recovery path, thereby becoming a positive signal for the economy as well as the stock market in 2024.

Latest News

ASEAN, RoK agree on transposition of AKFTA product specific rules

ASEAN, RoK agree on transposition of AKFTA product specific rules

ASEAN member states and the Republic of Korea (RoK) have reached a consensus on the transposition of ASEAN-RoK Free Trade Agreement (AKFTA) Product Specific Rules from the Harmonised System Codes HS 2017 to HS 2022.
Opportunities for digital technology businesses to go global

Opportunities for digital technology businesses to go global

Finding solutions and directions to promote and develop Vietnamese digital technology enterprises is an important task, which will promote the stability and sustainability of the country's economy, heard a recent conference.
Vietnam, China eye stronger border trade

Vietnam, China eye stronger border trade

Border provinces of Vietnam and China should continue close coordination and enhance trade promotion between the two sides, stressed the recent talks between the management boards of the economic zone of the northern province of Ha Giang and the Malypo border economic cooperation zone of China’s Yunnan province.
Improve competitiveness and sustainable development of the seafood industry

Improve competitiveness and sustainable development of the seafood industry

VCN - In early 2024, seafood exports have prospered. This is the driving force that helps seafood businesses hope for a stronger recovery this year. Ms. Nguyen Thi Thu Sac, Chairwoman of the Vietnam Association of Seafood Exporters and Producers (VASEP) shared with Customs Magazine.

More News

Business environment reform needs further promotion: expert

Business environment reform needs further promotion: expert

Resolution 02 issued by the Government creates pressure for the ministries, sectors and localities to make changes for the business community as well as the socio-economic development.
Singapore is the largest foreign investor in VN in Q1

Singapore is the largest foreign investor in VN in Q1

The disbursed FDI rose by 7.1 per cent in the first quarter to reach $4.63 billion, a signal that the disbursement will continue the positive trend, the agency said.
Thai Binh boosts investment, trade cooperation with Germany

Thai Binh boosts investment, trade cooperation with Germany

A delegation from the northern province of Thai Binh, led by Deputy Secretary of the provincial Party Committee Nguyen Khac Than, visited several localities and business organisations in Germany from March 25 to 27, in a bid to enhance trade cooperation with and attract direct investment from the European nation.
Lifting obstacles to develop industrial parks

Lifting obstacles to develop industrial parks

VCN - Attracting investment and developing industrial zones (IZs) and economic zones (EZs) is one of the important contents to implement the policy of developing a multi-component, open, attract investment and resources from all economic sectors to develop the country. In addition to the results achieved, there still limitations that need to be removed to draw investments to develop industrial parks and economic zones, including financial problems for industrial parks.
Unlock capital flows and create favorable conditions for investors

Unlock capital flows and create favorable conditions for investors

VCN - Talking with the press, Dr. Ngo Cong Thanh (Photo), Provisional Executive Committee member of the Vietnam Industrial Park Finance Association (VIPFA), said that it is necessary to open up capital flows and create conditions for investors to access key factors. Facilitate production and business factors and innovate investment promotion activities to more effectively develop industrial parks.
More than 300 businesses, manufacturers to attend VGMF 2024

More than 300 businesses, manufacturers to attend VGMF 2024

More than 300 domestic and foreign businesses and manufacturers will attend the Vietnam Global Manufacturing Forum 2024 (VGMF2024) to explore investment and business cooperation opportunities.
Connecting with FDI firms helps boost wood exports: insiders

Connecting with FDI firms helps boost wood exports: insiders

Strengthening linkages and cooperation between foreign-invested and domestic enterprises will contribute to promoting the sustainable development of the Vietnamese wood industry, according to insiders.
Doosan Vina exports nearly 2,000 tonnes of modules to US

Doosan Vina exports nearly 2,000 tonnes of modules to US

The Doosan Enerbility Vietnam (Doosan Vina) specialising in heavy industries announced on March 26 that it has just exported a batch of nine modules weighing nearly 2,000 tonnes to the Golden Triangle Polymers company in Texas, the US.
Wood processing enterprises strive to increase the proportion of individually designed goods

Wood processing enterprises strive to increase the proportion of individually designed goods

VCN - Many wood and furniture processing enterprises are promoting investment in design activities, helping to increase the proportion of individually designed products (ODM) in exports, thereby affirming the industry's capacity Vietnamese wood in segments with higher added value.
Read More

Your care

Latest Most read
ASEAN, RoK agree on transposition of AKFTA product specific rules

ASEAN, RoK agree on transposition of AKFTA product specific rules

ASEAN member states and the Republic of Korea (RoK) have reached a consensus on the transposition of ASEAN-RoK Free Trade Agreement (AKFTA) Product Specific Rules from the Harmonised System Codes HS 2017 to HS 2022.
Opportunities for digital technology businesses to go global

Opportunities for digital technology businesses to go global

Finding solutions and directions to promote and develop Vietnamese digital technology enterprises is an important task, which will promote the stability and sustainability of the country's economy, heard a recent conference.
Vietnam, China eye stronger border trade

Vietnam, China eye stronger border trade

Border provinces of Vietnam and China should continue close coordination and enhance trade promotion between the two sides, stressed the recent talks between the management boards of the economic zone of the northern province of Ha Giang and the Malypo border economic cooperation zone of China’s Yunnan province.
Improve competitiveness and sustainable development of the seafood industry

Improve competitiveness and sustainable development of the seafood industry

In early 2024, seafood exports have prospered. This is the driving force that helps seafood businesses hope for a stronger recovery this year.
Business environment reform needs further promotion: expert

Business environment reform needs further promotion: expert

Resolution 02 issued by the Government creates pressure for the ministries, sectors and localities to make changes for the business community as well as the socio-economic development.
Mobile Version