Formosa blamed for fish death

Chairman of the Government Office Mai Tiến Dũng yesterday announced that the Taiwanese Hưng Nghiệp Formosa Hà Tĩnh Steel Corporation was responsible for the massive fish deaths in several central Vietnamese provinces in the past few months.
formosa blamed for fish death Fish deaths did not impact exports: VASEP
formosa blamed for fish death VFTU slams China’s fishing ban
formosa blamed for fish death
Formosa Hà Tĩnh leaders apologise for the incident on Wednesday.

He told a news conference yesterday in Hà Nội that Formosa had released toxic wastewater into the sea along these provinces.

“Based on the result of careful inspections and consultancy with international scientists, we came to the conclusion that violations in the construction and testing operation of the Formosa Hà Tĩnh Steel plant are the cause for serious pollution killing a massive amount of fish in these central provinces,” he said.

He also said that Formosa had admitted responsibility for the fish deaths and committed to publicly apologising for such violations.

Dũng said Formosa Hà Tĩnh would also have to pay US$500 million to compensate affected people, help fishermen find new jobs as well as to pay for clean-up works and to recover the sea environment.

The company’s chairman, Chen Yuan Cheng, apologised in a film clip shown at the news conference and said he accepted full responsibility.

“We take responsibility for the incident and deeply apologise to the people of Việt Nam, particularly the residents of Hà Tĩnh, Quảng Bình, Quảng Trị and Thừa Thiên – Huế provinces. We would also like to apologise to the Party, the Government, the National Assembly and the Prime Minister of Việt Nam for causing such an environment incident which has seriously affected the livelihood of these residents,” Chen said.

Chen also said that Formosa had committed to improve its wastewater treatment system and ensure proper treatment of toxic waste before discharging to the environment in line with Việt Nam’s requirements.

“We will co-operate with Vietnamese authorities and the central provinces to develop a solution to monitor the central region’s sea environment and to make sure that there will be no environmental incidents similar to what happened,” he said.

“We commit to not repeat violations regarding environmental protection and water resources in Việt Nam.”

“We deeply hope the Vietnamese people can forgive us".

In a letter sent to his staff, which was written in Vietnamese and published just hours before the press conference, Chen said that the investigation led by Việt Nam’s environment ministry found that subcontractors’ faults during the trial phase of operation had killed the fish.

“We respect the Government’s investigation results and are co-operating with the authorities to handle and mitigate the consequences,” he said in the letter.

Why $500 million?

Minister of Natural Resources and Environment Trần Hồng Hà said the amount of $500 million was calculated based only on economic damages.

“Much more damage has been done to the sea environment, while emotional damage to local residents and other consequences can’t be put on the scale,” he said.

“But what we want is not money, we want Formosa and their stakeholders to understand that they have to be responsible for what they cause in Việt Nam,” he added.

The Vietnamese Government, however, did not provide figures on the exact number of fish dead and economic losses of the four provinces affected in the disaster.

The Ministry of Science and Technology led the investigation work in collaboration with the Việt Nam Academy of Science and Technology, joined by more than 100 Vietnamese and international scientists, analysts and experts over the last three months. They managed to identify a big source of wastewater in Vũng Áng.

“The wastewater moved along the sea current, taking the oxygen out of the water and causing toxicity wherever it went,” Hà said.

“The conclusion was reached via images taken from the seabed and satellites”.

Lawsuit against Formosa?

Dũng said in the press conference that the Vietnamese Government still had to consider whether to bring Formosa to court.

“Việt Nam is determined to investigate and find the real culprit, Formosa, in this case,” he said.

Dũng, however, added that Formosa “has apologised to the Vietnamese people and committed to compensate” for its actions, and Việt Nam has a tolerance-oriented policy towards law-breaking foreign companies which readily admit their violations.  

Media access

Confronted by the media on whether or not the Government had intentionally blocked information access to the mass fish death after the incident happened, Information and Communication Minister Trương Minh Tuấn said that media investigation could not replace a comprehensive one by scientists and law enforcement forces in such a complicated case.

Since the incident took place, only three press conferences – including today’s to announce the final cause – were held by the Government in response to the fish death. The media had little access to what had happened and what the Government was doing to handle the environmental crisis.

“There were times the Government asked the media to stop reporting unproven news lest it hindered the investigation work,” Tuấn said.

Ha added that if the Government provided all the information they had, there would be no “weapons” left to battle the culprit.    

The mass fish death first started on April 6 in Kỳ Anh Town in Hà Tĩnh Province - the place where Formosa Hà Tĩnh is located. Within the next nine days, fishermen and local residents along the central coast found themselves panicking when tonnes of dead fish continuously washed up ashore southwards, from Quảng Bình to Quảng Trị and later down to Thừa Thiên-Huế, just dozens of kilometres away from the famous tourism city of Đà Nẵng.

Initial statistics from the four provinces reported some 277 tonnes of dead fish – both washed up on the beaches and farmed fish from the sea, causing estimated economic losses totaling more than VNĐ260 billion ($11.5 million). Further, at least 123,000 fishermen and locals who rely on the sea for a living or who work in the tourism industry were severely affected by the incident. This has not taken into account the damages to the local environment.

Soon after the fish death happened, suspicions for what caused such an environmental catastrophe instantly fell on Formosa - a subsidiary of the conglomerate Taiwanese Formosa Plastics Group – when fisherman Nguyễn Xuân Thành in Hà Tĩnh’s Kỳ Anh Town informed of a colossal wastepipe running under the sea that directly discharged “yellowish and foul-smelling water”. One end of the pipe was out to the open sea, and another end was connected to the Formosa factories.

Formosa then acknowledged having imported 296 tonnes of some 40 different types of chemicals in the first quarter this year, many of which experts said to be “poisonous and very poisonous” to human and animal beings. 

formosa blamed for fish death Vietnamese steel unit of Taiwan’s Formosa under scrutiny

The steel unit of Taiwan's Formosa Plastics Group in the north-central Vietnamese province of Ha Tinh has ...

Formosa Hà Tĩnh, the biggest project in Việt Nam, comprises the Sơn Dương deep-water port and an industrial complex producing cast steel. Formosa kicked off the project in 2008 with a total investment of nearly $10 billion and is considering to up the ante to $27 billion. 

Source: Vietnam News

Related News

Solutions to establish a green ecosystem in the logistics industry

Solutions to establish a green ecosystem in the logistics industry

VCN - In the current context, if the criteria to "green" the logistics industry are not quickly implemented, in the future, businesses will face many difficulties and gradually be "eliminated" from business, domestic trade and global import and export. Mr. Dao Trong Khoa (Photo), Standing Vice President of Vietnam Logistics Services Association, talked about some issues surrounding green logistics transformation.
Greening creates competitive and sustainable advantages for enterprises

Greening creates competitive and sustainable advantages for enterprises

VCN - The gradual greening of production, green factories, green technology, clean materials, green energy, etc., has become an inevitable trend and creates competitive and sustainable advantages for enterprises in the face of difficulties and challenges.
Drastically suppress smuggling activities at sea

Drastically suppress smuggling activities at sea

VCN - Since the beginning of 2024, the Command of Coast Guard has implemented measures and promptly established a specialized project to fight against criminals, and criminal lines at sea.
Drugs drifting at sea mainly cocaine

Drugs drifting at sea mainly cocaine

VCN - The competent authorities have continuously discovered and seized many drug packages drifting at sea in the Central region, said Major General Nguyen Ngoc Quang, Deputy Director of the the Drug Crime Investigation Police Department (C04) under the Ministry of Public Security on an interview with the press.

Latest News

State President welcomes top legislator of Cuba

State President welcomes top legislator of Cuba

State President Luong Cuong met with Politburo member, President of the National Assembly of People’s Power, and President of the Council of State of Cuba Esteban Lazo Hernandez in Hanoi on November 2.
Remove "bottlenecks" for economic breakthrough

Remove "bottlenecks" for economic breakthrough

VCN - In recent articles and speeches, General Secretary and President To Lam has repeatedly mentioned that the country is facing a new era of national growth. General Secretary and President To Lam also requested that the “bottlenecks” of the economy must be quickly removed, creating innovation and breakthroughs to complete the set tasks.
Int’l organisations, experts remain optimistic about Vietnam's economic outlook

Int’l organisations, experts remain optimistic about Vietnam's economic outlook

International organisations and experts have made positive comments on the Vietnamese economy, affirming their optimism about Vietnam's economic outlook.
Party chief clarifies major issues on new era of nation

Party chief clarifies major issues on new era of nation

Prof. Dr. To Lam, General Secretary of the Communist Party of Vietnam (CPV)’s Central Committee on October 31 had a discussion with participants of a training course for officials planned for the 14th Party Central Committee, focusing on a number of issues on a new era – the era of the nation’s rise.

More News

Vietnam, others call on US to immediately end embargo against Cuba

Vietnam, others call on US to immediately end embargo against Cuba

Vietnam calls on the US to immediately end its embargo against and remove Cuba from the list of state sponsors of terrorism, moving towards normalising relations between the two countries based on equality, mutual respect, and respect for each other's national sovereignty and political independence, stated Ambassador Dang Hoang Giang, Permanent Representative of Vietnam to the UN.
Vietnam

Vietnam's economy is recovering well

VCN - According to Dr. Nguyen Quoc Viet, Deputy Director of the Vietnam Institute for Economic and Policy Research (VEPR), by the end of the third quarter of this year, Vietnam's economy had recovered relatively well amid optimism about the overall growth of the world economy in late 2024 and 2025.
“Carbon footprint” reduction needed for sustainable tourism development: insiders

“Carbon footprint” reduction needed for sustainable tourism development: insiders

Vietnam's tourism industry is making efforts to reduce its “carbon footprint” in pursuit of sustainability, focusing on developing “green tours”, upgrading transport infrastructure, and developing renewable energy-used vehicles, said insiders.
Concerted efforts underway to prevent IUU fishing

Concerted efforts underway to prevent IUU fishing

Vietnam is making thorough preparations to welcome the European Commission (EC)'s inspection delegation with the hope of having its “yellow card” on illegal, unreported and unregulated (IUU) fishing against the fisheries sector removed, thus boosting seafood exports to the EU market.
Vietnam needs to diversify supply chains for sustainable growth: economists

Vietnam needs to diversify supply chains for sustainable growth: economists

The diversification of global supply chains is creating significant opportunities for Vietnam to engage more deeply in international production networks. However, along with market expansion prospects, there are challenges posed by trade tensions, the reality of climate change accompanied by natural disasters, and the requirements for carbon emissions reduction, according to experts.
PM arrives in Abu Dhabi, beginning official visit to UAE

PM arrives in Abu Dhabi, beginning official visit to UAE

Prime Minister Pham Minh Chinh, his spouse and a high-ranking delegation of Vietnam arrived at Zayed International Airport in Abu Dhabi at 11 am on October 27 (local time), starting their official visit to the United Arab Emirates (UAE) at the invitation of President Mohamed bin Zayed Al Nahyan.
Big rebound forecast for southern industrial property market in 2025

Big rebound forecast for southern industrial property market in 2025

Despite a challenging 2024 marked by global economic uncertainties and regulatory changes, the industrial property market in the south is poised for a robust recovery in 2025, according to property consultancy Knight Frank.
Vietnams tourism likely to boom under "Six Countries, One Destination" visa initiative

Vietnams tourism likely to boom under "Six Countries, One Destination" visa initiative

A shared visa zone for the Southeast Asia region, similar to Europe’s Schengen visa mechanism, could be a game-changer Vietnam’s tourism sector needs. The proposed “Six Countries, One Destination” initiative aims to facilitate seamless travel across six neighboring countries, thus boosting regional tourism.
Vietnamese Prime Minister to visit UAE, Qatar, Saudi Arabia

Vietnamese Prime Minister to visit UAE, Qatar, Saudi Arabia

Prime Minister Pham Minh Chinh, his spouse, and a high-ranking delegation of Vietnam will pay official visits to the United Arab Emirates (UAE) and Qatar, attend the 8th Edition of the Future Investment Initiative (FII) and make a working trip to Saudi Arabia, from October 27 to November 2.
Read More

Your care

Latest Most read
State President welcomes top legislator of Cuba

State President welcomes top legislator of Cuba

State President Luong Cuong met with Politburo member, President of the National Assembly of People’s Power, and President of the Council of State of Cuba Esteban Lazo Hernandez in Hanoi on November 2.
Remove "bottlenecks" for economic breakthrough

Remove "bottlenecks" for economic breakthrough

General Secretary and President To Lam requested that the “bottlenecks” of the economy must be quickly removed, creating innovation and breakthroughs to complete the set tasks.
Int’l organisations, experts remain optimistic about Vietnam's economic outlook

Int’l organisations, experts remain optimistic about Vietnam's economic outlook

International organisations and experts have made positive comments on the Vietnamese economy, affirming their optimism about Vietnam's economic outlook.
Party chief clarifies major issues on new era of nation

Party chief clarifies major issues on new era of nation

Prof. Dr. To Lam, General Secretary of the Communist Party of Vietnam (CPV)’s Central Committee on October 31 had a discussion with participants of a training course for officials planned for the 14th Party Central Committee, focusing on a number of issues on a new era – the era of the nation’s rise.
Vietnam, others call on US to immediately end embargo against Cuba

Vietnam, others call on US to immediately end embargo against Cuba

Vietnam calls on the US to immediately end its embargo against and remove Cuba from the list of state sponsors of terrorism, moving towards normalising relations between the two countries based on equality, mutual respect, and respect for each other's national sovereignty and political independence, stated Ambassador Dang Hoang Giang, Permanent Representative of Vietnam to the UN.
Mobile Version