Amending regulations for proactive, responsible tax officials

VCN - Dr. Phan Hoai Nam, CEO of W&A Consulting, Member of the Association of Chartered Certified Accountants (ACCA), CPA Australia, and the Chartered Institute of Taxation (CIOT), discusses tax refund issues with Customs Magazine.
Dr. Phan Hoai Nam
Dr. Phan Hoai Nam

Could you share your assessment of the positive outcomes and limitations of the tax refund process in recent years?

In recent years, we have observed positive progress in the tax refund process. This is evident through strengthened tax management, a reduction in tax evasion, and increased revenue for the state budget. These results reflect the concerted efforts of both the tax system and the business community.

However, it is undeniable that delays in tax refunds still occur, as reported by businesses. These issues may arise from complex procedures, incomplete management systems, or delays from related parties, which have created challenges not only for businesses but also impacted the economy by raising business costs and disrupting cash flow.

To address these challenges, we must continue to streamline the tax refund process, simplify procedures, and enhance transparency in tax management. Furthermore, collaboration between businesses and tax authorities is crucial to resolving tax refund issues in an effective and transparent manner.

One key reason for tax refund delays is the presence of high-risk factors related to invoice fraud in tax refund dossiers. What is your assessment of this issue?

In my view, a major factor causing tax refund delays is the high risk of invoice fraud in refund applications. This can be seen in cases where companies declare illegal input invoices or engage in VAT fraud through invoicing schemes.

This issue not only slows down the verification and inspection process but also compromises transparency and fairness in the tax system. Additionally, it creates an unhealthy and unfair business environment, negatively impacting state revenue.

To combat this, we need to strengthen monitoring and inspection of business activities, particularly in sectors with high invoice fraud risks. Leveraging information technology and artificial intelligence could also help detect and prevent invoice fraud more effectively.

I believe that through close cooperation between the tax authorities and the business community, we can mitigate tax refund delays, improve cash flow management for businesses, and foster a healthier, more transparent, and fair business environment.

What recommendations would you offer to regulators and businesses in implementing solutions to accelerate tax refunds while ensuring no budget losses?

For regulatory bodies, I believe enhancing transparency and fostering consensus with businesses throughout the tax collection and refund process is essential. This can be achieved by improving procedures, simplifying processes, and using technology to optimize tax management. Regulatory authorities should also intensify monitoring and checks to effectively prevent invoice fraud.

Businesses, for their part, need to comply with tax policies and provide accurate, complete information to tax authorities. They should also conduct self-audits and review their tax refund documents to ensure the accuracy and legitimacy of their declared information.

The ongoing amendment to the VAT Law includes a proposal stating that 'Tax officials bear responsibility for issuing refunds in accordance with their duties, abiding by tax and tax management laws, based on documents provided by taxpayers and relevant information from authorized government bodies.' How do you foresee this proposal impacting the tax refund process if legislated?

The proposal to amend the VAT Law clarifies the responsibility of tax officials in the tax refund process. Under this draft, tax officials would not be criminally liable if they unknowingly process inaccurate or misleading information outside their purview. I see this as a step toward balancing legal responsibilities while enabling tax officials to perform their duties with greater professionalism, flexibility, and efficiency.

If enacted, this regulation could change tax officials’ approach to tax refunds. Rather than being overly cautious due to perceived risks, officials could proactively fulfill their duties with heightened responsibility, advancing administrative tax reform and supporting businesses better. Alleviating the mentality of 'no action, no error' would create a positive working environment and encourage initiative among tax officials.

However, it is crucial to ensure that the exclusion of criminal liability does not reduce diligence and transparency in tax officials' work. This is especially important as transparency and anti-fraud measures are increasingly emphasized. Establishing rigorous control and supervision mechanisms will be essential to ensure this regulation is implemented fairly and effectively.

Thank you very much for your insights!

By Thu Hiền/Thanh Thuy

Related News

Tax policies facilitate business development

Tax policies facilitate business development

VCN - Sharing with Customs News on the sidelines of the Tax and Legal Forum 2024 recently held, Deputy General Director, General Department of Taxation Dang Ngoc Minh (photo) said that the Government is researching and implementing new tax policies to support and facilitate business development in the time to come.
Amendments to the Value-Added Tax Law passed: Fertilizers to be taxed at 5%

Amendments to the Value-Added Tax Law passed: Fertilizers to be taxed at 5%

VCN - With the majority of National Assembly deputies voting in favor, the National Assembly officially approved the revised Value-Added Tax (VAT) Law during its afternoon session on November 26, 2024, as part of the 8th session's agenda.
Propose many solutions to shorten tax refund time

Propose many solutions to shorten tax refund time

VCN - Fully defining the duties and responsibilities of tax officials and having a mechanism to protect tax officials in tax refunds are breakthrough solutions being proposed to remove bottlenecks and barriers, speeding up the tax refund process in the coming time.
Tax refund applied for imported raw material serving for export production

Tax refund applied for imported raw material serving for export production

VCN - According to regulations, imported raw materials for production have paid import tax, when exporting products, if they meet all conditions, they will be refunded tax.

Latest News

Drastic measures needed to accelerate disbursement of foreign-funded public investment

Drastic measures needed to accelerate disbursement of foreign-funded public investment

Drastic measures are needed to remove roadblocks and accelerate the disbursement of foreign-funded public investment in the remaining months of this year, as the disbursement rate remains far below the target of 95 per cent, according to the Ministry of Finance.
Urging collection of land-related revenues in the last month of the year

Urging collection of land-related revenues in the last month of the year

VCN – In order to achieve the highest revenue target in the last month of 2024, creating momentum for the good implementation of socio-economic development tasks in 2025 and the period 2026 - 2030, the Prime Minister assigned the Ministry of Finance to promote revenue management solutions, strictly control tax assessment, tax declaration, tax payment, and collect arising revenues, especially revenues related to land.
Innovation and restructuring of state-owned enterprises: Start from institutions

Innovation and restructuring of state-owned enterprises: Start from institutions

VCN - The work of restructuring and innovating state-owned enterprises (SOEs) has had remarkable results in reducing quantity and improving quality, but is still behind schedule and the effectiveness is not commensurate with the resources.
Tax sector exceeds revenue target 2024

Tax sector exceeds revenue target 2024

VCN – Currently, the revenue managed by the Tax sector has reached VND1,538,000 billion, exceeding the 2024 estimate. This positive result was said by the leader of the General Department of Taxation at the Finance Forum “Financial policies to promote aggregate demand for economic development”.

More News

Stimulate production and business, submit to the National Assembly to continue reducing 2% VAT

Stimulate production and business, submit to the National Assembly to continue reducing 2% VAT

VCN - Reducing value added tax (VAT) has an impact on the decrease of state budget revenue but also stimulates production and promotes business activities, thereby contributing to creating more revenue for the state budget.
M&A in Vietnam expected to be bustling in 2025

M&A in Vietnam expected to be bustling in 2025

Merger and acquisition (M&A) activity in Vietnam is expected to be bustling again, thanks to the domestic economic recovery and higher foreign investment.
Major reforms in the management of state capital in enterprises

Major reforms in the management of state capital in enterprises

VCN - The draft Law on Management and Investment of State Capital in Enterprises is set to be presented and discussed at the National Assembly, featuring numerous new provisions after multiple rounds of public consultation. The draft law is expected to bring significant reforms to the operational framework for managing state capital and state-owned enterprises (SOEs).
Vietnam makes comprehensive strides in public financial management reform

Vietnam makes comprehensive strides in public financial management reform

VCN - Vietnam has achieved significant milestones in its public financial management (PFM) reforms, earning praise for its comprehensive progress across multiple areas, according to the latest Public Expenditure and Financial Accountability (PEFA) Report.
Central bank increases credit growth limit for banks for second time this year

Central bank increases credit growth limit for banks for second time this year

The State Bank of Vietnam (SBV) on November 28 announced it would increase credit growth target for credit institutions, for the second time this year.
Decree on the implementation of global minimum tax: Ensuring a clear and transparent legal framework

Decree on the implementation of global minimum tax: Ensuring a clear and transparent legal framework

VCN - The decree detailing the implementation of the global minimum tax must align with practical management requirements, ensuring a clear and transparent legal framework that enables businesses to comply with new tax regulations while safeguarding national interests, emphasized Dang Ngoc Minh, Deputy Director General of the General Department of Taxation.
Agree to continue reducing VAT by 2%

Agree to continue reducing VAT by 2%

VCN - National Assembly deputies all expressed their agreement with the policy of continuing reducing value-added tax (VAT) by 2% in the first half of 2025, but there needs to be an effective support policy for sustainable development of businesses.
Four challenges that put pressure on monetary policy management

Four challenges that put pressure on monetary policy management

VCN - According to the State Bank of Vietnam (SBV), monetary policy in the coming time will face many pressures, including the impacts of the international context and the continued implementation of the policy of reducing interest rates.
Legal basis to improve quality of price appraisal

Legal basis to improve quality of price appraisal

VCN - According to the representative of the Price Management Department, the regulations related to the activities of appraisers, adjusting the conditions for valuation practicing are new contents of the 2023 Price Law, contributing to improving the quality of valuation activities.
Read More

Your care

Latest Most read
Drastic measures needed to accelerate disbursement of foreign-funded public investment

Drastic measures needed to accelerate disbursement of foreign-funded public investment

Drastic measures are needed to remove roadblocks and accelerate the disbursement of foreign-funded public investment in the remaining months of this year, as the disbursement rate remains far below the target of 95 per cent, according to the Ministry of Finance.
Urging collection of land-related revenues in the last month of the year

Urging collection of land-related revenues in the last month of the year

VCN - Since the beginning of 2024, the macro-economic situation has been stable, growth has been promoted, major balances of the economy have been ensured, and the state revenue in the first 11 months of the year has reached 106.3% of the estimate.
Innovation and restructuring of state-owned enterprises: Start from institutions

Innovation and restructuring of state-owned enterprises: Start from institutions

The work of restructuring and innovating state-owned enterprises (SOEs) has had remarkable results in reducing quantity and improving quality, but is still behind schedule
Tax policies facilitate business development

Tax policies facilitate business development

VCN - Sharing with Customs News on the sidelines of the Tax and Legal Forum 2024 recently held, Deputy General Director, General Department of Taxation Dang Ngoc Minh (photo) said that the Government is researching and implementing new tax policies to sup
Tax sector exceeds revenue target 2024

Tax sector exceeds revenue target 2024

VCN - “These tax support policies have directly impacted the financial resources of enterprises, contributing to maintaining production and business and promoting consumption, thereby creating momentum for economic recovery and development,” said Minh.
Mobile Version