Vietnam can be a leader in tax reform: Oxfam

Vietnam has the potential to become a leader in tax reform, said Johan Langerock, tax policy expert of Oxfam at the Vietnam Fiscal Policy and Development Forum 2019 themed “Towards a Fair Tax System’ which opened in Hanoi on November 13 with scientists, managers, policy-makers, and business representatives in attendance.
vietnam can be a leader in tax reform oxfam

Johan Langerock, tax policy expert of Oxfam

Upon addressing the forum themed “Towards a Fair Tax System", Langerock noted that the country’s economic growth reached a 10-year high of 7.1 per cent last year, with this strong economic momentum expected to continue for the remainder of the year.

The nation has been transformed from one of the world’s poorest countries that suffered from frequent food shortages, to a lower middle-income economy that is currently a leading exporter of rice, seafood, coffee, and other commodities.

The official poverty rate has fallen from 58 per cent in the early 1990s to less than 10 per cent today.

Despite this success, the country’s extraordinary economic track record has not been accompanied by a similar pathway in tax revenue. Most notably, compared to the size of the economy, tax revenues nationwide have been decreasing in recent years.

Langerock believes that in the long term this could pose a danger to the sustainability of the country.

He noted that decreasing tax revenues represent a concerning trend for several reasons. Mainly, it means that the tax system is failing to collect and redistribute created income and wealth in the country.

Several reports already indicate that the benefits of the nation’s economic growth are increasingly going to the wealthiest 10 per cent of the population.

According to the Oxfam representative, one of the biggest factors causing a decrease in tax revenue is the focus on lowering corporate income tax rates, along with the existence of many tax incentives that are in place for foreign investors.

This means that while revenues decrease, tax expenditures have remained high. As a result, export-led industrialization has seen significant development, at the expense of growth among agricultural and small businesses.

It is therefore inevitable that tax expenditure policies have contributed to the country’s economic growth, boosting investment in the process.

However, it must be contemplated that now is the time for the nation to rationalise tax expenditures that are placed on large companies.

Up until now, Vietnamese authorities have not been paying enough attention to performing efficient or effective analysis of tax expenditure policies. The social cost of tax expenditures remains too large to be ignored.

According to the OECD, the revenue loss stands at an estimated 1 per cent of GDP, representing a staggering amount of over VND50 trillion.

This amount could potentially finance 25 new 1000-bed hospitals nationwide. When tax revenue collection on large companies falls, either pressure to levy higher VAT rates on ordinary citizens increases, or fewer public services are delivered.

Langerock expressed his belief that the nation could get rid of its largest tax incentives without growth or competitiveness suffering.

According to a recent survey conducted by Grant Thornton on private equity prospect nationwide, 69 per cent of replies consider the increase in disposal income and middle-income classes as the most important factor for investing in the country.

Furthermore, 60 per cent consider high and stable economic growth, whilst only 13 per cent consider government incentives and subsidies as the most important factor.

The Oxfam representative said ASEAN countries are pushing one another into an aggressive race to the bottom in terms of corporate taxes.

Regional firms have seen their tax rates lower over the last decade. In such an environment, only large companies and wealthy shareholders win at the expense of essential public services for ordinary citizens.

He also recommended the Vietnamese authorities can proceed in two ways, noting that some tax incentives should be eliminated following an impact assessment.

In addition, as the chairman of ASEAN in 2020, Vietnam should make it a priority to raise awareness, in addition to debating the issue of tax competition and tax incentives at a regional level. Both steps should lead to an increase in tax revenue in both a fair and equitable way, according to the Oxfam tax advisor.

He pointed out that this will lead to inequalities decreasing whilst the Government will have more resources to invest in health, education, and the fight against climate change.

vietnam can be a leader in tax reform oxfam

VEPR President Nguyen Duc Thanh

At the forum, representatives from the General Department of Taxation and Vietnam Institute for Economic and Policy Research (VEPR) also delivered in-depth reports on tax expenditure in Vietnam.

They also gave some recommendations for the Government in order to use tax incentives effectively within the context of a budget deficit and high public debts.

Source: VOV

Related News

Vietnam and Japan promote cooperation

Vietnam and Japan promote cooperation

VCN - On August 28, Deputy Prime Minister and Minister of Finance Ho Duc Phoc had a working session with the Japanese Senate delegation led by Mr. Nakanishi Yusuke, Senator of the Liberal Democratic Party.
Close cooperation between Vietnam and the EU in sustainable development

Close cooperation between Vietnam and the EU in sustainable development

VCN - EuroCham will closely collaborate and share experiences with various sectors in Vietnam to promote green economic development and sustainable growth.
Green energy goals still face many challenges

Green energy goals still face many challenges

VCN - Green development, energy transition, and emission reduction are inevitable trends that Vietnam cannot stand aside. This is also an opportunity to develop and restructure the economy towards green, clean, and sustainable. However, green energy transition in Vietnam still faces many challenges. Dr. Vo Tri Thanh, Director of the Institute for Brand Strategy and Competitiveness, shared about this issue.
EU proposes to change maximum residue levels in many agricultural products of Vietnam

EU proposes to change maximum residue levels in many agricultural products of Vietnam

VCN - The Vietnam Sanitary and Phytosaniary Notification Authority and Enquiry Point (Vietnam SPS Office for short) has just received a notice from the Secretariat of the World Trade Organization (WTO) SPS Committee on the European Union (EU) seeking opinions from WTO members on draft SPS measure notifications.

Latest News

Strictly handle price gouging and stabilize consumer sentiment after storms and floods

Strictly handle price gouging and stabilize consumer sentiment after storms and floods

VCN - Storm No. 3 (Typhoon Yagi) has caused serious consequences, leading to food shortages and localized price gouging. Pham Van Binh, Deputy Director of the Department of Price Management, Ministry of Finance, said that it is necessary to strictly handle acts of profiteering and violations of price laws.
General Department of Taxation implements tax exemption, extension of taxes and fees for people and businesses affected by storm No. 3

General Department of Taxation implements tax exemption, extension of taxes and fees for people and businesses affected by storm No. 3

VCN – The General Department of Taxation issued official Dispatch to 26 local Tax departments to instruct tax exemption, extension of taxes and fees for people and businesses after storms and floods.
Insurance brings peace of mind to customers during Yagi typhoon

Insurance brings peace of mind to customers during Yagi typhoon

VCN - The Insurance Supervision Authority (Ministry of Finance) initially estimated that the total amount of insurance paid for human and property damage was about VND7,000 billion. However, with the severe damage caused by storm No. 3 (Yagi Typhoon) and the post-storm circulation, this number will certainly increase.
Banks lend significant amounts to green projects

Banks lend significant amounts to green projects

Many banks have recently poured thousands of billions of Vietnamese dong into green projects.

More News

Curbing stock market manipulation

Curbing stock market manipulation

VCN - Amending and supplementing a number of articles of the Law on Securities is necessary to ensure that the securities market operates more transparently and effectively, to ensure the rights of investors, to prevent fraudulent behavior, and to create conditions for the development of the securities market.
Control of major shareholders in banks

Control of major shareholders in banks

VCN - In compliance with the provisions of the Law on Credit Institutions 2024, banks have made public the list of information on shareholders owning 1% or more of shares. This is expected to block the “octopus tentacles” of cross-ownership.
Banks reduce interest rates, offer new loans for storm-affected customers

Banks reduce interest rates, offer new loans for storm-affected customers

Several private and State-owned banks have reduced interest rates and offered debt relief for customers affected by Typhoon Yagi.
Allocating credit room, motivation for banks to compete

Allocating credit room, motivation for banks to compete

VCN - The State Bank of Vietnam (SBV) has announced that it will allocate the credit growth limit (room) for banks that have achieved 80% of their target. This is an incentive for banks to increase their competitiveness.
New securities accounts in August reach record high in over two years

New securities accounts in August reach record high in over two years

August saw the highest number of new securities accounts opened in more than two years, dating back to May 2022.
Fiscal policy needs to return to normal

Fiscal policy needs to return to normal

VCN - Talking to Customs Magazine about the role and orientation of fiscal policy in the new period, Dr. Le Duy Binh, CEO of Economica Vietnam, affirmed that returning to normal fiscal policy is a message that is consistent with current reality.
Credit growth target is within reach to contribute to boosting economic growth: SBV

Credit growth target is within reach to contribute to boosting economic growth: SBV

Another important factor is to increase the capital absorption capacity of enterprises which will require a combination of macro policies to create favourable conditions for businesses, SBV’s Deputy Governor Đào Minh Tú said.
Strictly handle violations of invoices in a timely manner to avoid budget losses

Strictly handle violations of invoices in a timely manner to avoid budget losses

VCN - The General Department of Taxation has just issued a document directing local tax authorities nationwide to conduct close and timely review and supervision of businesses showing signs of risks in the illegal trade and use of invoices.
SBV gives the green light to increase credit

SBV gives the green light to increase credit

Commercial banks and other credit institutes whose credit growth reached 80% of the targets set by the central bank at the beginning of the year, will have their credit limit increased, stated the State Bank of Vietnam (SBV).
Read More

Your care

Latest Most read
Strictly handle price gouging and stabilize consumer sentiment after storms and floods

Strictly handle price gouging and stabilize consumer sentiment after storms and floods

VCN - According to market surveys by the Department of Price Management), the prices of rice and meat are relatively stable compared to the time before the storm.
General Department of Taxation implements tax exemption, extension of taxes and fees for people and businesses affected by storm No. 3

General Department of Taxation implements tax exemption, extension of taxes and fees for people and businesses affected by storm No. 3

VCN - According to instruction, enterprises will be exempted and extended many taxes: Personal Income Tax, Corporate Income Tax, Special Consumption Tax, VAT deduction, Resource Tax, and non-agricultural land use tax.
Insurance brings peace of mind to customers during Yagi typhoon

Insurance brings peace of mind to customers during Yagi typhoon

The Insurance Supervision Authority (Ministry of Finance) initially estimated that the total amount of insurance paid for human and property damage was about VND7,000 billion.
Banks lend significant amounts to green projects

Banks lend significant amounts to green projects

Many banks have recently poured thousands of billions of Vietnamese dong into green projects.
Curbing stock market manipulation

Curbing stock market manipulation

Amending and supplementing a number of articles of the Law on Securities is necessary to ensure that the securities market operates more transparently and effectively
Mobile Version