Need to abolish preferential treatment on tax and land to avoid pushing the race to bottom

VCN – ASEAN countries needed to stop the race of preferential treatment on tax policy as well as land to attract FDI investment, and focus on building healthy business environment. This information was presented in the dissemination workshop “Towards sustainable ASEAN development: Improve business environment is the key to FDI not tax competition” in Hanoi.
5401-3210-124764370-2774419736109912-4241249947742465866-o
Prof. Nguyen Duc Thanh made a speech at the conference.

Competition on preferential tariff

According to a report of the Vietnam Institute for Economic and Policy Research (VERP), the ASEAN region was facing major challenges during the Covid-19 pandemic. Besides the economic and health crisis, FDI that flowed to developing countries in Asia was forcasted to fall to 30-40% and tax revenues faced great trouble.

Therefore, ASEAN countries are competing in a race to reduce corporate income tax rates and offering huge tax incentives for multinational corporations without any real benefits.

According to VERP, instead of focusing on the key factor in deciding the FDI sector as buildling a business environment that has proven to be key element, governments in the region are adopting tax policies that are only beneficial for large foreign companies.

The VERP report showed the average corporate income tax rate of ASEAN has fallen from 25.1% in 2010 to 21.7% in 2020. Besides cutting corporate income tax rates, the application of other major incentives based on profits to attract FDI such as grace of tax was also very popular in ASEAN countries. The cost of excess tax incentives is likely to exceed benefits brought by FDI. The cutting corporate income tax excessively poses a threat to national revenues in the form of tax expenditure.

“Tax incentives could cause negative impact on economic efficiency. It was difficult for ASEAN countries to cope with those consequences, especially in the context of the economic and health crisis that all countries are facing. We need to choose between building sustainable societies with good land policies, or just benefiting companies that were working to minimise their tax bills. Whose interests would come first?” Ah Maftuchan, Director of PRAKARSA said.

Besides tax incentives, the use of non-tariff incentives was also widespread in ASEAN countries and exacerbated the race to the bottom in the region. Competition in the provision of non-tax incentives was illustrated clearly in preferential tariffs of land. Long-term land lease options were available in all ASEAN countries. For example, Thailand even allowed foreign investors to own land in some special cases. Or like Vietnam and Laos exempting or cutting land rent for investment projects in remote areas or promoting production.

Race is pushed down to bottom

Prof. Nguyen Duc Thanh, founder and chief advisor of Vietnam Institute for Economic and Policy Research, said while the competition of the business environment was a race to lead, the competition for the preferential treatment of tax and land was a race to the bottom. The provision of preferential treatment for land, especially extended land lease terms, lack of transparency could increase the risk of corruption.

“These unnecessary tax and non-tax incentives affect a nation's ability to mobilise domestic revenue, from that it would affect spending for essential public services in order to fight poverty and reduce inequality. It was absurd that those policies were not necessarily effective in attracting FDI inflows as policymakers often thought,” Prof. Thanh said.

According to VERP, many studies showed indicators of the new business environment were decisive factors in the selection of FDI investment locations, namely economic stability, political stability and domestic market, transparent legal framework, quality of labor, quality of infrastructure, quality of roads.

Therefore, VERP recommended ASEAN countries should take unified actions such as making a white and blacklist of tax incentives; prevent competition for making land incentives; agreeing on a minimum tax rate for the entire region; developing rules for well management of investment incentives; and unify the list of business environment factors for attracting FDI.

“ASEAN countries need to act together in the fight against poverty for the lives of millions of people in the region. It is the time to acknowledge that preferential tariff and non-preferential tariff are exacerbating economic and social inequality and not the key to sustainable foreign investment. Therefore, all ASEAN member countries need to unite and prioritise improving the business environment instead of offering ineffective incentives,” Mustafa Talpur, Regional Manager of narrowing the gap campaign, Oxfam in Asia, stressed.

By Thùy Linh/Thanh Thuy

Related News

Creating a healthy and competitive environment for petroleum business

Creating a healthy and competitive environment for petroleum business

VCN - Talking to Customs News, Prof. Dr. Nguyen Thuong Lang, Institute of International Trade and Economics, National Economics University, said that it should have solutions to increase competitiveness in the petroleum business, but it was not possible to let the market self-regulate without the help of regulatory agencies.

Latest News

Continue to handle cross-ownership in banks

Continue to handle cross-ownership in banks

VCN - The situation of excess share ownership, cross-ownership between credit institutions (CIs), CIs and enterprises, although has decreased significantly compared to previous periods, is still complicated and requires continued inspection and control.
Striving for average CPI not to exceed 4%

Striving for average CPI not to exceed 4%

VCN - According to the report of the Ministry of Finance, there are still some factors that put pressure on price levels in the remaining months of 2024, so the Ministry has updated 2 scenarios of average inflation in 2024 increasing in the range of 3.7-3.92%.
Delegating the power to the government to waive, lower, or manage late tax penalties is suitable

Delegating the power to the government to waive, lower, or manage late tax penalties is suitable

VCN - Discussing in groups about the project "1 law amending 7 laws" in the financial sector according to the program of the 8th Session on October 29, 2024, National Assembly delegates proposed that the Government should be assigned to make specific regulations on decentralization, granting the right to exempt and reduce taxes, and handling penalties for late payment of taxes...
Removing difficulties in public investment disbursement

Removing difficulties in public investment disbursement

VCN - According to the report of the Investment Department (Ministry of Finance), the estimated disbursement from the beginning of the year to October 31, 2024 is VND 355,616.1 billion, reaching 47.43% of the 2024 plan, reaching 52.29% of the plan assigned by the Prime Minister.

More News

State-owned commercial banking sector performs optimistic growth, but more capital in need

State-owned commercial banking sector performs optimistic growth, but more capital in need

VCN - According to the report sent to the National Assembly before the 8th Session of the Government on investment, management and use of state capital in enterprises nationwide in 2023, the business performance of the state-owned commercial banking sector achieved positive growth.
Stipulate implementation of centralized bilateral payments of the State Treasury at banks

Stipulate implementation of centralized bilateral payments of the State Treasury at banks

VCN - The Ministry of Finance (MOF) gathers feedback on the draft Circular regulating the management and use of accounts of the State Treasury opened at the State Bank of Vietnam (SBV) and commercial banks.
Rush to finalize draft decree on public asset restructuring

Rush to finalize draft decree on public asset restructuring

VCN - According to the Ministry of Finance, the draft Decree regulating the rearrangement and handling of public assets is being urgently completed by the Ministry of Finance to submit to the Government for promulgation.
Inspection report on gold trading activities being complied: SBV

Inspection report on gold trading activities being complied: SBV

The State Bank of Vietnam (SBV) has announced that inspections on compliance with legal policies in gold trading activities of credit institutions and gold trading businesses have been completed and an inspection report is being compiled.
Budget revenue in 2024 is estimated to exceed the estimate by 10.1%

Budget revenue in 2024 is estimated to exceed the estimate by 10.1%

VCN -The Government estimates that state budget revenue in 2024 will exceed VND 172.3 trillion, up 10.1% over the estimate, of which tax and fee revenue will reach 13.1% of GDP.
Ensure timely and effective management and use of public asset

Ensure timely and effective management and use of public asset

VCN – In order to promptly and effectively implement public asset management and use, ensuring compliance with legal regulations, the Ministry of Finance has just issued an official dispatch requesting ministries, branches and localities to comply with regulations in the Government’s Decree No. 114/2024/ND-CP dated September 15, 2024.
Accelerating decentralization in public asset management

Accelerating decentralization in public asset management

VCN - Amending the Law on Management and Use of Public Assets aims to improve regulations on accelerating decentralization and improving efficiency in management and use of public assets, and promoting financial resources, ensuring that the unified application the Law on Management and Use of Public Assets and other legal documents.
Difficulty in finding banks eligible to receive compulsory transfers

Difficulty in finding banks eligible to receive compulsory transfers

VCN - Reporting to the National Assembly, the State Bank of Vietnam (SBV) said that one of the difficulties in restructuring the credit institution system is the long process of finding and negotiating banks eligible to receive compulsory transfers.
Businesses can choose a suitable electronic invoice model generated from the cash register

Businesses can choose a suitable electronic invoice model generated from the cash register

VCN - The Ministry of Finance said that individual business households can choose a suitable model to apply electronic invoice solutions from cash registers, depending on the number of invoices used in the year, in the month and the current status of software solutions and technical infrastructure.
Read More

Your care

Latest Most read
Continue to handle cross-ownership in banks

Continue to handle cross-ownership in banks

VCN - The situation of excess share ownership, cross-ownership between credit institutions (CIs), CIs and enterprises, although has decreased significantly compared to previous periods, is still complicated and requires continued inspection and control.
Striving for average CPI not to exceed 4%

Striving for average CPI not to exceed 4%

VCN - According to the report of the Ministry of Finance, there are still some factors that put pressure on price levels in the remaining months of 2024, so the Ministry has updated 2 scenarios of average inflation in 2024 increasing in the range of 3.7-3
Delegating the power to the government to waive, lower, or manage late tax penalties is suitable

Delegating the power to the government to waive, lower, or manage late tax penalties is suitable

National Assembly delegates proposed that the Government should be assigned to make specific regulations on decentralization, granting the right to exempt and reduce taxes, and handling penalties for late payment of taxes...
Removing difficulties in public investment disbursement

Removing difficulties in public investment disbursement

VCN - According to the report of the Investment Department (Ministry of Finance), the estimated disbursement from the beginning of the year to October 31, 2024 is VND 355,616.1 billion, reaching 47.43% of the 2024 plan, reaching 52.29% of the plan assigne
State-owned commercial banking sector performs optimistic growth, but more capital in need

State-owned commercial banking sector performs optimistic growth, but more capital in need

According to the report of the Government on investment, management and use of state capital in enterprises nationwide in 2023, the business performance of the state-owned commercial banking sector achieved positive growth.
Mobile Version