Arbitrator Trương Thanh Đức: Law on SMEs not wholly feasible

VCN- Trương Thanh Đức, an arbitrator from the Vietnam International Arbitration Centre (VIAC), shares with Customs Newspaper his views on the draft Law on Supporting Small and Medium Enterprises.
law on smes not wholly feasible expert
Trương Thanh Đức, an arbitrator from the Vietnam International Arbitration Centre (VIAC)

How do you evaluate the meaning of the Law on Supporting Small and Medium Enterprises?

Businesses, especially small and medium enterprises (SMEs), play an important role in the national economy. This is a firm foundation for creating jobs and ensuring stability for macroeconomic development.

Big and foreign enterprises that want to effectively operate have to lean on small and medium enterprises. Thus, the law on Supporting Small and Medium Enterprises is already behind compared to the international integration process. However, better late than never.

The urgent task now is to set up a clear legal corridor to better support the SMEs.

Do you think the law meets the requirements of supporting enterprises?

First of all, the law should redefine small and medium enterprises. In the draft, the definition did not clearly distinguish between small businesses, even micro enterprises, and medium ones.

For example, under the draft law definition, a medium enterprise is a business having an annual turnover of less than VNĐ3 billion (US$136,000) and 300 employees. But given the scale of Việt Nam’s economy, such a business is considered a big enterprises. So, putting that kind of businesses in the same group with small and micro enterprises is not fair.  

law on smes not wholly feasible expert Time for private businesses to have “greater voices”

Now that Việt Nam emphasises the importance of the private business sector, there is a chance for ...

he criterion should be based on capital and employment scales. Besides, enterprises should be classified into three groups of micro, small and medium. And production fields should be grouped in three sectors of agriculture, forestry and fishery; industry and construction; and trade and services.

The small and micro businesses should be given special preferential treatment.

Do you think the assistance proscribed by the law is sufficient?

The important question is how and what to support.

In my opinion, the draft law should detail the assistance measures, including support in finance, land for production workshops, advanced technology application, and market expansion.

One of the most important factors for business survival and development is capital. However, in the draft law, the article on preferential loans is not feasible.

The regulation only makes sense if soft loans are under State policies or the State budget. Asking the banks to give cut-rate interest loans put them on the spot. Banks must base loans or credits on borrowers’ risk evaluation, capital reimbursement ability, mortgage assets and business projects.

It can not give preferential treatment to enterprises that would negatively affect its “health”.    

Therefore, the law should clarify the assistance from by the State budget or other sources and instruct enterprises how to access it.

Another important point which is not mentioned in the draft is legal assistance. At present, most small enterprises can not afford to hire legal experts.  

In my opinion, there are many unfeasible and useless articles.

Notably, the law should not contradict Việt Nam’s commitments to free trade agreements in order to avoid anti-subsidy lawsuits.

By Thuy Linh/Hoang Linh

Related News

Why more than 100 Vietnamese means of transport detained in China?

Why more than 100 Vietnamese means of transport detained in China?

VCN - From the beginning of 2023, in Lao Cai area, there have been more than 100 Vietnamese means of transport detained in China.
Without resolving three significant bottlenecks, real estate market

Without resolving three significant bottlenecks, real estate market's revival will face numerous challenges

VCN - Economic expert Vu Dinh Anh shares insights on the real estate market's recovery trajectory in 2024.
Developing e-commerce goes hand in hand with increasing responsibility for compliance with the law

Developing e-commerce goes hand in hand with increasing responsibility for compliance with the law

VCN - The Prime Minister issued Decision No. 319/2023/QD-TTg approving the Project on anti-counterfeiting and consumer protection in e-commerce until 2025. The project demonstrates special interest and The Government's determination to ensure e-commerce activities are transparent, and healthy, and effectively protect the legitimate rights and interests of businesses and consumers.
There is still motivation and room for enterprises to continue to recover

There is still motivation and room for enterprises to continue to recover

VCN - Complicated fluctuations in the world's geopolitics and significant markets have strongly impacted indicators of Vietnamese enterprises' production and business activities. Talking to Vietnam Customs New, Mr. Hoang Quang Phong, Vice Chairman of the Vietnam Confederation of Commerce and Industry (VCCI), emphasized that enterprises should proactively identify opportunities and challenges to find solutions to achieve business results in 2023.

Latest News

Imports and exports achieve US$239 billion by the end of April

Imports and exports achieve US$239 billion by the end of April

VCN - The import-export turnover in April witnessed a slight decrease compared to the previous month but it is still high with more than US$60 billion.
Spending more than US$31 billion for importing computers and electronic products in 4 months

Spending more than US$31 billion for importing computers and electronic products in 4 months

VCN - Computers, electronic products, and components are the group of imported commodities with the largest scale in the country.
Multi-dimensional picture of textile and garment enterprises

Multi-dimensional picture of textile and garment enterprises

VCN - Despite a quite positive start in the first quarter of 2024, the textile and garment industry has still faced many challenges from new requirements of importing countries, requiring enterprises to have proactive solutions to respond.
Promoting Vietnamese pharmaceutical industry

Promoting Vietnamese pharmaceutical industry

Vietnamese pharmaceutical market grew from $2.7 billion in 2015 to $7 billion in 2022 and is forecast to reach more than $10 billion by 2026.

More News

HCM City to host iTech Expo 2024 in July

HCM City to host iTech Expo 2024 in July

The first-ever international technology exposition (iTech Expo) 2024 will take place in Ho Chi Minh from July 10-12, featuring 500 booths from leading technology countries and territories around the world, heard a press conference on May 20.
Pangasius exports are forecasted to bounce back at the end of the year

Pangasius exports are forecasted to bounce back at the end of the year

VCN - It is forecasted that pangasius exports is forecasted to be better from the third and fourth quarters of 2024, leading to the uptrend being adjusted to increase by at least about 10% compared to the current price.
Exports to the US reaches over US$6 billion

Exports to the US reaches over US$6 billion

VCN - The US continues to be Vietnam's largest export market and achieves positive growth.
Market diversification key for enterprises to expand exports

Market diversification key for enterprises to expand exports

Vietnamese enterprises need to meet quality requirements and rules of origin, increase value-added content, and diversify markets, as production and business activities are forecast to face many challenges due to the unpredictable global economy and climate change.
Businesses advised to focus on brand protection in online export

Businesses advised to focus on brand protection in online export

As more and more Vietnamese businesses are using international e-commerce platforms such as Amazon, eBay and Alibaba to expand market, experts have advised domestic firms to pay greater attention to the protection of trademark in the cyberspace, especially during online exporting activities.
Find solutions to attract goods through the first specialized container port in Vietnam

Find solutions to attract goods through the first specialized container port in Vietnam

VCN- As the first specialized container port in Vietnam with 25 years of operation, the volume of goods passing through the international container port of Vietnam (VICT) is still very modest. Mr. Truong Nguyen Linh, Deputy General Director of VICT port, has shared solutions to attract cargo through this port.
Textiles and footwear in a greening spiral

Textiles and footwear in a greening spiral

VCN - More and more regulations on sustainable development are issued in major markets such as the US and EU, imposing pressure on Vietnamese textile and garment enterprises to be faster on the green roadmap.
Agricultural, forestry and fishery product exports continue to "scoring points"

Agricultural, forestry and fishery product exports continue to "scoring points"

VCN - In the first four months of 2024, the country's total export turnover of agricultural, forestry and fishery products is estimated to reach more than US$19 billion, an increase of 23.7 percent compared to the same period last year. Most key agricultural and forestry export products increased higher than the same period last year as well as the export value to all markets increased.
Build and protect the rice value chain against market fluctuations

Build and protect the rice value chain against market fluctuations

VCN - Due to recent risks and challenges,business performancehave been badly hurt andmany chain links have been under threats ..., the rice industry needs to enhance the role of ministries, branches, localities, and farmers and businesses in building and protecting the rice value chain against market fluctuations.
Read More

Your care

Latest Most read
Imports and exports achieve US$239 billion by the end of April

Imports and exports achieve US$239 billion by the end of April

The import-export turnover in April witnessed a slight decrease compared to the previous month but it is still high with more than US$60 billion.
Spending more than US$31 billion for importing computers and electronic products in 4 months

Spending more than US$31 billion for importing computers and electronic products in 4 months

Computers, electronic products, and components are the group of imported commodities with the largest scale in the country.
Multi-dimensional picture of textile and garment enterprises

Multi-dimensional picture of textile and garment enterprises

VCN - The financial report of Thanh Cong Textile - Investment - Trading Joint Stock Company recorded revenue of more than VND 934 billion in the first quarter 2024, an increase of 7% compared to the same period in 2023; Net profit reached over VND 62 bill
Promoting Vietnamese pharmaceutical industry

Promoting Vietnamese pharmaceutical industry

Vietnamese pharmaceutical market grew from $2.7 billion in 2015 to $7 billion in 2022 and is forecast to reach more than $10 billion by 2026.
HCM City to host iTech Expo 2024 in July

HCM City to host iTech Expo 2024 in July

The first-ever international technology exposition (iTech Expo) 2024 will take place in Ho Chi Minh from July 10-12, featuring 500 booths from leading technology countries and territories around the world, heard a press conference on May 20.
Mobile Version